3 ms·
So Much for the Decentralized Internet
- kilo_bravo_3 6y agoI love the outsized importance applied to Twitter by journalists and news junkies who lazily rely on it. The vast, overwhelming, majority of human beings would not notice if Twitter had disappeared last night if it weren't for lazy journalists and news junkies reporting on its disappearance. Journalists writing about twitter remind me of novels about quirky authors, songs about musicians on the road, and movies about Hollywood: self-important inside baseball.
- kylebenzle 6y agoSo true. Whats funny, is a perfectly good decentralized option exists and works great but they wont use it because usability and security are not things they care about. They want to write short stories based on tweets.
- nix23 6y agoTrue, 5y ago it was Facebook and in 5y they relay on TikTok....lazy journalists...
- carterklein13 6y agoI'm not advocating for or against blockchain / DLT here, but I find it kind of weird that this article explicitly talks about not just the lack of decentralization in the modern internet, but about cryptocurrency... and doesn't mention the claims from DLT companies that they're fixing that. Ethereum is almost a household name as much as Bitcoin. IPFS is obviously more niche but if you were to spend an afternoon reading about blockchain you'd surely stumble upon it. I just find it odd that this article presents a very clear problem, but doesn't present the thousands of people working on hundreds of projects who passionately feel that they have a solution.
- artfulhippo 6y agoYour tech bubble mentality is leaking. Passionate feelings aren’t solutions. To date, Ethereum and IPFS have yet to provide value to regular people. The blockchain/DLT space is focused on financial infrastructure, and until scaling is solved (“6 months away”) it just isn’t relevant to a general audience. Ethereum is nowhere near the brand that Bitcoin is. Bitcoin at least enables people to commit crimes.
- nix23 6y ago>And Ethereum is nowhere near the brand that Bitcoin is. Wow and calling others out that they are in a bubble... >Bitcoin at least enables people to commit crimes. Like encryption, the internet and tor right?
- carterklein13 6y agoRefer back to my comment where I explicitly said that I'm not advocating for blockchain / DLT, nor did I say that Ethereum / IPFS provide any value. But, there are millions of dollars in investment and research being poured into these pieces of technology that attempt to address the problem stated in the article. I'm not saying they do or do not solve anything - my point was that it just struck me as odd that an article explicitly talking about crypto and the problems of centralization, didn't so much as mention that there are folks out there trying to fix it. It would be like saying "fracking is a problem" without mentioning any group that's trying to address that problem. It's pointing out a problem without a call to action. Whether or not that call will actually fix that problem is a different story.
- nix23 6y ago>nor did I say that Ethereum / IPFS provide any value. Not true: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15367531 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15367531 Bitcoin: https://www.coindesk.com/blackballed-by-paypal-scientific-paper-pirate-takes-bitcoin-donations https://www.coindesk.com/blackballed-by-paypal-scientific-pa... https://www.forbes.com/sites/rogerhuang/2019/04/26/how-bitcoin-and-wikileaks-saved-each-other/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/rogerhuang/2019/04/26/how-bitco...