6 ms·
> It's just a normal service like any other. Normal companies do that just fine. No, they don't. Like others have mentioned USPS delivers to anyone in the exte
by bmitc 6y ago
> It's just a normal service like any other. Normal companies do that just fine.
No, they don't. Like others have mentioned USPS delivers to anyone in the extended U.S. with sane prices. They also provide sane international shipping prices. USPS also provides other services like free shipping materials and free pickup. Hiding these and the other services they provide behind companies who only care about the bottom line would hurt people who couldn't afford the services or simply have services they're used to dropped.
- eru 6y agoIf you want to help people, it's more efficient to use a program that's financed by progressive taxes and targeted at the poor and needy. Instead of a hodge-podge that's financed by city dwellers who need to send a lot of letters, and assists people who chose to live in the middle of nowhere even if they are filthy rich. Yes, charging more to people who cause more costs would be exactly the point. (The poor people could use the targeted help I talked about to afford the higher price. Or they could use that help to buy something they need more than sending letters. Like food or nice clothing for an interview etc. Or whatever they fancy.)
- avianlyric 6y agoThere’s a wonderful irony in your suggestion. The current one-price-to-anywhere postal system originated because it is/was cheaper to provide a single flat price, than to compute a bespoke price for every letter dependant on its destination. Most original postal systems (and I’m primarily thinking of Royal Mail) started by charging depending on distance a letter would travel. I’m not sure your system of progressive taxes and rebates, and the needed administrative infrastructure would be cheaper than operating a flat price system. Especially in a country like the US which doesn’t have a large well developed welfare system that already performs these types of assessments.
- eru 6y agoThe US already has progressive income taxes and a welfare system. About postal sytems, the first was probably the private London Penny Post https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/London_Penny_Post https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/London_Penny_Post As the name implies, sending letters cost a penny flat.
- avianlyric 6y agoThe London Penny Post only delivered in London. You can’t really compare it USPS or Royal Mail that deliver to every nook-and-cranny of an entire country, regardless of how wet, dry or frozen over said nook-and-cranny maybe. > The US already has progressive income taxes and a welfare system. The current pandemic is demonstrating how woefully under-equipped that system is, I don’t think your proposed expansion would help much.
- eru 6y agoYes, the London Penny post was merely the first. The concept got more properly developed later.
- avianlyric 6y agoI’m a little confused, what point are you trying to make with the London Penny Post? It supports the ideas of flat pricing, something you said you don’t support. It also not even close to the first postal company, Royal Mail was incorporated almost a hundred years before.
- eru 6y agoI said I am against making flat pricing or universal coverage a legal requirement. I'm not against any company implementing a flat pricing scheme or universal coverage. > It also not even close to the first postal company, Royal Mail was incorporated almost a hundred years before. The London Penny Post was an important early innovator, and privately owned. "The new Penny Post was influential in establishing a model system and pattern for the various Provincial English Penny Posts in the years that followed. It was the first postal system to use hand-stamps to postmark the mail to indicate the place and time of the mailing and that its postage had been prepaid. The success of the Penny Post would also threaten the interests of the Duke of York who profited directly from the existing general post office. It also compromised the business interests of porters and private couriers." "Before the emergence of the Penny Post the profits of the existing General Post Office were assigned by Parliament in 1663 to the Duke of York, who now had similar designs on Dockwra's lucrative Penny Post. As the Penny Post proved to be a great success and a potential new source of constant revenue the English government and the Duke of York at the time fined Dockwra £100 for contempt, claiming it infringed the monopoly of the General Post Office, and took control of the Penny Post's operations in 1682, bringing that enterprise to an end.[3] Less than a month later the London Penny Post was made a branch of the General Post Office. For compensation of his losses Dockwra obtained a pension of £500 a year after the Revolution of 1688." The Penny Post successfully competed with the Royal Mail. And then the government took over the cash cow.
- michaelt 6y agoUniversal mail delivery isn't just about helping the poor and needy. It's also about allowing the government to deliver services efficiently. The government has an obligation to send every citizen voter registration cards, census forms, driving licenses, tax forms, firearms registration forms, passports and so on. The alternatives - an IRS office in every backwater town, denying a vote to people living in remote areas, ATF agents delivering gun permits in person, denying driving licenses to people without a home internet connection - would either be more expensive, or less constitutional. Unless UPS or FedEx wanted to take on a universal service obligation, of course...
- eru 6y agoThe German government manages to send those forms out just fine, despite them privatising Deutsche Post and eventually abolishing their letter monopoly.
- michaelt 6y agoDeutsche Post has flat-rate pricing within Germany - unlike your proposal that mail to and from remote locations should cost more. So I'm not sure how that example supports your argument?
- eru 6y agoMy proposal is that companies should be allowed to charge different amounts. Not that they should. What pricing scheme they want to use is up to them to decide.
- cmurf 6y agoWhat they decide is to not service large areas of the country. This also happens with internet service. Without government enforced rate setting and subsidies, rural areas would have very expensive roads, water, electricity, and phone service - even unaffordable.
- 6y ago
- tehwebguy 6y agoYou are making points that seem relevant but aren’t. We don’t want a market normalized mail shipping price, we want a reasonable enough price that allows every single resident to send and receive mail. It’s far more important that the lowest income residents can send and receive mail. Also, the same people who want to privatize USPS are the ones who don’t want subsidies or payments to the poor at all. Killing this would be done in exchange for nothing, not as part of a reform bill that targets help toward those that need it.
- eru 6y agoJust give the lowest income residents some money. They can use that to purchase mail delivery services on the market. (Or purchase other things they might like better.)
- tehwebguy 6y agoHow would it help to throw away the benefit of the scale of USPS while driving FedEx & UPS prices through the roof? Would this come with a mandate for the duopoly to service every household in the US? The retail rate for sending a letter via FedEx & UPS is currently over 30 times the retail rate for USPS ($0.55 vs > $20)
- missedthecue 6y agoPoor comparison. FedEx and UPS cannot ship first class mail. It is literally against the law. The USPS has a monopoly on first class mail, no one else can do it, so you cannot compare costs.
- eru 6y agoYes. FedEx is only legally allowed to ship 'extremely urgent mail'. Not regular 'first class mail'. So their costs are going to be higher.
- missedthecue 6y agoSay the stamp costs double and it now costs a dollar to mail an envelope instead of 50 cents. No one is priced out of mailing a letter, and we are in a better position s the net benefit is better off (total cost is lower than the previous total cost)
- ekianjo 6y agoThen why postal services in most countries have a monopoly still? If they are so good at what they are doing by all means let it be known on a real market place. Guess what, they will fight tooth and nail so that competition for regular mail does not happen. I love how people on HN complain about monopolies in tech but find it absolutely OK to have monopolies in other walks of life. In Japan you have heavy competition for package deliveries and the former National post gets trashed when it comes to reliability and speed vs Sagawa or Yamato.
- eru 6y ago> I love how people on HN complain about monopolies in tech but find it absolutely OK to have monopolies in other walks of life. Because democracy is magic?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cwhiz 6y ago> USPS delivers to anyone in the extended U.S. with sane prices. They are able to do this by overcharging for local mail and absurdly undercharging for rural mail. Just another in the never ending list of ways that dense areas subsidize less dense areas. But the kicker is the less dense areas are the ones who would vote to privatize the USPS. So I say give them what they want.
- soulofmischief 6y agoThat's how comprehensive pricing works, yes. Are you similarly angry that healthcare plans operate this way?
- cwhiz 6y agoI'm not angry about either. I am in favor of giving people what they want. Look at who supports the postal service and who doesn't. There will be no downsides for me if the postal service goes away. The people who want it to go away must have considered the downsides and still don't care. Why would I want to get in the way?
- eru 6y agoYou should be! There's a difference between insurance and cross subsidies. Insurance is basically a bet. If I have deep enough pockets and some actuary tables, I can write you a single insurance policy. And I can expect to make money of that single policy on average. (But in the specifics, I might have to pay out.) No need for a group that cross subsidizes each other.
- tehwebguy 6y agoThe duopoly of private shippers charge more than 30x for letter delivery within the US (and still substantially more than USPS for most package services) and those prices are surely as low as they are because USPS drives them down.
- jccooper 6y agoUSPS has a legal monopoly on letter service, save for "extremely urgent material". All private document delivery must therefore be Express-class. It's not reasonable to compare FexEx Express to USPS First Class. USPS Express and FedEx Overnight for documents are essentially the same price, even though FedEx has a higher standard of service. (Which is not surprising, because FedEx runs the backbone of USPS Express.) FedEx and UPS parcel prices generally beat USPS above a certain fairly small weight, even at retail prices. I'm happy to have USPS around, and I do a lot of business with them as they're the better option in certain circumstances, but let's not pretend their pricing is particularly magical.
- leesalminen 6y agoI live in rural America and USPS doesn’t deliver to my house because I live on a dirt road. UPS, FedEx, DHL and OnTrac all deliver just fine.
- hundchenkatze 6y agoAre you the only house on that road? I know a rural mail carrier and a large portion of their customers live on dirt roads and they deliver to them. However, they won't deliver packages to your door if you're the only house on the road and it's over a certain distance.
- leesalminen 6y agoNo, there’s plenty of houses on the road. We fall into the “distance” category. We’re 1.1 miles from the end of the pavement. I believe they use an OR operator in that decision and not an AND. They won’t deliver if you’re the only house on the road OR if you’re over a certain distance from a paved road.