5 ms·
It's not just that it's not currently run meritocratically, but that naive attempts to make it meritocratic make it less meritocratic. The easiest-to-achieve me
by jfengel 6y ago
It's not just that it's not currently run meritocratically, but that naive attempts to make it meritocratic make it less meritocratic. The easiest-to-achieve meritocratic tools are the ones that benefit the people already benefitting from the current system.
It's not clear that there is any way at all to make a true meritocracy, since "merit" doesn't have an objective definition. The people who make the definition will always be biased, and will usually do so to favor themselves and people like them. After all, they're meritorious enough to be in a position to make the definition, right?
But even if such a thing exists in some hypothetical universe, it's not the universe we live in. The important part of the article is that it's a belief that you can get to a meritocracy piecewise that leads to errors. Doing the easy things first makes it less and less likely that you'll ever get around to noticing the people being excluded.
- Grimm1 6y agoI don't believe in the idea of a true meritocracy because not only does every system have different things to merit and because often we can't define what those merits should be. Though as someone stated in another comment this isn't all or nothing anyway and the concept of merit can and has been useful at various levels. That said I do believe that making things more equal inherently requires you to re-evaluate how you value people and makes you lean towards things of substance from a person (though what is of substance is still abstract and varied) and less the superficial ques we very very heavily rely on now such as wealth status, school, profession etc etc. Edit: Cleaned up the first paragraph I had rolled two separate thoughts into one run on.
- mytailorisrich 6y ago'Merit' is to be defined in context. For example in the job market one would want people to be hired on merit, i.e. based on their qualifications and skills to perform the job, not based on who they know, race, gender, etc. In the Olympic Games, merit is how one athlete compares to the others in a fair race. This is transparent and fair, and the best we can hope for.
- Grimm1 6y agoSure and I think I said this in another comment somewhere in the thread, merit is probably fine for smaller systems with homogeneous groups. I think both of those qualify. Even then what I look for in an employee is probably different than what you look for so even our ideas of what constitutes a merit are different.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoMerit is fine for society at large, and again we haven't come up with something fairer and more equal while valueing individual freedoms at the same time. It has also the benefit of ensuring a minimum of competence for people in public office and expert positions.
- Grimm1 6y agoI just don't agree there is some objective standard of merit because there isn't, its a subjective concept. That leads to issues because not everyone's system is the same arguing otherwise would be blatantly false.