4 ms·
If I wanted to clandestinely introduce invasive species, I would of course not send seeds from whatever suspicious country to random people. A package marked as
by nine_k 6y ago
If I wanted to clandestinely introduce invasive species, I would of course not send seeds from whatever suspicious country to random people. A package marked as e.g. folk art piece would be used, containing seeds, maybe covered with fertilizer, as a filler of an actual e.g. animal figure, or something. The package would arrive to a package consolidation service and packaged, along with some other goods, with a US originating address.
That package would be taken by an agent who would rip it and throw it away onto some strip of farming land along a busy road, while driving there at night, reasonably far away from home. The agent would not understand that this action is the "payload" of the mission, and would never associate the incident with the seeds' country of origin.
If I can come up with this trivial plan in 5 mins, a secret service would, too.
So no, this certainly is not a clandestine operation by a serious nefarious actor, it's a silly e-commerce shtick by a small-time seed seller.
- bbarnett 6y agoUnless.... They are sending these seeds to many people in the US, aka PRC supporters. Or even those pressured to do their work. And they simply got the address wrong, a few times out of thousands. Invasive species can destroy an economy. Devastate it. I'm not saying the PRC is doing this, but if I was trying to harm the US.. I'd do all sorts of evil things like this.
- nine_k 6y agoWe know from history that bad guys sometimes have terribly poor opsec. But again, if I were in charge I would never ever give the people packaging the seeds in China any address in the US except the parcel consolidation service address, or any idea that such other addresses may exist. And look, I did not serve in the secret service a single day. I bet people in the Chinese secret service department that works on clandestine operations abroad are at least as qualified as me.
- jakeogh 6y agoAlso, plausible deniability is a first tier consideration.
- bArray 6y ago> They are sending these seeds to many people in the US, aka > PRC supporters. Or even those pressured to do their work. I'm not sure why you're being down-voted, this is entirely a viable exercise in economic disruption (whether intentional or not). You can definitely get at least 1 in 1000 to plant them (intentionally or unintentionally). Remember for example the old trick of leaving USBs in company car parks. You can tell people a billion times not to plug random crap into their machines, but you'll find at least one person willing to do so at each company. The problem got so bad that they had to glue the USB ports at some places. > Invasive species can destroy an economy. Devastate it. 100%, it's why many Countries have such very strict laws regarding bringing organic foreign goods across the border. > I'm not saying the PRC is doing this, but if I was trying > to harm the US.. I'd do all sorts of evil things like > this. If they are shipping from China, you can likely say they are originating from China. Whether or not it is nefarious is another question altogether. With just a few thousand dollars (to cover shipping) they could cause massive damage. This actually happens all the time as it happens, people buy random seeds from Amazon (for example) and receive something that should really not be planted in local soil. Without planting them, it can be quite hard for the average person to tell them apart.
- gorgoiler 6y agoFSB tactics, on the other hand, involve doing almost everything they can to signal that they were the perpetrators while at the same time denying responsibility. It’s a weird way to flex, братан, but the diplomatic and psychological impact of the attack is far more effective than the attack itself. Example: Russian poisoning suspects say they were only visiting cathedral https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2018/sep/13/russian-television-channel-rt-says-it-is-to-air-interview-with-skripal-salisbury-attack-suspects https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2018/sep/13/russian-tele...
- FearNotDaniel 6y ago> братан I'm always curious about new slang or jargon but can't place this sense of 'Bratan' in the context of espionage/geopolitics. Flexing brotherhood? Flexing manliness?
- gorgoiler 6y agoIt’s the the “bro” in ”weird flex, bro”, which is US English slang meaning “that’s an impressive display of strength which I also find to be bizarrely convoluted”.
- derefr 6y ago“Flex” in that slang term isn’t precisely a “display of strength” but rather “a display of one-upmanship[1]” in any form. A weird flex is specifically one-upmanship in a form where nobody else was really competing over it in the first place. It’s “weird” because you’re trying so hard to out-compete others in a category where nobody else is trying to compete at all, and where, therefore, a category where it’s very easy to “win.” Most Guinness World Records are weird flexes: not hard-fought limits of discovered human ability, but rather something one person decided to prove they could do that nobody else has really even cared to challenge them about since. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One-upmanship https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One-upmanship
- FearNotDaniel 6y agoAh, makes sense now, thanks for the explanation. I must have missed the comma first time round, and thus thought that "bro" was the thing being flexed.
- moksly 6y agoOn the other hand, if you wanted to hide a few shipments of seeds, you could flood a country with a sea of packages.
- godelski 6y agoIf I were going to do it I would partner with a cereal company and run a national campaign about how planting flowers are going to save the bees. For those that don't get the joke (this is a joke) https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/nation-now/2017/03/20/cheerios-gave-away-flower-seeds-save-bees-but-they-could-do-harm/99416524/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/nation-now/2017/03/20/c... https://www.cheerios.ca/bringbackthebees/ https://www.cheerios.ca/bringbackthebees/
- rocqua 6y agoPeople could just throw the letters away, end up in landfill, and start from there
- m463 6y agoA few years ago, some folks sent out some advertising letters that contained flower seeds in the paper. You could literally bury the paper in the ground to grow the flowers. plantable seed paper: https://buddyburst.com/products/plantable-seed-paper/postcard/ https://buddyburst.com/products/plantable-seed-paper/postcar...
- schwartzworld 6y agoHonestly, if you really wanted to do it, all you'd need is a single person in a car with a giant bag of seeds. How many could a single person plant in a week going for walks in conversation areas? What if you had 10 people or 100? Way more efficient than mailing the seeds out and hoping people plant them.