3 ms·
> the phones got thinner No. They didn't. iPhone 5: 7.6 mm thin, 6: 7 mm iPhone 7: 7.1 mm > While Apple could likely have gotten their water resistance even
by formerly_proven 6y ago
> the phones got thinner
No. They didn't.
iPhone 5: 7.6 mm thin, 6: 7 mm
iPhone 7: 7.1 mm
> While Apple could likely have gotten their water resistance even with the headphone jack, they couldn’t have made the phones as thin.
Except that's a pretty obvious lie. Not just that the phones did not get thinner (or lighter), they stayed around the same thickness (+- 0.5 mm), while getting larger, much heavier and much more expensive. But also the thinnest Android phone with a 3.5 mm jack is just 5.1 mm thick, for example. Sony even made a waterproof phone that's 6.5 mm thin and still has a 3.5 mm jack, which is thinner than any iPhone ever.
Everything about this argumentation is wrong or an outright lie. The only reason they did this is because they could moneygrab through accessoires better when they eliminate standardized I/O.
- joshspankit 6y agoI would argue the the camera “bump” means that the phone is not actually thinner anyway. Honesty means measuring thickness by it’s thickest point.
- joshspankit 6y agoIt would be very straightforward as well to simply come up with a new thinner analog headphone jack: maybe something balanced and with a magnetic connector since we’re at it?
- dangoor 6y agoThank you! I stand corrected. It looks like the reason most cited, in hindsight, for Apple removing it was to pave the way for a design without bezels and with more speakers https://screenrant.com/why-apple-removed-the-headphone/ https://screenrant.com/why-apple-removed-the-headphone/ https://bgr.com/2017/10/06/pixel-2-headphone-jack-iphone-x-design/ https://bgr.com/2017/10/06/pixel-2-headphone-jack-iphone-x-d... Which is, indeed, a very different reason.
- jdkdodo 6y agoThe only reason? Doesn’t shallow dismissive posting violate comment rules here? It’s almost as if “every argument I make about frugalness and standards is maybe leading me to ignore other considerations.” “Pros” continue to make use of their wired kit, and it changes the math of recurring waste problem; I’ve thrown away many fewer pairs of $30 earbuds since iPhone 7. Saved money and generated less consumer waste over the long run. Now scale that up to the iPhone user base. You seem to believe human agency must be functionally fixed on how we used to do things. Or at least how you have been lead to believe we did. Turns out iterating away through new invention is how we do things. Or do you have your wax cylinders ready? And for people that want a wire a 2” dongle is available. Given all else they get with a life that affords an iPhone, oofda what a stretch. Let’s get to the back of the line with our first world sour grapes a bit. I can see how broader utility was enabled in a variety of ways. Sorry you haven’t been able to cope with, really, such a trivial change in 5 years.
- formerly_proven 6y ago> Doesn’t shallow dismissive posting violate comment rules here? Despite being aware of this, you went on to create a posting that's largely assumptions, projections and some salty ad-hominem. > Sorry you haven’t been able to cope with, really, such a trivial change in 5 years. I haven't upgraded my phone in a number of years, so it actually still has a headphone jack, which I virtually never use since I don't listen to music on the go.
- hanche 6y agoThe explanation/excuse I recall seeing, was about space, not thickness. The headphone jack takes up space inside the phone that they’d rather put to other uses, like more battery for example. At least, that seems to make a bit more sense.
- formerly_proven 6y agoYes it does. I think back then teardown pictures made the rounds where the innards of the two generations where virtually the same, except they added some component where the headphone jack used to be. And as far as smartphone components go, a 3.5 mm jack is pretty big; I'd guess about the volume of a camera module. I don't know who started the thinness-jack meme, I suspect it was an explanation made up by people other than Apple, since Apple is usually more into omitting things instead of lying.