11 ms·
Knowing Nintendo, they probably don't have a way to revoke the licenses. They're not very good at the online thing, or the digital store thing. Their core compe
by echelon 6y ago
Knowing Nintendo, they probably don't have a way to revoke the licenses. They're not very good at the online thing, or the digital store thing. Their core competency is in hardware and games, and the rest of the org just sort of gets dragged along for the ride.
If it's as I hypothesize and they can't revoke software licenses, I think their stance is reasonable from the perspective that this could be used to acquire all the games for free. But I think they should be compelled to fix this going forward.
- octodog 6y agoThat's not reasonable at all. If their product doesn't work, you are entitled to a refund. Whether or not their systems allow them to refund you in a manner that _suits them_ is irrelevant.
- the8472 6y ago> If their product doesn't work, you are entitled to a refund. Or a fix?
- hugh-avherald 6y agoIf the product doesn't work (at all), you are entitled to a refund. You are also entitled to a fix/replacement, but it's the consumer's choice. Hinges on whether the product has a "major failure" or a (lesser) defect.
- Benjamin_Dobell 6y agoI've no doubt what you've written is the case. However, incompetence is rarely an admissible defense for breaking the law.
- retSava 6y agoI think having it forced upon them to refund games would be a great motivator to implement any such missing mechanism. I think companies in general gets too much of a free pass when it comes to their responsibilities and too much of free reign when it comes to what they can do when they claim their rights. For example, if I'm late with a payment for a product, the punishment is by default going to be of the "eff you, pay us"-kind, while the opposite often ends up in the "oopsie, my bad you had to wait a few months for that refund, and had to cancel the sub by fax". I really think consumer laws in general should be improved and enforced more. Pretty happy with those in Sweden, although many (also big) brands try to sneak their way out of them.
- MaxBarraclough 6y ago> If it's as I hypothesize and they can't revoke software licenses, I think their stance is reasonable from the perspective that this could be used to acquire all the games for free. Doesn't sound reasonable to me. The law doesn't cease to apply when a business finds compliance to be inconvenient. At least, it shouldn't.
- squiggleblaz 6y agoIndeed. "If it's as I hypothesise and they can't afford a loaf of bread, I think their stance is reasonable from the perspective that this could be used to starve them to death" You can always tell if something is reasonable by changing it from a company screwing an individual into an individual screwing a company. If an individual hurts a company to survive, we normally see that is illegal quite quickly. It's only when a company hurts an individual in order to make a profit that we struggle.
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoI'm not sure I see the value in that. My point was about consistent enforcement of laws that are on the books. Stealing to avoid starvation, is a very different moral question.