3 ms·
> A reasonable reading of her statement is that she doesn't regard trans women as actual women Do people realize that this is just a linguistic question? It's
by BurningFrog 6y ago
> A reasonable reading of her statement is that she doesn't regard trans women as actual women
Do people realize that this is just a linguistic question?
It's an argument about what the word "women" means or should mean. Not about any substantial real world issue.
To me, arguing about the meaning of words is one of the lowest forms of discourse.
- jariel 6y agoIt's not a linguistic question, it's a social question. "Is a man who identifies as a woman, a woman, or a man?" - that's a pretty core question. To be fair, it's pretty important to trans women that they identify and be referred to as 'women'. That's pretty core to the identity, so it's more than a word. So, in that sense, I can understand how her arguments could be disconcerting to some. But - when we talk about what is 'objectively a woman' or the policies we apply in sports, that kind of stuff, then it's an issue that transcends just self identification. In terms of 'self identity' - well - 'who cares' really, I agree, but what about the legal requirement for others to use specific words, or sports, special facilities, access to gendered facilities and clubs etc. - then it becomes a real problem.