2 ms·
Note that this convert H2O, CO2, energy -> fuel Water is free [1], Carbon Dioxide is free [2]. Energy is never free. You need some big solar panels or a nucl
by gus_massa 6y ago
Note that this convert
H2O, CO2, energy -> fuel
Water is free [1], Carbon Dioxide is free [2]. Energy is never free.
You need some big solar panels or a nuclear reactor to get the energy. (Can you put a wind turbine in a ship?) (The usual trick of burning fuel to produce energy is not a good idea here.) So this kind of process should not be interpreted as "water -> fuel" but like "energy -> fuel".
It can be useful to store energy for a while, or producing fuel using a nuclear reactor in the carrier and using the fuel in the planes. (I'm not sure that this is economical or tactically a good idea.)
If the idea is to produce the fuel on land, it is much more efficient to sell the energy and buy fuel. The energy you sell will cause a electric plant that use carbon to close and the net effect will be bigger reduction of the CO2 level.
From the article:
> Laboratory team led by Heather Willauer announced it had used a catalytic converter to extract carbon dioxide and hydrogen from seawater and then converted the gases into liquid hydrocarbons at a 92 percent efficiency rate.
I really doubt this. Organic reactions have a horrible low efficiency, specially the ones that create complex molecules using simple ones. (Perhaps the 92% efficiency is counting how many of the CO2 are converted, but the most important part of this reaction is the energy. If it convert the 92% of the CO2, but it stores only the 1% of the energy, it is very wasteful.)
[1] Processing water to avoid the problems with salt and tartar may be a big problem, so it may not be so easy.
[2] But the concentration is usually low, that is generally bad for fast and efficient reactions.
- guerrilla 6y agoThanks for the details. On the other hand, doesn't this incentivize carbon capture by making the cost of energy storage just energy?
- jjoonathan 6y agoIn terms of energy, it's not a contest and it's not a hangup. Carriers are already powered by nuclear reactors. They have about 1500MW of steam power available as a matter of course. Compare to 25MW if you paved the flight surfaces with solar panels and parked it at the equator on a sunny day with perfectly calm seas and measured at noon. Unlike solar in this example, the nuclear design is not bumping up against physical constraints and could be scaled up quite dramatically if there was a compelling reason to do so. Fuel production would be a compelling reason. The chemistry and chemical engineering problems you point out are the major hangups.