3 ms·
Paying the minimum in tax allowed by law to reserve the maximum amount of money possible for pursuing your own social or charitable goals is not immoral. The g
by sneak 6y ago
Paying the minimum in tax allowed by law to reserve the maximum amount of money possible for pursuing your own social or charitable goals is not immoral.
The government is not a charity (indeed, Apple HQ’s government uses some fraction of their tax revenues to conduct mass murder) and to argue that anyone is immoral for not paying more tax than is specified by the law is an argument against the rule of law in society.
If you don’t like the laws, take it up with your lawmakers, or with the concept of representative government or democracy in general, NOT those who explicitly comply with the law, and indeed spend millions on staff (and their payroll taxes) to ensure that they do.
- sukilot 6y ago> for pursuing your own social or charitable goals is not immoral. Assumption of facts not in evidence.
- sneak 6y agoLack (or later loss) of those social or charitable goals does not cause the prior act to be (or retroactively become) immoral.
- sneak 6y agoIn case there was any doubt: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/29/us/mackenzie-scott-billion-fortune-bezos.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/29/us/mackenzie-scott-billio...
- BbzzbB 6y agoIt outprortionally transfers the cost of doing business to normal taxpayers, even those not interacting with said companies. It swoops local money and hides it in coffers of unrelated countries. I don't blame them for doing it, I blame it on global politics (it will probably require a global response), but it doesn't make it any more moral or damageless, tho I guess it's somewhat subjective.
- sneak 6y ago> It swoops local money and hides it in coffers of unrelated countries. It absolutely does not. Tax revenues (“local money”) are based on the law and the law alone. It’s simply not “local money” if the law does not describe it belonging to that local jurisdiction. The concept of ownership and rights to money are legal ones, and the cash flows are flowing according to the law. You may argue that it goes against the spirit of the idea of tax, but that is simply not documented anywhere and thus could not be complied with precisely even if someone wanted to. Don’t criticize people for obeying the law as written, and certainly don’t criticize them for not voluntarily donating to organizations that like to use their resources to run torture camps and bomb children.
- BbzzbB 6y agoI don't understand why you are adopting this tone, read my message again as you seem to be misinterpreting it. I explicitly mentioned that I am blaming the laws themselves and not the corporations for abiding by them, it is the entire point and premise of the few comments I left on this thread. These laws are at fault for allowing corporations to make money in country X and pays tax for it in country Y, to defend this form of taxation seems boneheaded to me.
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoApple plays a shell game with revenue and gets away with it. Shkreli plays a shell game with revenue and has to go to prison. Corporations are people right?