4 ms·

Suppose a child disrupts class for 30 of his peers because his dad beats him. His dad has now effectively victimized 31 kids. Wouldn't it be productive and m

Suppose a child disrupts class for 30 of his peers because his dad beats him. His dad has now effectively victimized 31 kids. Wouldn't it be productive and moral to find ways to help all 31, perhaps by putting misbehaving kids in special classrooms where they can receive specialized help?

danielheath 6y ago
Assuming the specialised help isn’t just worse facilities somewhere else, maybe (or maybe not). In practice - who is going to ensure the other facilities are of a good standard? The abusive parents? If you don’t help that kid, the other 30 will spend their whole lives sharing a society with an adult who didn’t get help. That’s an unfair drain on their life too (increased crime, policing costs, etc). Putting the disruptive kids in the same place as everyone else means the incentives are right to do something useful to help them.
- catalogia 6y ago
  One of my aunts is a such a specialized teacher; her program is called "emotional support" or something to that effect. From what I understand it's a classroom in the same school building and the students sent to her classroom are troubled in frequently very sad ways which she won't discuss in specifics. She's accountable to the same principle that the normal teachers are. From what I know of this sort of program, it seems to be a sincere attempt to help kids, not merely brush them off into a corner to forget about them. I don't know how often it's successful, but I think in that school district at least it's well motivated. From what I know of it, it seems like a much better system than allowing those kids to disrupt normal classrooms.
  - ed25519FUUU 6y ago
    That’s good work your aunt is doing. Necessary work indeed, but unfortunately not academic work. For these students who are deeply troubled, there must be healing before there can really be learning.
deleted 6y ago
[deleted]
chongli 6y ago
It would take one hell of a teacher to handle a full class of misbehaving students. I think most teachers would pass on that opportunity.
jessaustin 6y ago
First let's hire another teacher and cut that class size down!
lifeisstillgood 6y ago
This is still behaviour management, but not entirely in the schools circle. Society as a whole needs to help manage the behaviour - we manage the dads behaviour by arresting him, manage the rest of the family through in person support and finally worry about the school.

danielheath 6y ago

Assuming the specialised help isn’t just worse facilities somewhere else, maybe (or maybe not). In practice - who is going to ensure the other facilities are of a good standard? The abusive parents? If you don’t help that kid, the other 30 will spend their whole lives sharing a society with an adult who didn’t get help. That’s an unfair drain on their life too (increased crime, policing costs, etc). Putting the disruptive kids in the same place as everyone else means the incentives are right to do something useful to help them.

catalogia 6y ago
One of my aunts is a such a specialized teacher; her program is called "emotional support" or something to that effect. From what I understand it's a classroom in the same school building and the students sent to her classroom are troubled in frequently very sad ways which she won't discuss in specifics. She's accountable to the same principle that the normal teachers are. From what I know of this sort of program, it seems to be a sincere attempt to help kids, not merely brush them off into a corner to forget about them. I don't know how often it's successful, but I think in that school district at least it's well motivated. From what I know of it, it seems like a much better system than allowing those kids to disrupt normal classrooms.
- ed25519FUUU 6y ago
  That’s good work your aunt is doing. Necessary work indeed, but unfortunately not academic work. For these students who are deeply troubled, there must be healing before there can really be learning.

deleted 6y ago

[deleted]

chongli 6y ago

It would take one hell of a teacher to handle a full class of misbehaving students. I think most teachers would pass on that opportunity.

jessaustin 6y ago

First let's hire another teacher and cut that class size down!

lifeisstillgood 6y ago

This is still behaviour management, but not entirely in the schools circle. Society as a whole needs to help manage the behaviour - we manage the dads behaviour by arresting him, manage the rest of the family through in person support and finally worry about the school.