10 ms·
You only pay the R&D costs once. All you're saying is that you have to put a lot into R&D, but that's all on the I side of ROI. It was the same with SpaceX, the
by renewiltord 6y ago
You only pay the R&D costs once. All you're saying is that you have to put a lot into R&D, but that's all on the I side of ROI. It was the same with SpaceX, the I part was huge. The question is whether you can make the R part work. And if you have scale, then the R part moves differently.
It's the same with the first car you build. The first Tesla Roadster cost tens of millions to make. The second Tesla Roadster cost half that.
- looping__lui 6y agoWell, the R side pops up when they optimistically tell you that your 20 min commute is going to cost 70 USD... SpaceX is exactly the WORST example in this context: they just went ahead without all the bureaucratic overhead you find at NASA; they weren’t exactly transporting people at the beginning but cargo... And they had a pretty clear market with fat margins; those margins were fat due to the (unnecessary) overhead other agencies created. You can’t do that in this case. Put a bit differently: you can probably guess the magnitude of costs for a car to develop. In this case, I would be more than surprised if the get within a 10x magnitude in the end for their cost estimate and EVER get it certified. Again: there are currently NO guidelines how to certify that... An example from Airbus and the A400 flagship: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Europrop_TP400 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Europrop_TP400 “Several technical problems delayed the engine's certification test program and pushed the entire A400M aircraft program into further scheduling adjustments. The engine delays were primarily due to problems with completing the full authority digital engine control (FADEC) software to the satisfaction of the civil authorities. More specifically, Europrop determined in mid-2008 that the engine worked correctly, but the FADEC software still did not meet EASA requirements.[27] Since the A400M was intended for humanitarian missions, the aircraft also needed to have a civil certification. Europrop did not realize that this meant the FADEC also had to show traceability and accessibility, so EASA denied civil certification of the software. Because of this problem, the first A400M test aircraft, which was flight-ready by September 2008, was not permitted to fly. Europrop had to triple the size of its workforce to fix the issue,[28] resulting in a FADEC system consisting of over 275,000 lines of code, which was four times more complex than the FADEC software for the largest civil jet engine.[29] Other problems included numerous plane subsystems providing insufficient logging to the main aircraft computer.[30]”
- renewiltord 6y agoThat's a $250 flight which is mostly labour turned into a $70 flight without the labour. That's a marginal cost thing. It goes in a different part of the book. I'm not saying this is doable but those numbers show nothing.
- looping__lui 6y ago? Pilots essentially work for free... It has become “almost industry standards” that young pilots PAY to fly. If I threw a wild guess at 30k USD salaries for these kind of “pilot jobs” with 1000h of flying per year, that puts labor costs to 30-50 USD/h. Maintenance and gas will by far outweigh that.
- renewiltord 6y agoHelicopter pilots in the Bay Area get paid $30k/year? Okay, I don't know that to not be the case but it sounds hard to believe.
- searchableguy 6y agoOP might be talking about europe: https://www.dw.com/en/being-a-pilot-isnt-what-it-used-to-be/a-45038289 https://www.dw.com/en/being-a-pilot-isnt-what-it-used-to-be/... https://dutchpilotgirl.com/pilot-salary/ https://dutchpilotgirl.com/pilot-salary/
- looping__lui 6y agoNo, I wasn’t talking about Europe... I don’t want to “shame” anybody in particular, but look up your local charter airlines and what they offer... This can of course vary if there are rather complex requirements (e.g., a certain type rating, experience level etc.) - but being a pilot isn’t cool financially anymore. A small fraction ends up with “the large airlines” - but if you don’t, you are not in for the big money...
- looping__lui 6y agoI think we have different mindsets here: !every! company in aviation, the automotive or transportation industry is worried about the “I” for the R&D. If there is a factor 10 whatever uncertainty in this equation - you are essentially just gambling like an Options-Day-Trader on Reddit. I understand that investors see “the hockeystick” unlimited revenue upside and justify everything around that. But I personally would not want to so business in the most over-regulated, slow-growing and low-margin industry with a “factor 10 investment uncertainty”; that uncertainty btw renders your investment null, void and lost if your plane doesn’t get certified. And you don’t even have certification guidelines.
- renewiltord 6y agoAre you in the aviation industry? I am not. So know that what I'm saying is based on low-grade near-zero prior knowledge. Would love to know the certainty on your knowledge.
- looping__lui 6y agoI think what matters more is the line of my argumentation. If I was a long-standing aviation industry veteran I would probably not be the source of great innovation and thus be blind for radical disruptions. Automotive and space disruptors had little to no prior knowledge but asked the right questions and had the right arguments... My line or argumentation does not require much aviation expertise: a heavily regulated market with many uncertainties that put the chance of your investment succeeding at a low percentage, require ALL the investment be made before you can test it on the market is a big red flag; even more when the industry is known for very high costs in the innovation space and you are “disrupting” it; add to that that the return on investments have historically been horrible -e.g., google Cessna, Piper, Beechcraft and a dozen other big players that went bust or were very close to it...
- renewiltord 6y agoYour arguments can be independently evaluated. Your claim to facts are questionable if they aren't from knowledge. I'll take it that you aren't in the industry and have priors similar to mine on your knowledge. Thanks for the discussion.