6 ms·
And that can happen quite easily. e.g. A work team went out for an event and got genuinely atrocious service. i.e. Legitimately worthy of a 1 star review. Fair
by Havoc 6y ago
And that can happen quite easily.
e.g. A work team went out for an event and got genuinely atrocious service. i.e. Legitimately worthy of a 1 star review. Fair. Shit service, shit review.
...except somehow they hyped each other up to ALL do so. So that party of 20 left 20 bad reviews.
I wasn't part of that but when I heard about it I couldn't help but think about this effect. One table having a bad time (happens) might have just killed an entrepreneurs dream. :(
- aspaceman 6y agoThat is a brutal and amazingly petty thing to do. I would stay far, far away from whoever got folks to do that. They sound cruel.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- richbradshaw 6y agoI’d guess they don’t really realise the impact it has.
- IsopropylMalbec 6y agoWhat would be the point of a review if it had zero impact?
- whymauri 6y agoCertainly there's a mid-point between 'zero impact' and business-crippling.
- nikanj 6y agoThey served 20 people poorly and got 20 bad reviews. How is that brutal or petty?
- oehpr 6y agoReviews are fuzzy measurements that humans interpret as individual, independent, samples. When you go to the reviews section, your perception is that these reviews are uncorrelated. Correlated reviews are less meaningful, they provide less data. Most people arriving at a review section, seeing 20 1 star ratings, would presume ratings were independent individuals. If 20 independent reviewers each had a bad experiences. That amount of data is extremely telling of the service. 1 singular review, on the other hand says much less. Maybe their waiter was bad and was fired later? Maybe that was a bad day for the kitchen or the staff somehow? Maybe the reviewer came in with a negative expectation and was biased somehow. Maybe there was some kind of culture issue? Reviews arn't measurements, they're fuzzy. And while a party agreeing that they were not treated well is MORE information than a single person, it is no where near the signal strength of 20 individual samples. In this way. They had significantly more influence than was due. It wasn't fair.
- Swizec 6y agoThe difference is that it’s a one-off event. Say you have a bad day at work but usually you’re awesome. This happens to be the day 20 new coworkers see you for the first time. They all tell their manager. Do you deserve to be ostracized forever because you bombed one presentation to a vocal minority? Or should that be balanced against your amazing work on other days? The Algorithm just sees those 20 bad reviews. It doesn’t know about your other amazing days. In the case of a restaurant another dimension comes into play: Serving a table of 20 is a logistical nightmare compared to serving 10 tables of 2. This is why large parties usually call in advance and get a prefixed menu. The restaurant would also ensure extra staffing for that time.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- nikanj 6y agoPeople lose their jobs all the time for a single tweet or customer interaction.
- 6y ago
- JamesBarney 6y agoOne other issue is a lot of restaurants can't handle a group of 20 people coming in very well. So the service they got might not be representative of the restaurants more typical service.
- thephyber 6y agoI think honestly most bad Yelp reviews are mismatches between expectation and reality. I've seen a 1 star review of a decent restaurant because "they didn't fill my water glass often enough" -- no other complaints. Sometimes you pay enough for this kind of service, but most restaurants (especially the ones that take a risk on a new server) are going to have bad days. That said, any bad service or review during the early days of a restaurant are impactful on long term revenues. The slope of the curve in the early days has a bigger effect on the area under the curve.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]