3 ms·
It seems to me that pseudo-science requires a pseudo-scientist. I don't know anything more about Carlson than your link suggests, but scientist doesn't seem to
by ncmncm 6y ago
It seems to me that pseudo-science requires a pseudo-scientist. I don't know anything more about Carlson than your link suggests, but scientist doesn't seem to be in the list.
Graham Hancock certainly makes no pretense of being a scientist. He is a mythographer, forthright about seeking evidence for a factual basis of received myth. Unusually among writers in his genre, in print he is very careful to distinguish established fact from speculation.
But I am still trying to understand your implication about the O-18 data. The graph encompassing the YD period showing a period of sharply lower temperature is commonplace. Are you saying that should be interpreted, instead, as a sharp increase in terrestrial water retention at YD onset, followed by a sharp reduction at the end, rather than a change in temperature? What do you interpret as might cause such retention?
Or does it, instead, refer to a change in the rate of release of terrestrial water to the ocean, pausing for millennia, then resuming at the end?
Thank you for your patience. This is not my field.
- sradman 6y agoThe Younger Dryas (YD) delta-O-18 changes are most extreme in the Greenland ice core values; the result of precipitation from Atlantic surface evaporation. There are multiple variables that influence this value like 1. Sea Surface Temperature, 2. delta-O-18 of the surface water, and 3. distance from source to destination (how monsoon data is extracted from Asian cave stalactites). The YD was initiated by massive meltwater pulses. Depending on the fluid dynamics of freshwater mixing in the Atlantic, the early YD should logically result in delta-O-18 spikes due to the influx of freshwater. The meltwater pulses are not caused by sudden temperature spikes though it is plausible that the freshwater influx disrupts the major Atlantic currents and has localized temperature impacts. YD-style spikes occur after each glacial termination in the era of 100-ky glacial cycles as seen in the LR04 data set; parallel meltwater pulse events every 100 ky. You are correct, the graphs showing sharply lower temperatures are common and these graphs are technically correct because they are plotting delta-temperature-“equivalents”, but drastic changes can be the result of freshwater changes alone at a constant temperature.