4 ms·
This is interesting. The allegation is that Google didn't properly notify users about combining Doubleclick and other Google data. Google did run a popup notif
by nl 6y ago
This is interesting. The allegation is that Google didn't properly notify users about combining Doubleclick and other Google data.
Google did run a popup notification about the change, but:
The ACCC alleges that the “I agree” notification was misleading, because consumers could not have properly understood the changes Google was making nor how their data would be used, and so did not - and could not - give informed consent.
It's not exactly clear what the ACCC is saying here? Is it that Google didn't explain it enough, or is it that no amount of explanation is enough because user's "could not give informed consent"?
- Khaine 6y agoFrom the ACCC website “I agree” notification The conduct is alleged to have impacted millions of Australians with Google accounts. From 28 June 2016 until at least December 2018, Google account holders were prompted to click “I agree” to a pop-up notification from Google that purported to explain how it planned to combine their data, and sought the consumers’ consent for this. Some new features for your Google Account We’ve introduced some optional features for your account, giving you more control over the data Google collects and how it’s used, while allowing Google to show you more relevant ads. The notification also stated, “More information will be available in your Google Account making it easier for you to review and control”; and “Google will use this information to make ads across the web more relevant for you.” Not sure how you can provide informed consent, when the notification is so vague
- nl 6y agoIf you scroll down they include screenshots, which have diagrams including how the data flows, and additional text. It's quite a lot of information. Hard to know what the appropriate level here is, but Google sure did a lot more than just saying what the text said.
- IncRnd 6y agoYou bring up a great point. If people don't understand the ACCC's statement, then people didn't understand the less informative Google popup notification.
- manicdee 6y agoGiven the information available to the user there is simply no way to understand what is being done. You might be able to guess or use insider knowledge to film in the blanks but someone who is not a Google employee in a privileged position can’t put those pieces together. Plus there is an element of duress since Google is changing the rules for access to a service that the user has come to rely on.
- nl 6y ago> Given the information available to the user there is simply no way to understand what is being done. You might be able to guess or use insider knowledge to film in the blanks but someone who is not a Google employee in a privileged position can’t put those pieces together. Did you scroll down and look at the screenshots of the popup Google used? There's a lot more information they provide to the user.
- manicdee 6y agoNot enough. What are the penalties for entities misusing my information provided to them by Google?
- shakna 6y agoThat statement from the ACCC says that informed consent cannot be reached as Google spelled out neither the changes, nor how the data would be used. It doesn't actually go into the question of how much information is needed for informed consent, just that as things happened, there was not enough. Informed consent itself actually has a legal definition in regards to the laws the ACCC acts upon, so it might be useful to spell that one out as well: > Informed consent means that a person: > a) is provided with appropriate and adequate information > b) is capable of understanding the nature of the information and the consequences of a decision made in relation to this information > c) can freely make decisions without unfair pressure or influence from others.