4 ms·
The author made a fundamental mistake of judgement. So far, what he says amount to an advocacy against digital signing of code as such. Miikka Koskinen says "
by baybal2 6y ago
The author made a fundamental mistake of judgement.
So far, what he says amount to an advocacy against digital signing of code as such.
Miikka Koskinen says "digital signing doesn't work, so, lets decide to use something even more broken." Just that alone makes me think he has no say on this.
- derefr 6y agoNah. He said that the current infrastructure for signing JARs is broken, making supplying signed JARs pointless. He didn’t say that this is the way things should be. He advised, at the end, fixing the system; but it is implicit in his tone that he doesn’t expect anyone to try—it’s been broken this long with nobody caring, so why would that change now? And yes, he advised relying on other mechanisms for verification, for the time being. Because those mechanisms provide nonzero (if small) security, while the current infrastructure for JAR signing provides zero security. (Compare: “if calling the police does nothing, at least carry pepper spray.” This advice does not imply that pepper spray is better than effective police response; only better than an ineffective one. It also does not imply that one should not seek police reform. It only suggests what one should do while the condition of “ineffective police response” still holds.) At the end, he says: > I’ve written this post in part to be proven wrong. I’m eagerly waiting for posts from y’all about how you do, in fact, systematically verify the signatures. One would presume that, if he were proven wrong, and the digital signatures Of JAR files actually did anything, he would retract this post and post one giving the opposite advice.