12 ms·
Thinking of a Cybersecurity Career?
- cyberbanjo 6y agoThat's surprising to someone not in CyberSec that so few can do basic tasks of their job. I wonder how they declare the bar for basic or not.
- rckoepke 6y agoThe % breakdown table was for candidates, I'm presuming that a decent fraction of the candidates might not have been "experienced candidates" but could have been entry level. Also, the weakest candidates are generally going to apply to the most job openings, so they may be counted multiple times here.
- dx87 6y agoI used to do interviews for pentesters at an old job, and I was suprised as well. I think it's because CyberSecurity is relatively new, so companies have no idea how to hire for it, and end up hiring whoever can talk the best. I interviewed a lot of people with titles like "Senior Cybersecurity Engineer" who had no security knowledge beyond how to run an automated scan against an IP range, and put the findings it printed out into a report for management.
- tinco 6y agoThat's also the kind of report that management would like to hear instead of the real report, which should say things like "every single person on teams X-Z should use a password manager and 2-FA for everything they access both in business and in private". Security is a bother at best, and disruptive at worst. It's a tough sell, and it's so much easier to point at some badly configured network devices.
- dx87 6y ago> Security is a bother at best, and disruptive at worst. Yep, the devs where I work actually went to my manager and said that me reporting security findings that need to be remediated is messing up their timeline, so they wanted all testing to be put on hold until the app was already in production. Luckily my manager pushed back and said that if they don't want their timeline messed up by constantly having to remediate findings, they should stop including basic vulnerabilities in their code.
- PenguinCoder 6y agoAnd yet here I am with half a decade actual experience in 'Cyber Security', can write passable Golang, C, C++, Python, hands on, real world knowledge and experience of threat actors and APT TTPs, for Blue team threat hunting, IDS/IPS signature creation, incident response... etc. And I can't even get a callback from any other company, because I don't check the "Bachelor degree required" box. Fucking, awesome.
- staticassertion 6y agoThat's very surprising. I don't have a degree and at Dropbox, the last company I worked for, dropouts were more common than those who held a bachelors. Maybe there's something else going on?
- user5994461 6y agoLocation most likely. Search cyber security jobs on indeed in London and there is hardly anything coming up. I can't imagine what it's like in a small city.
- 616c 6y agoWas curious to learn more about you, your website is nice, but the blog (blog.penguincoder.com) redirects to the main site (penguincoder.com), FYI.
- PenguinCoder 6y agoHey, thanks for the reply. My blog isn't ready for primetime yet, so I do have it redirecting to the main page for now.
- Shared404 6y agoSeems like a good place to copy/paste one of my comments from a different thread. Disclaimer: I'm not particularly good at this, so whatever comments I make are well intentioned but may be of varying accuracy. ... Online sources: * OWASP.org is a good place to find info. If you look something up, there's a good chance you will find it here. * https://owasp.org/www-project-web-security-testing-guide/ https://owasp.org/www-project-web-security-testing-guide/ Thanks to redis_mic for this one, I didn't know it existed until today. * overthewire.org Similar to HTS, but you don't need an account. The subject matter covered is also slightly different. * https://0x00sec.org/ https://0x00sec.org/ A forum dedicated to security. There's a lot of script kiddies, but also some gold. * https://www.hackerone.com/ https://www.hackerone.com/ What better way to learn then practice on live targets? That being said, I would do some of the others first. ... I do a lot of learning through reading, so books: * Network Security Assessment by Chris McNab. I have second edition, which is a good and instructive read, but quite outdated. * Real-World Bug Hunting by Peter Yaworski. Web security 101. Good read, and fairly useful. * Advanced Penetration Testing by Wil Allsop. Outdated, but interesting. You will never use flash again after reading this. * Social Engineering, The Science of Human Hacking by Christopher Hadnagy. This is a very interesting read. Also, one of the few that can't go out of date. ... This should be enough to get you started. There's a couple more books I can think of, but they tend to be more specialized into certain fields of security and less approachable/generally applicable. If you want these recommendations as well, feel free to email me, my email's in my bio.
- ciprian_craciun 6y agoVery interesting article, but at the same time it depicts a very sad truth... [Disclaimer: also not a certified security professional, but I do follow the topic and practice it hands-on from time-to-time...] However I think there are multiple (sometimes non-overlapping) types of cyber-security professionals / roles: * the policy maker / enforcer -- which is what some companies want, and what the most well known people out there (including Schneier, Krebs, etc.) are blogging and speaking about; (to put it metaphorically they are the ones in charge of designing an IT "hygiene", and making sure everyone "washes their hands" properly;) :) * the operations security -- which should make sure systems and networks are well locked down, patches properly installed, watches out for suspicious activity, and if he is capable enough tries to check the boundaries and limits the firms security; this is another role most companies want, what some courses train for, and what usual bloggers write about; * "applied cryptography / security" developer (for the lack of a better name) -- which (if he knows better) should make sure proper well-known techniques and best practices are used throughout the developed applications, and when necessary (if not already covered by existing solutions) is capable enough to mix cryptographic primitives; * "high budget zero-day" researcher (also for the lack of a better name) -- which is mostly employed by state level actors to discover zero-day vulnerabilities, and on the other side employed by large corporations (e.g. Google, Microsoft, etc.) to make sure their most valuable systems aren't vulnerable to those types of attacks; these are the guys that come up with Spectre and Meltdown and other very low-level hardware related vulnerabilities; * (many others that escape me at this moment...) Each of these roles require some different traits and focus areas, which most of the time aren't strictly related to IT or security; for example: * the policy maker should be well versed in social sciences and human behavior, as in the end he has to work with people; * the operations security person should be as capable (if not more) than any of its "normal" peers in all matters of network and systems administration; * all of them must understand that in the end security is a spectrum (i.e. from air-gapped-system to no-authentication-internet-connected) and it has to take into account a balance between internal cost (development, operations, etc), end-user costs (e.g. how cumbersome is for the end-user to login), risks (e.g. is the data valuable enough to protect it with 2FA), time-to-market, etc. So in the end I think the underlying problem is that most companies want "one cybersecurity guy", and most candidates see themselves as that "one guy", when in reality there is no real person that can actually fulfill all these roles. Just like nobody wants to hire "a developer", but a "web developer", or an "embedded developer", so should companies specify what kind of security professional they are looking for...
- jamescun 6y agoI find this article very interesting. I'm coming at this from the other way around. I am a Site Reliability Engineer, so I've been writing code, architecting systems, building networks etc for 8 years professionally; I am however eyeing a more security oriented position so only now I am looking at courses and training.
- mpettitt 6y agoIt's important to note that while there are a lot of skills which can be useful, it's fairly rare to find a job which requires them all. For example, if you have a mobile application specialist, they probably don't need to worry about, say, VLAN configuration on a regular basis. It's quite likely that even if they do know it, the lack of use will result in them not showing that knowledge well in an interview situation. If you give them a few hours and an internet connection, though, they may well be able to refamiliarise themselves easily. Alternatively, you just need to hire someone who specialises in network architecture and segregation - this does rely on the person doing the hiring to know vaguely what they need, though, which is not always the case. I work in the industry, and there are people who are well known as experts in specific fields, but who I would never expect to be able to do some other aspects of my job, just as I would struggle to do things they can do without any difficulty. I think the cyber security industry is at the stage where the web was 15-20 years ago, where a company would hire a "webmaster" who did all the web related stuff, rather than getting a combination of people in different roles each specialising in one area. It's slowly getting better, but it's still common for companies to look for a jack of all trades security person, rather than getting the specific knowledge they need.
- ackbar03 6y ago>I think the cyber security industry is at the stage where the web was 15-20 years ago, where a company would hire a "webmaster" who did all the web related stuff, rather than getting a combination of people in different roles each specialising in one area This is an interesting view. You really think so? The use case of the "web" /website industry is so much wider. I feel like cybersecurity companies are struggling a lot more to come up with an actual product and continues to be more of a consultancy type business. I know in China a lot of the smaller cybersecurity startups have eventually been folded into either alibaba or tencent cause it's so hard to come up with a product that people want to buy.
- GekkePrutser 6y agoTotally agree, it's not really possible for a hacker or security specialist to excel at all categories. Some people become an expert in web injection, others in buffer overflows, network attacks or crypto. The field has become way too wide for one person to have expert knowledge in everything.
- wjnc 6y agoIn my experience many jobs in "risk management" (under which I'd file a large part of cybersecurity from an organisational perspective) are 'second career jobs'. You first need to have done the job yourself before you start learning how to properly comment, guide, influence and teach colleagues and teams. People are notoriously resistant to outside critique even when you are part of the same organisation and principally on the same boat. So I would advise companies to let medior to senior staff that are not management material but can lead by example to take on more risk management roles. So how to get into cybersecurity? Don't. Do what you like (programming, systems administration or even IT-procurement) and after a few years start transitioning to cybersecurity. An exception would be the hardcore whitehats but firms usually don't have those on board and rely on consulting. So programmer-consultant is another route. But you won't get hired without quite the demonstrated homework, so you'll need to love it.
- iuguy 6y agoKrebs does not work in Cybersecurity, does not come from a position of knowledge or experience in Cybersecurity and his only skill relating to Cybersecurity is doxxing people. I could understand if this was "Thinking of a Cybersecurity journalism career" but there are better people to learn from.
- pentae 6y agoPerhaps instead of going after the author you could go after his ideas? It seems like quite a well written essay imo
- iuguy 6y agoShall I do that for everyone who does not work in the industry they are advising people on?
- phaus 6y agoI do incident response for a living and the general idea of his article was accurate. His message is that many candidates lack the technical capability to do the job but its easy to acquire those skills on your own using resources from the web if you are really interested in it. He even added a disclaimer that he's not a technical expert.
- the_goku 6y agonah miss me with that cyber security stfuf
- the_goku 6y agohow does one cybersafe though?
- ackbar03 6y agoI feel like it's hard to teach cybersecurity formally. It deals with hacking and by nature the spirit of hacking is hard to teach. I have learnt cybersecurity as a hobby and have competed with our university team in some online well known attack/defense style competitions (we sucked) and a lot of this stuff is really hard to formalize. I guess you could teach the basics like overflows, aslr, stack canaries, basic assembly, but in the end it's up to the hacker to string everything together to overflow a buffer, control the return pointer, leak the canary, string together a rop chain and pwn the system, and this takes a lot of tinkering and discovery rather than prior knowledge, although experience definitely helps. I guess it's also why some random high school teenager could be going up against the hacking team from Tencent in these competitions. And this is only for binary exploitation mind you. If you look at some of the crazy talks from defcon, the stuff they do draws upon a lot of random knowledge, and it comes down more to the act of piecing everything together than knowing anything before hand, hence the "hacking". And that's also why I love it :)
- scollet 6y agoSounds like they need to bring apprenticeships to the field.
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y agoAs someone undertaking a Master's in Cybersecurity, that table is totally true. Most of my courses have a programming alternative for assignments yet the students alongside me have very little interest. I've been doing this a while so maybe I'm just an outlier as I've always been the guy who is the jack of all trades, but I can't help but see something unknown as something to learn.
- OminousWeapons 6y agoIt's a similar story in my cybersecurity Master's program. Many students seem to lack any dev or administration skills and are basically locked out of the high quality, practical classes because of it. Everyone that seems to be succeeding in my program and in the job market either has a formal CS background or is a motivated, self-taught dev or admin.
- Izmaki 6y agoDon't ditch programming. Knowing how programs are made will in some situations help you understand how they can be abused as well.
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y agoOf course not... after 11 years as a software engineer, it would be difficult to not do it.
- 7174n6 6y agoAs with most positions, the largest obstacle to getting a job in security is overcoming the HR Gatekeepers. The hiring system is broken. Those who successfully attained job are those who generally have networked their way around the first line HR personnel. Get your name out there so that hiring managers know who you are. Blog, go to meet-ups, make friends, do capture-the-flags, create a website, create a Git repo, and a home lab that you write about.
- staticassertion 6y agoTBH while a lot of people say the shortage is a myth, I am not so convinced. I wouldn't personally hire most people in infosec because I think the industry has the wrong idea of what the career should look like. Most people in infosec have no coding skills. That isn't their fault, they aren't told it's important. I think it is, so I won't hire them. That just cut out the vast majority of candidates with a single criteria, and I believe a lot of the criteria is broken.
- GekkePrutser 6y agoI think the cybersecurity (I hate the term cyber btw as it's usually used by people who don't know what they're talking about), is very focused on the 'think like a hacker' skillset right now. While I do agree this is important in various roles in the security realm, there are also many jobs where this doesn't really add value. A lot of work is about implementing things like MFA, role-based-access etc where knowledge of the platform used (e.g. Microsoft) and internal processes are more important. After all, most companies already fail at the 'fix the obvious' stage, it's not necessary to go looking for clever ways in when there are many doors left open. Just to elaborate: A lot of discussions go like this. A pentest or random scan finds obvious issue. Ticket is raised to the security team. They go like "WTF why do we still have Windows 95?? Kill it.". Then their boss goes like "Sorry, Bill the manufacturing VP lobbied with the CEO, we have to leave that one alone". Of course when it actually gets hacked, Bill is nowhere to be found. This is why internal influencing skills are so important in real everyday security jobs. Of course in the pentesting role this kind of thinking is absolutely necessary. However even there the kind of training given right now is too much in the realm of 'scriptkiddie'ism. Hacking is about inventing and true mastery of technology, not about using the tools everyone uses. Being able to run metasploit and wireshark does not make one a hacker. By doing this, pentesters test for yesterday's hacks, not tomorrow's.
- movedx 6y ago> Being able to run metasploit and wireshark does not make one a hacker. By doing this, pentesters test for yesterday's hacks, not tomorrow's. Be careful here. This is bordering on elitism. Having someone come into a business and check for "yesterday's hacks" is better than no one doing any checks at all, therefore such skills are still valuable and worthwhile. In learning how networking works; how operating systems are designed and implemented; why and how the OWASP Top Ten work; and knowing solutions to these problems is still a valuable skill set. What you're suggesting is everyone has to be willing and able to write fresh exploitation on the spot when they're testing a client's network when in fact there's a lot that can be discovered (and resolved) with basic scans and simple questions based off of Security+ grade knowledge.
- 6y ago
- jonny383 6y agoDuring my degree, I had a crossover unit for cryptography. The unit was a mix of computer science majors, and also a new "cyber security" degree the university had recently started. This was a third year unit. Holy-moly, did the cyber security students flop from the first class. It was immediately clear that the new "degree" they had signed up for had not given them even elementary math skills in comp. sci related fields (discrete math, linear algebra). A few of them put in the hard yards, studied about a year's worth of math and did okay. But the majority flopped out hard and failed. The "degree" was dropped a year later. Poor kids.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- beardedwizard 6y agoI'm a senior level security leader and hiring manager. I focus on software security. Ask me anything about what I see, or don't, in candidates.
- Izmaki 6y agoHow much do you value CEH?
- allanbreyes 6y agoA follow-up: how much do you value OSCP?
- Izmaki 6y agoHopefully the answer will be "A LOT more than CEH", but I wanted to test the waters. :P
- beardedwizard 6y agoI do not value CEH or OSCP at all. The candidate will need to demonstrate they can apply that skill against a real world situation. I wont be more likely to interview you by having these on your resume, but it may help a recruiter put it in front of me (though I will never tell them to look for these keywords)
- GekkePrutser 6y agoGood!! That's the right approach. I also think these certifications are forcing students to think in the direction intended by the underlying company, whereas hacking is about looking for the unexpected. It's about mastery of technology, not about ticking some boxes and knowing command-line parameters of common tools by heart. Indeed there is a major issue with HR focusing too strongly on certificates because they lack the knowledge to evaluate a candidate any other way.
- 6y ago
- jtdev 6y agoIn my experience, c level folks just want someone who can produce a dashboard or executive report with a bunch of green check marks that basically say “yay! We’re secure”. They don’t care about the why, how, if the check marks are actually meaningful, etc. This mindset is then reinforced by vendors selling security snake oil - the entire infosec domain is a shit show; if infosec practitioners ever want to be taken seriously, they need to collectively get their shit together and organize around some real tangible standards.
- Izmaki 6y agoThere's the MITRE ATT&CK Framework https://attack.mitre.org/ https://attack.mitre.org/ which is gaining attention and seems very promising (although it of course isn't the golden answer to all questions, it goes a long way to cover the basics).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- user5994461 6y agoCyberSecurity, the domain that doesn't recruit yet has a shortage. What cybersecurity is to most people is automated security scans. This can be done by interns with a week of training to run the tools. (Interpreting and remediating the findings is another matter). Besides that, security is mainly about authentication. That's done by setting up LDAP, active directory, openid connect and co, and integrating in applications. A tremendous amount of setup and integration work for administrators/developers. (Not cyber security engineers) There are cyber aspects around infrastructure and networking for sysadmin/devops/sre/developers. Setting up firewalls and 2FA in AWS, configuring TLS, upgrading OS and abandoned libraries. (Still, no permanent cyber security roles in sight) Last is a couple of researchers finding vulnerabilities, concentrated in the likes of the NSA, NSO Group, project zero. Highly technical work that very few companies recruit for. These are full time jobs, offensive cyber security (vulnerability researcher) but extremely few in the world. When I see people looking for cyber security engineers or trying to break into security. I can't help but think what do they mean by that? Just become a developer or a sysadmin/devops.
- dpeck 6y agoThis. So much this. Unless you’re going the vulnerability/malware research, reverse engineering, or something equally specialized don’t paint yourself into a corner and limit your options with over specific signaling. And realize that the above are tough roles to get paid for. There aren’t many of them, you have to have intense technical skills across many domains to be effective. All things considered you are unlikely to be able to make as much money as a developer (with just a little business savvy) putting in the same amount of effort. Don’t get me wrong, I’m still an old hacker at heart and infosec has a lot of amazing aspects of it. It is one of the last holdouts of the old community-driven cultures around computing, but know what you’re getting into with open eyes. Recruiters and businesses have been working hard to commoditize it for years, and will continue to. In addition it’s been a “hot” job track for a while now, similar to “devops” a few years ago, so you’ll find a lot of folks in it without a particular interest or understanding beyond the surface level resume fodder.
- vsareto 6y ago> CyberSecurity, the domain that doesn't recruit yet has a shortage. Yes, they are 100% lying about this. Any time you see an article about skills shortage, it's complete bullshit. It is cheap for them to create the illusion of a skills shortage via articles and blog spam. What they really want is people to spend their own money on training vs. them training their own talent. Then, once you've spent your money on training, you'll still run similar gauntlets in interviews that developers like to complain about. This is why some of the certs are kind of useless at getting a job despite industry advice to get them. Some places will see something like OSCP and then still give you a time-limited CTF to do before they'll even talk to you about an entry-level position. Other larger companies will praise you for your certs, saying certs + programming skills is what they look for with new people, then just ghost you. The interviewing process in pentesting is just as bad, if not worse, than development. Plus, despite most pentesting gigs being more difficult day-to-day than regular web development jobs, they pay much, MUCH less, sometimes as much as $40k less (80k vs. 120k in a large metro area). All of this is kind of countered by the fact that you can really do bug bounties on your own now, so you may not really need a traditional job. IMHO, you're better off being a developer first before going down that route.
- bane 6y agoCybersecurity, as a field, is in desperate need of identifying different roles within it. These roles are notionally understood within the field, but what they are called and what exactly they do hasn't really crystallized quite yet. You still see job postings for "Cyber-security SME" or whatever and the organization has almost no idea what exactly they want out or the person they hire. So they end up with bored, highly skilled, reverse engineers and pentesters running automated scans, or overwhelmed "security guys" who's career was running compliance checklists being asked to build a defensive intelligence platform. I call this the "Cyber Dash" problem where there's many different kinds of Cyber-<insert job> but the industry hasn't figured out what those are, what to call them, what they do, and what the requirements are beyond maybe a handful of roles.
- aiisjustanif 6y agoIdentifying roles? SANS has done this 10 times over.
- danmg 6y agoThis is a predictable pattern at this point: 1) Employers don't like the fact that the labour they require has skills that a lot of time to become competent at and the labour wants to be compensated accordingly. 2) They get universities to start offering degree programs tailored to churn out new graduates who are willing to work for entry level wages. 3) Employers complain that the grads who come out of these programs are unprepared to do the same job as the old guard. Using Metasploit, Nessus, and nmap should be a 1 credit elective course in a CS degree. Not top billing.
- jrott 6y agoTotally it's the same pattern over and over again we don't want to pay technical talent that can actually do stuff, and won't or can't train the people that are willing to work cheap.
- danmg 6y agoStep 4, in the US at least, is to lobby for more H1B bodies. While they may or may not have the skills that are actually needed, the H1B system makes feudal servants bound to the corporation.
- Whinner 6y agoI’m in Georgia Techs online MS in cybersecurity program and have argued these points a few times. Most of the cybersecurity classes are just CS classes. I think it was just a money grab to repackage their existing CS degree into a more marketable package. I’ve argued that we should have some type of network and OS hardening classes. There is a required network security And secure computer communication class but they are much more about programming vs implementation. The counter arguments I get are that what I’m suggesting is more aligned with a vendor cert. But a lot of cyber security is doing the hardening of os and proper user access. A lot of the cyber students end up switching to the policy track instead of the information security track. They are admitting students with almost no prior CS experience. They get away with only having to take an intro to cyber security CS class. Their remaining classes are all management classes marginally related to security. I’m going to use this article to backup my arguments that there is more to cybersecurity than programming.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bawolff 6y agoSo this article is not what i expected. I agree that hands on skills are important. And i agree that candidates often lack them. But im not sure that the skills in the article are really hands-on skills. For example, the article talks about picking up a book on tcp/ip. That's not hands-on, that is theory. I also question what type of cybersecurity degree program this is, where you don't learn how the internet works? All the things in the article sound like stuff i would expect a "cybersecurity" degree to cover. They don't sound like things that need to be taught practically.
- lormayna 6y agoIn my opinion (working as security architect for an US Fortune500) technical skills are mandatory, but they are not enough for a successful career on cybersecurity. You need to have great communication skills (writing a great pentest report is probably the most important and difficult part), negotiation and persuasive abilities (sometimes you have to accept risks against budget, deadlines and business requirements). In the cybersecurity community I see a certain degree of elitism (don't use Kali, don't use Metasploit, etc.), but we need to understand that they are just tools, so anyone is free to use the tool that is more confident and more appropriate for the tasks.
- leafboi 6y agoIf it can be done without a degree and largely by self study than most of it can be packaged into a course or a book with practice problems and labs that anyone with dedication can finish can complete and come out competent. Maybe such a course that covers what's needed to get into that top 10% doesn't exist yet but I'm sure it can exist and I would gladly pay for such a course to attain the required mastery rather than explore the space haphazardly myself. Do any professional security experts know of such a course? Are any of you willing to start one?
- mettamage 6y agoCall me naive, but isn't simply completing every live hackthebox.eu box a good way to get some practice in to apply for certain security roles? Hacking 20 boxes on various levels to me seems that you have what it takes. The easy ones are Metasploit and so on. The medium ones are attacks like SQLi or injection into MongoDB. The hard ones are simply a chain of those things with a lot less intelligence to go on. The insane ones also put some binary analysis or C vulnerabilities in there (e.g. heap overflows or ROP attacks of stripped binaries). Then again, I'm far too early in my career to know whether simply rooting all live boxes is good enough. Doing so myself has definitely helped me at my job as a full-stack developer to make the company I work at more secure. Here's an example of an "insane" box: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p8XkVDRtTQg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p8XkVDRtTQg And this is a "medium" one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7QXzebQHEWA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7QXzebQHEWA
- aiisjustanif 6y agoThe amount of people completely forgetting and not even mentioning: - Cybersecurity Incident Response, - The behemoth that is SIEM (nowadays called security analytics platforms) and everything else Blue Team - The role of centralized Vulnerability team and Threat Intelligence team. - And Red Team for in-house vulnerability detection to support the previous bullet. Is alarming.