6 ms·
> Jeff hoped not only that he would get that dream job with Nasa, but that the organisation would start to work with the USSR rather than competing with it. >
by dehrmann 6y ago
> Jeff hoped not only that he would get that dream job with Nasa, but that the organisation would start to work with the USSR rather than competing with it.
> "Even when I was fairly young, I could see the potential for collaboration between the US and Soviet Union," he says. "It just never made sense to me that we were pointing nuclear weapons at each other, when we could be collaborating to do extraordinary things in space."
Oh, kids. Nasa's raison d'etre was to research how the US can watch the soviets from space or shoot them from space. That's why its budget peaked in '66. Doing "extraordinary things in space" was just a means to that end. But I do appreciate the sentiment.
- rorykoehler 6y agoThe world would be a much better place if curiosity was the main driver instead of power.
- jedmeyers 6y agoAs long as you have limited resources to manage, your curiosity will go nowhere without the power to obtain resources to satisfy that curiosity. I too love to dream about how great life is going to be once we all have unlimited resources.
- rorykoehler 6y agoWe have more than enough to go around and we have for a long time.
- Judgmentality 6y agoDo we? Fresh water isn't unlimited - in fact much farming today is done unsustainably by pumping ground water faster than it can be replenished. Desalination plants are expensive and not necessarily viable. Oil is obviously limited, and while there are energy alternatives it's not quite that simple. Not to mention the abundant use of petroleum in every day items we take for granted such as plastic. Sure, we can imagine a world without oil, but right now that world does not exist. Land is limited. Minerals are limited. Medicine can be limited (I'm fairly certainly whoever develops a vaccine will find it used nationally much more densely than internationally until it is ubiquitous).
- arcticbull 6y ago> Fresh water isn't unlimited... Yep, but we have more than enough for the time being. > ... in fact much farming today is done unsustainably by pumping ground water faster than it can be replenished. Yes, however a lot of that is done to produce products that are unnecessary (a single almond requires 1.1 gallons of water to produce), a political exercise (40% of all US corn is grown for Ethanol, which produces more carbon emissions than it saves), or otherwise in support of our largesse (49% of all US corn is grown for animal feed). > Oil is obviously limited, and while there are energy alternatives it's not quite that simple. Not to mention the abundant use of petroleum in every day items we take for granted such as plastic. Sure, we can imagine a world without oil, but right now that world does not exist. Substantially less oil would be consumed for power, making it available for plastics, etc, if we actually invested in nuclear, wind and solar. The amount consumed for the manufacture of plastics is pretty limited and plant-based alternatives are coming to the fore. > Land is limited. Minerals are limited. The density of the US is 94 people per square mile, with more than enough minerals to go around. There's effectively no limit to how far up you can build in a metropolis if the city council chooses to permit it (see: San Francisco vs. Miami, Houston). > Medicine can be limited (I'm fairly certainly whoever develops a vaccine will find it used nationally much more densely than internationally until it is ubiquitous). Medicine is always going to be limited, the question is how we choose to ration it -- based on luck (aka free market capitalism, to whomever can afford it) or based on need (via socialized scheme). > Food... Consider that America wastes 40% of all the food it produces -- 80 billion pounds of food per year -- enough to feed the entire rest of the planet. [1] There is enough to go around, we just choose not to let it. [1] https://www.rts.com/resources/guides/food-waste-america/ https://www.rts.com/resources/guides/food-waste-america/
- Judgmentality 6y ago> with more than enough minerals to go around I think we actually agree on most things except for this. China is hoarding rare Earth minerals, mostly the kind you need to develop batteries to transition away from our dependency on oil. https://www.forbes.com/sites/kensilverstein/2019/07/10/china-has-a-powerful-trade-weapon-rare-earths-used-in-green-energy-products/#808b2034e4c1 https://www.forbes.com/sites/kensilverstein/2019/07/10/china... So no, we absolutely do not have enough minerals to go around, at least if you want to transition to alternative energy resources.
- srean 6y agoThe problem word is 'enough'. For some its never that, how much ever they might have. It not an unnatural phenomena. Biological cells sometimes do that too.
- rorykoehler 6y agoWe need therapy for people like that. I understand where it comes from but it doesn't align with contemporary pressures.
- chongli 6y agoThere will never be unlimited resources. The earth has a finite amount of space, minerals, water, and energy (mostly from the sun). Even if we gained access to exoplanets the problem would still remain. People can and will continue to demand more. Individuals will stake claim to entire planets for their own. The problem is that satisfaction comes from relative success, not absolute. Look at folks like Bezos and Musk. The only thing that will slow them down is aging and eventual death.
- alasdair_ 6y agoMusk has set a very clear end goal for his ambitions, unlike any other billionaire I can think of. He wants to make humanity become an interplanetary species. That’s the goal. Not power for power’s sake, but to accomplish a specific thing. Which is, of course, not to say that power doesn’t corrupt and that once he hits his goal, he won’t want more, but for now at least, he has a specific aim.
- loceng 6y agoPower isn't the main driver, it's the desired outcome however. The main drivers would be control to be able to maintain a certain status or behaviour - arguably that you can't maintain due to what society deems is acceptable or that you couldn't lawfully gain ethically/legally.
- indymike 6y agoThe ability to control other's behavior is called power.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- loceng 6y agoPeople want that power for a reason, there's an underlying reason - that reason is the driver.
- dTal 6y agoAre you sure? 1984 asserts otherwise, that those who seek absolute power do it for its own sake. It certainly seems plausible that people who seek power for its own sake will do so with more consistency than people who have an ulterior motive.
- wnscooke 6y agoIf only the other side felt the same way.
- harimau777 6y agoI did an internship at NASA and found them to be very motivated by curiosity and a desire to educate the public. Granted this was long after the Cold War ended and it may represent a difference between the motivations of the people who work for NASA and the motivations of the politicians who fund NASA.
- dehrmann 6y agoThe end of the Cold War definitely changed things. We even have an ISS, now.
- dehrmann 6y agoThe other part is that if you've work in a large R&D org, you know that doubling the size of an organization definitely doesn't 4x the velocity or magnitude of work and discoveries. It doesn't even 2x it. It's more like 1.25x-1.5x. Competition might also be a better driver of innovation that cooperation.
- tim333 6y agoStill Nasa got to work with Soyuz space launches to the ISS which is sort of along those lines even if the USSR had collapsed by then.
- rurban 6y agoBut at least they turned one of those 5 Hubble telescopes around, and instead of reading Russian car plates they are now fotographing deep space.