7 ms·
I see the similarities, but one big difference is that the Red Guards were created by Mao as a way to purge the party of his enemies and reshape society to serv
by BurningFrog 6y ago
I see the similarities, but one big difference is that the Red Guards were created by Mao as a way to purge the party of his enemies and reshape society to serve him more fully.
What's happening in the US emerging from below, without anyone orchestrating it.
- AlanYx 6y ago>one big difference is that the Red Guards were created by Mao as a way to purge the party of his enemies... No -- that's not the case, and that's precisely why I think the parallel to what is happening now is so strong. The Red Guards started in 1966 as a student movement. They later developed a manifesto, which Mao thought he could leverage to his own advantage, so he endorsed its broadcast. This fanned the flames of the movement (being a kind of political endorsement), and from that point Red Guard cells sprung up organically across the country. From that point, things became chaotic and the leadership in Beijing made a series of sometimes opposing moves, some of which tried to restrain the movement to preserve the government and others which fanned the flames.
- missosoup 6y agoThis comment is 100% correct and the fact that most people here misunderstand the Red Guards movement is the terrifying proof that they have no idea what we're dealing with in the US right now. This ideology is not something that strives for or can be steered into a productive outcome, it inherently wants to expand its reach and list of enemies until it takes over the entire world or someone shuts it down. It's the cultural analogue of a cancer, and it masks its initial growth phase by pretending to rally behind a virtuous cause, and then shutting down any criticism of it as anti-virtuous. People from Cambodia, USSR, China, Vietnam, Germany, etc. have seen this before, but the current generation of westerners has not, so they're giving it the benefit of doubt and allowing it to gain momentum - it seems to be rallying behind a virtuous cause, after all. This is what GP and I are saying: alarm bells are going off in our heads because we have 1st or 2nd hand experience of how this plays out. And just like back then, people now are going 'naaaah, it'll be fine'. Lord of the Flies should remain mandatory school reading forever. It's a warning tale exactly about this.
- monocasa 6y agoI mean, Lord of the Flies is fiction. In real life, the boys stranded on a deserted island made a pact to never quarrel, and kept that pact for a half century. https://www.theguardian.com/books/2020/may/09/the-real-lord-of-the-flies-what-happened-when-six-boys-were-shipwrecked-for-15-months https://www.theguardian.com/books/2020/may/09/the-real-lord-...
- Ygg2 6y agoI don't think children now would have the trust enough to cooperate.
- monocasa 6y agoI think you might be surprised. The sense of comradery between the younger gens is crazy.
- jostylr 6y agoKeep in mind that the book that is from, Humankind, while a hope filled book (I enjoyed it thoroughly), makes the point that when we get together, the bonds between people can lead them to do horrendous things to others. Our power to cooperate is our superpower and our kryptonite.
- graeme 6y agoLovely story! That said, lord of the flies had at least 20-30 boys involved, whereas this group was six boys who were already friends. More is different. (Not arguing reality would go the way of lord of the flies, merely that the example above is not definitive. But boy would I like to see the movie they made!)
- nitrogen 6y agoIn addition to Lord of the Flies, we had to watch a movie in my high school (long ago) about student movements getting out of hand, I think it was called The Wave. https://m.imdb.com/title/tt0083316/ https://m.imdb.com/title/tt0083316/ might be it
- 6y ago
- BurningFrog 6y agoI guess we've read different books about it. This is my source: https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0679746323/ https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0679746323/ What Mao did in secret may not be possible to know fully. But are you really telling me that China in 1966 was a free enough society that students could just start an independent political movement that took over the country?
- AlanYx 6y agoI haven't read that book, but the Wikipedia article gives a reasonable account based on what I've read: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Guards#Origins https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Guards#Origins >But are you really telling me that China in 1966 was a free enough society that students could just start an independent political movement that took over the country? It wasn't a free society by any stretch, but the students' radicalism was in line with the prevailing zeitgeist... they denounced university officials as intellectual elites, corrupted by bourgeois notions that threatened the success of the revolution. Meanwhile, Mao faced ongoing struggles to maintain and consolidate power, so he found endorsing their ideas useful. But the movement itself rapidly spun beyond his direct control.
- free_rms 6y agoMao leveraged the movement to try and get himself back in the driver's seat, after he had been sidelined following the Great Leap Forward. He amplified them greatly for his own selfish reasons, which is also happening in our current moment, in different ways. They wound up being, surprise, unpredictable and destructive. (A note, I read that book too, it's good but needs discounting for bias. Anybody who writes Beijing as 'Peking', or Zhou Enlai as "Chou En-lai" in the 21st century has clearly got a KMT-flavored axe to grind. But it also has some great original research.)
- BurningFrog 6y agoYeah, the anti Mao sentiment is very clear. This is not just a factual historical account. It also takes a lot of opportunities to point out how awful a person Mao was, and makes claims about his motives, which don't always seem knowable. Of course, when writing about one of the worst rulers in human history, being a bit judgemental is understandable. But it does make me want to check other sources. On the fact level, there seems to be an enormous amount of work behind the book.
- nappy 6y ago>(being a kind of political endorsement), and from that point Red Guard cells sprung up organically across the country. This is a massive understatement of what Mao's support and endorsement meant, and understating the "organic” nature of what happened after.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pdonis 6y ago> What's happening in the US emerging from below Partly, yes. But it is also being co-opted by people whose actual motives are very different from the perfectly justifiable demands for equality before the law. > without anyone orchestrating it It may have started without anyone orchestrating it, but I don't think it's that way now. See above.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]