4 ms·
Makes sense to me, and should be done in the US as well. Providing a tax exemption is in a way the opposite of a separation of church and state. The state is
by colordrops 6y ago
Makes sense to me, and should be done in the US as well. Providing a tax exemption is in a way the opposite of a separation of church and state. The state is giving them special treatment.
- ekianjo 6y agoIn Japan post temples are clearly for profit operations (charging people outrageous amounts of money for about anything) and they are also not taxed by the government. Which is why you have a plethora of sects.
- NotSammyHagar 6y agoYes, it's obvious that a religion gets special treatment over say a club and it is unneeded.
- xupybd 6y agoHow about tax exemptions for clubs too. If it's a group of people pooling money for non commercial activities why should that be taxed?
- seesawtron 6y agoAs long as clubs give free entry, sounds reasonable to me that club dancing would be considered a social, community-like activity to bring people closer to each other (literally too) and make them feel joyful.
- alasdair_ 6y agoBecause people exploit the rules massively (the Church of Scientology is one example of many). More importantly: these religious buildings still call the police when there is a break in and call the fire service when there is a fire. They expect all of the benefits from paying taxes without actually doing so.
- olliej 6y agoThese sound like property taxes, but that aside, your example could register itself as a non profit organization. The important distinction between non-profits and churches in the US is that churches do not have to demonstrate that they aren’t a just a profit generating company (see Scientology, many evangelical churches) - they don’t have to provide any documentation at all. I’m fine with churches being untaxed non-profits, as long as they actually demonstrate that.
- morelisp 6y agoFormalized clubs do get some tax benefits. Most people are only familiar with 501(c)(3)s but there are many kinds of 501(c)s; specific tax benefits and allowed behavior to maintain them vary. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/501(c)_organization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/501(c)_organization
- ars 6y ago> Yes, it's obvious that a religion gets special treatment over say a club That isn't true. Non-profits are not taxed either.
- seesawtron 6y agoAre there any countries where the religious groups are NOT exempt from taxes? I'd be curious if this has been done and those religious groups still managed to remain "open to public" while surviving on private donations.
- laurencerowe 6y agoBritain nationalised church property during the reformation.
- skissane 6y agoIt is more complex than that. The Church of England started out as the English branch of the Roman Catholic Church. In that form, it was scarcely a private body – it was the state religion, intimately entwined with the state, with the power to levy taxes, and it ran its own court system with jurisdiction over issues which today would be viewed as essentially secular in character (validity of marriages; inheritance of personal property; crimes committed by clergy), and the state would recognise and enforce that court system's decisions. The property of such a state religion is hardly "private property", it is arguably "public property". For centuries, the King and Pope had intermittently fought over control of it (a situation not unique to England, but repeated across mediaeval Europe). Henry VIII did not see himself as carrying out a state takeover of the Church, but simply as settling that traditional conflict between Pope and King decisively in his own favour.
- solresol 6y agoTo put this in perspective, in Switzerland your employer takes your church donations out of your salary. Your taxes directly fund the church. _That's_ the opposite of separation of church and state. In the USA, tax deductions to churches is giving the same treatment as a charity.
- colordrops 6y agoDo churches not use US infrastructure and services? We are implicitly taxed on behalf of churches.
- alpaca128 6y agoBoth are wrong. Churches should prove they act as non-profits just like any other organisation. Because especially in the US a lot do not exactly oppose profits.
- Svip 6y agoCharity organisations usually get tax exemptions too. Maybe make that the only tax exemption, and have religious organisations prove that they are charities.
- skissane 6y agoUnder English common law, religious organisations are charities by definition. A charitable trust is a trust which serves a "charitable purpose", and the "advancement of religion" has long been recognised as a charitable purpose, going back to at least 1601 [1]. (Originally all charities were trusts, and so charity law formed part of trust law; later, people began using other legal structures for charities, and the rules which defined a charity in trust law were extended to apply in those other cases too.) Most jurisdictions which inherited English common law, have maintained the classification of "advancement of religion" as a charitable end. To give just one example, look at how the IRS defines "charity" in the US [2] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charitable_trusts_in_English_law#Charitable_purpose https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charitable_trusts_in_English_l... [2] https://www.irs.gov/charities-non-profits/charitable-purposes https://www.irs.gov/charities-non-profits/charitable-purpose...
- lightgreen 6y agoThey don’t have to be charities. It should be enough if they are nonprofit (which most churches are I hope).
- Galaxeblaffer 6y agoNo one really knows since they don't have to tell anyone how they get money or how they spend them
- lightgreen 6y agoIt doesn’t matter because in order to get nonprofit status they’d need to fill some forms explaining how it is managed, financial statements, maybe perform external audit if they are large enough etc. If they are not willing to do that work, they won’t be eligible for nonprofit tax exemption.
- ars 6y ago> The state is giving them special treatment. No it's not. All non-profits are untaxed. If you are going to charge churches, then charge all non-profits. Personally I think that's a bad policy.
- thefounder 6y agoMany churches are not non-profits. In fact they have quite big profits.
- GreenWatermelon 6y agoand many are not. so the right thing is to evaluate them on case by case basis.
- thefounder 6y agoThey should just register as charities. No more special cases.
- ars 6y agoIf you check the law that's exactly what already happens. https://www.thebalancesmb.com/are-there-advantages-to-being-a-faith-based-nonprofit-2501882 https://www.thebalancesmb.com/are-there-advantages-to-being-... "There are no direct legal benefits associated with being identified as an FBO."
- lazyasciiart 6y agoThat's because it's a legally meaningless phrase. Being a church, however, is legally different and gets benefits like not having to register before claiming charitable status.
- pravda 6y agoBut non-profits have to pay property tax, right? I don't think religious institutions have to pay property taxes. Ok, I looked it up: “states subsidize religions to the tune of about $26.2 billion per year by not requiring religious institutions to pay property taxes for property worth about $600 billion. This subsidy is of particular interest because property taxes pay for services such as firefighting and police, which religious institutions use the same as corporations and private citizens.”
- skissane 6y agoThe article makes clear that churches in Montreal are still getting their tax exemption if they stick to purely religious activities (prayer, worship, etc). They are only being taxed when they use their property for not explicitly religious activities like charitable uses, community groups, etc. Do those people applauding this really want to applaud a policy that gives tax exemptions to specifically religious activities but denies them to activities that are less explicitly religious in character? It seems the opposite policy to what they actually want.
- roenxi 6y agoOpinions on the cheering side are likely diverse; but a good argument for it is wanting a consistent tax code where people are treated consistently without reference to what they are thinking. I am not at all sympathetic to the idea that we allow good works to go tax-free only when religious people do them. That isn't fair. No exemptions for churches is fair, although they should have gotten more notice if this article is representing the situation comprehensively. People doing charitable work probably shouldn't be paying taxes. People doing community work probably shouldn't be paying taxes. I'm even nervous about taxes on business since things like supermarkets are primarily involved with is getting food to people cheaply - discouraging that seems foolish. The basis of that taxation status shouldn't be linked to religious affiliation.
- skissane 6y agoWell, I know that here in Australia we mostly have what you want – there are few special tax exemptions for religious groups. Most of the religious exemptions from taxation in Australia are simply applications of the general tax exemptions for charities and non-profits, combined with the fact that religions are legally categorised as both. The main specific exemption I know of relates to fringe-benefits tax (FBT). Not all charities and non-profits get FBT exemptions or concessions, only some. Religious institutions fall into one of those categories that do get FBT relief, but so do other non-profits like hospitals, aged care facilities, health-related charities, charities targeting poverty/homelessness/etc. But a charity which promotes the advancement of arts and culture, for example, would not get any FBT relief, although it would be eligible for other tax exemptions due to charities and non-profits. Also, there is at least one area in Australian tax law where religious groups are disadvantaged: deductible gift recipient (DGR) status. Donations to religious groups are not tax-deductible when used to fund their core religious functions, only when used to fund their programs to help the poor, etc. By contrast, there are various other categories of charities and non-profits for which all donations are deductible (e.g. Scouts; Girl Guides; public libraries, museums and art galleries; some environmental groups; etc).
- josefx 6y agoThe headline is a bit misleading, purely church things are still exempt, side projects a church may be doing are not. A mega church raking in millions: tax free. A small town church running community projects on the side: taxed for every bit of good it does.