6 ms·
The false choice here is actually that you can sacrifice lives and still expect to have freedom. The alternative to not giving up privacy for contact tracing o
by Barrin92 6y ago
The false choice here is actually that you can sacrifice lives and still expect to have freedom.
The alternative to not giving up privacy for contact tracing or similar measures is to be locked into your home medieval style while the plague runs wild in the streets, which is a significantly stronger limitation of freedoms.
The choice isn't between liberty or safety, just as it isn't between economic health and lockdown, it's between intelligent and proactive measures or carnage. Without public health there's no liberty. If our systems fail to protect the health of our populations those rights will go out the door sooner or later because it proves that those values are useless.
It's completely paradoxical to argue that I'm free although I can't go to work, I can't safely go to the restaurant, I can't meet my friends without being afraid of contracting a deadly disease, but I'm free because I have privacy.
- anoncake 6y agoLocking yourself up for fear of a <1% chance of dying is very much a choice.
- Barrin92 6y agoThe chance of ending up in a hospital is much higher (about 15 times higher), and so are the chances for complications in general like loss of smell or neurological or heart/lung damage. And if you have pre-existing conditions (like a sizeable amount of people) those risks only go up. As can be seen in slumping economic stats many people are avoiding that risk which makes complete sense. It's absurd to frame this as a 'choice', it's a gigantic societal and civilisational failure to not be able to stop this disease. In particular in the US though framing collective failure of preventable harm as cost for freedom has become the norm. You can pick anything that doesn't work or that could have been prevented and within five seconds someone will tell you it's the price for freedom. I think the real explanation is much more sinister. As a society people have given up, so now every harm or burden is rationalised in this way.
- azinman2 6y agoThat 1% depends on a wide variety of contexts. It isn’t 1% for everyone, 1/3% of those who didn’t die seem to have debilitating persistent problems, and even if everything is fine with you, you can pass it to someone who passes it to someone who dies from your unwillingness to act for the greater good. To do anything but protect yourself is fundamentally selfish.
- orangecat 6y agoIt isn’t 1% for everyone True. If you're younger (really, under 60) and healthy it's much less than 1%. 1/3% of those who didn’t die seem to have debilitating persistent problems Unclear if you mean 1/3 of all infections, which is far too high, or 1 to 3 percent, which is possibly reasonable, although again it's going to be skewed towards older and unhealthy people. even if everything is fine with you, you can pass it to someone who passes it to someone who dies from your unwillingness to act for the greater good At some point people have to be responsible for themselves. If you're severely allergic to peanuts, then that's something that you have to watch out for; we don't ban peanuts for the general public. If you're at high risk for COVID then you should take appropriate precautions, but it's unreasonable to demand that everyone else be forbidden from seeing their friends and family for months or years.
- azinman2 6y agoAny levels of fatality is relative to how overwhelmed the health care system is, and the access to care that people have. We’ve seen it as high as 15% already in some places. This is a GLOBAL pandemic; any spread within your community can eventually make it to the Amazon in Brazil where it’s ravishing local communities that don’t have access to modern hospitals. Your statement seems to emphasize that the focus should be on the youth, who are also dying of this disease. But the careless nature of dismissing the fatality rate of those over 60 or with co-morbidities is really unbelievable. So my parents, who are otherwise healthy and I expect to live for DECADES more should die now so you can go out and see your friends? Or those who are young with diabetes that might otherwise have an entire full life? The level of selfishness of such a statement is just off the charts. If you were to kill just ONE person and be caught you’d be in jail for many years, purposefully (murder) or by accident (manslaughter). Yet passing a disease that has brought the world to its knees around is somehow ok? When did those who get affected by your actions get to weight in and vote on this? Or do you feel you can just unilaterally decide that it’s fine for others to die _unnecessarily_? And for businesses to suffer because the disease keeps going and others DO care about their own safety and those around them? Furthermore, the CDC just acknowledged it may be as high as 1/3 of those recovered with persistent issues [1]. Even if it were 1-3%, why is that ok for that 1-3%? 1% of the global population is approximately 80 million people. How many of these would have solved climate change, found a cure for covid, or otherwise positively impacted the planet? That’s worth not just saying indoors collectively for a short period to prevent? It keeps going because people DON’T do what’s in the best interest for all of society, or even their future self. You’re basing your assumptions on an extremely short time span of data, but we know that many viruses can strike far later in life with devastating consequences, or a lifetime of flare ups. We simply don’t know, but Dr. Fauci has repeatedly warned people about such a possibility. How can you calculate such risks when they’re unknown? Peanuts are something that can be easily regulated and limited to those who are allergic. They pose no global threat, and don’t hop between people. Those allergic can also carry epipens. There is no epipen for covid (yet?). Until then we have an unusually highly contagious virus that spreads from a very high percentage of asymptotic carriers. Already in the US over 1/3 of Americans who died in WWII have died since March that largely wouldn’t have otherwise [2]. It’s July. Please reconsider your actions. [1] https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/69/wr/mm6930e1.htm https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/69/wr/mm6930e1.htm [2] https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/vsrr/covid19/excess_deaths.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/vsrr/covid19/excess_deaths.htm
- m3kw9 6y ago1% chance is for you. But if you are able to infect another person, that is no longer 1% as a whole.
- bad_user 6y agoWhile I understood lockdown measures, know that this is your privilege talking. You can stay in lockdown because you're middle class living in a wealthy country. In countries like India lockdown can cost far more than what Covid-19 can do. I'm not arguing against public health measures, when the cost to me is low or when accompanied by evidence. So where's the evidence that tracing apps work? That South Korea does it and South Korea manages to keep Covid-19 under control, that's not evidence. Plenty of confounders like the massive testing they did, their discipline in wearing masks, etc. And note that I'm not a denier. I do think 1% mortality is unacceptable, plus it appears that's not the only problem. High hospitalization rates, permanent heart and lung damage, etc. Still not willing to trade my privacy away, sorry. You're free to do that but I'm willing to fight for mine.
- BrandoElFollito 6y ago> 'm not arguing against public health measures, when the cost to me is low or when accompanied by evidence. Sometime there are no clear evidences, just suppositions - or the individual cost is not insignificant. In that case you should not be surprised to be forced to stay at home, similarly to not being allowed in a school when not vaccinated. You decide to pose a risk to society - you must face the consequences. My wife is immuno-depressed so people, for their comfort and freedom decide to be a danger are my personal enemies. I want to make sure they are forced to stay at home with their liberty with them. Only when you cooperate with society "for the greater good" then you are free to express your freedom publicly. This is not something philosophical - it is life at stake for some people.
- bad_user 6y agoI'm sorry for your immuno-depressed wife. I also have family members over 60 that would be at higher risk if they contacted Covid-19. And I'm an asthmatic and asthmatics are at higher risk. But that's still not a reason to have my privacy traded away. And if you're going to treat me like the enemy, willing to trade my freedoms away, for your safety, then don't be surprised if I'm going to treat you like an enemy too. --- I'm totally fine with vaccination btw. That's a really poor analogy b/c vaccination is the best evidence-based strategy we have for fighting viruses and it's a one time cost to pay. To be honest, even if contact tracing apps had evidence that they work somewhat, I'd still not trade my privacy away. I only pointed out the lack of evidence because it is absurd to give up your freedoms on something that may or may not work. In any case, I'd rather catch the virus.
- patrick451 6y ago> The false choice here is actually that you can sacrifice lives and still expect to have freedom. To the contrary, lives sacrificed is necessary for liberty. Personally, I would rather die of covid (or terrorists) than be locked in my house (or have my movements surveilled) by a government that fetishizes safety above all else. To hell with safety.