9 ms·
Well well well, if it isn’t the consequences of 50+ years of terrible policy making. Who could’ve seen this coming except every other country on the planet?
by paulcole 6y ago
Well well well, if it isn’t the consequences of 50+ years of terrible policy making. Who could’ve seen this coming except every other country on the planet?
- runawaybottle 6y agoYou really think 5 months of a pandemic is going to expose this? New York is returning back to normal. The new surges will pass in the same time frame (5 months). The looming primary care crisis will show itself on a much longer time frame. It’s a snake that’s wrapping around, slow acting venom, and we’ll finally see it when it’s not just the ailing boomers that will need continuous care for ubiquitous things like Diabetes, but gen x, y, and z after it. No one’s gonna die, that’s when it’s all going to come to a head. We cannot afford Medicare for all when everybody is fucking sick.
- controversy 6y agoWe should be able to afford it when the government takes its rightful place as health dictator. Ban alcohol. Ban tobacco. Ban fatty foods. Ban meat. Ban high fructose corn syrup. If not ban, make it so only rich white people can afford it. Then we can afford things by requiring doctors to either work within the system or they can’t be doctors. That takes care of them going into private care.
- 1996 6y agoBan, ban, ban, then force people to work for the government? I'm not sure I want to live in the country you are suggesting we make. What about drugs are legalized instead, and the medical sector is deregulated for example by removing residency requirements? If a rating system can let anyone become the equivalent of a cab, we certainly can do the same with doctors educated abroad while also educating more at home.
- controversy 6y agoThe republicans had their chance. They fucked it up. They are the Washington Team Named To Be Determines of policy makers. All they did was piss people off. Unfortunately we now have to fall into the lap of big daddy government.
- runawaybottle 6y agoYou guys are missing the point. I’m saying the general public is too unhealthy for this not to be extremely costly going forward, whether it’s for profit or non profit. The only thing we solved is making sure you can live with the ailment. We didn’t solve the cost of continuous care. Whoever is born today, will enter the demographic of questionable health in just 40 years. That means in our lifetime we’ll have almost 3 generations with garbage health inundating the healthcare system. Try to flatten that curve.
- baix777 6y agoIf you look at this from a socioeconomic standpoint, the poor are more obese and exercise less than the better off. Being poor is hard, so the wealth gap of the US looks to be partial cause of this, but the whole cause and effect is hard to determine here.
- dimensi0nal 6y agoShould health insurance, private or public, really pay to deal with people's self-induced health problems from eating too much, smoking, etc?
- coronadisaster 6y agoMaybe the health insurance companies should sue tobacco and fast food companies amoung others?
- maxerickson 6y agoA healthcare system should strive to make the care people need affordable. Your framing is boring, we need to figure out how to make the care as widely available as possible regardless of the payment model.
- wwweston 6y agoCertainly an issue insurers have been thinking about for a while. Funding certain kinds of care with heavy taxes on things like smoking makes a lot sense. Other things like unhealthy eating (or sitting, HN participants, lookin' at you) are so much harder to draw easy lines dividing contributing activity from everyday liberties that it makes less sense. You can work at the margins with something like soda taxes or maybe even incentives around bloodwork but the tradeoffs are less clear along with the dividing lines.
- paulcole 6y agoYes.
- wwweston 6y agoYour last sentence is logically equivalent to saying that no society can afford to give medical care to everyone, the only choice is who to ration it for, since Medicare-for-all is characteristically no different from any other comprehensive risk pool bridged over an entire population. And under conditions you're describing where the population truly is uniformly ill, every sub-population will look similar to the population at large, so no private insurance pool will do better by excluding some of the population. Sounds like a problem.
- AdrianB1 6y agoNo idea what you want to say, but in my country the situation is worse for about 100 years. Yes, we have free lack of health care: no resources shared to almost everyone, so we are equal in getting nothing.
- maxerickson 6y agoThe US centrally plans the healthcare supply and then doesn't control prices (sort of). We can and should have lots more doctors (and other primary care providers), but we've long restricted that because people have wacky ideas about things like economics and intelligence.
- fennecfoxen 6y ago> people have wacky ideas about things like economics and intelligence. Boy howdy. There are three major parts of the economy which are extensively regulated to achieve political goals: health care and higher education (on the national level with some state involvement) and housing (city-level zoning, with occasional other mandates particularly in places like California). Notice then the three areas where prices have become radically more expensive over the past several decades, fomenting a crisis that threatens our prosperity as a nation: housing prices, higher education prices, health care prices...
- kcb 6y agoYou really think that those are the only three things regulated to achieve political goals?
- prawn 6y agoAt the time of my reading, their comment says "three major parts of the economy which are extensively regulated". I don't think that they're ignoring all others.
- HarryHirsch 6y agoYou think that other countries don't have housing, education and healthcare policies?
- refurb 6y agoCanada is having a huge shortage of primary care doctors. So much many people don’t have one and have to rely on urgent care.[1] This isn’t a US only issue. [1] https://www.ctvnews.ca/health/despite-more-doctors-many-canadians-don-t-have-a-family-physician-report-1.4611149 https://www.ctvnews.ca/health/despite-more-doctors-many-cana...
- dantheman 6y agoThe US purposefully lowered the amount of doctors in the 90s. If anything we should be creating more need schools and creating more doctors.
- tharne 6y agoThat's a big claim to make without providing any evidence or even some context.
- wonder_er 6y agoI'm not the OP; when I read OP's comment, I thought "Oh, I think the AMA's been doing this since long before the 90's". Here's the article I read a few years back that made me think this is the case: I know it's mises.org, so hold the pichforks until the end. Even if they're way off base, there's got to be some value to be gleaned: https://mises.org/library/100-years-medical-robbery https://mises.org/library/100-years-medical-robbery
- controversy 6y agoThe AMA corrected course on this. The problem is not a lack of schools. The problem is a lack of hospitals to train them in as part of the residency. As long as residency is a thing, we have an insurmountable bottle neck. Evidence to the limitations. https://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/4561/does-the-ama-limit-the-number-of-doctors-to-increase-current-doctors-salaries https://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/4561/does-the-a...
- tesmar2 6y ago
- Proven 6y agowhich "policy making" hasn't turned out to be terrible? why not call it "50 years of statism"? let the state make the policy and before you know crony capitalists and corrupt state employees (in healthcare, insurance and politics) create a mess that results in high costs, poor quality or shortages. why is anyone surprised? the NYT has contributed to this mess by supporting increased role of government in healthcare (and not just in healthcare)