4 ms·
> Now, there are a number of updates one may want to apply to a signed PDF: > [such as] filling in form elements (in documents where multiple people have to fi
by thaumasiotes 6y ago
> Now, there are a number of updates one may want to apply to a signed PDF:
> [such as] filling in form elements (in documents where multiple people have to fill out parts of a form and each have to sign their parts)
> For that reason, signature validators have to decide, for all incremental updates that follow a given signature, whether the changes done by those incremental updates are harmless and constitute an intended use case like the ones listed above, or whether they are potentially harmful and try to give the impression that something else was signed than what was actually signed.
I don't see how filling in form elements could possibly be considered harmless? Why is that listed under intended use cases?
- layer8 6y agoImagine a form that is split into two sections, each of which has to be filled out and signed by a differemt person. The first person filling and signing will implicitly also sign the empty fields of the second person, and the second person will then change those fields to have actual values. The author of the form can specify which fields are allowed to be changed after which signature, and a validator would have to check that those constraints were observed. EDIT: You may have come across forms with fields marked with something like “don’t fill out this field, it will be filled in by the clerk processing the form”. That’s one kind of use case.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> The author of the form can specify which fields are allowed to be changed after which signature, and a validator would have to check that those constraints were observed. This can work, but it seems simpler to just have separate documents for each party to sign. It's easier to understand and much less prone to hidden failures when someone makes a mistake marking fields. If the value you put into a form is irrelevant to whether I sign it, just put that form in your document and not my document.