5 ms·
Two weeks ago I posted that I was suspicious of using 'cloud' based fitness data aggregation systems: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23775957 https://new
by walrus01 6y ago
Two weeks ago I posted that I was suspicious of using 'cloud' based fitness data aggregation systems:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23775957 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23775957
In this case I hate to be proven right, but it's not looking good for Garmin. There's lots of road cyclists out there with $750 useless watches now. I can tell you that after this event the odds of me ever purchasing a Garmin device that relies on anything 'cloud' based have even further decreased.
Even if the watches can function offline, how can anybody have any degree of trust that all of their previously uploaded data has not been stolen? Based on the reported use of ransomware and the very lengthy downtime, it really sounds like Garmin's network was owned quite thoroughly. Is there some group out there now in possession of hundreds of thousands of .gpx files with detailed tracking points of peoples' residences, favorite running and cycling routes, and what times of the day they're usually away from home? Nobody knows.
After seeing 20+ years and many dozens of instances of data breaches from this that we would now define as 'the cloud', I find that the only solution is to simply not upload to a third party anything you consider proprietary information.
Meanwhile my fully offline or local-workstation-hosted GPX based tracking method continues to work normally.
- SCdF 6y ago> There's lots of road cyclists out there with $750 useless watches now. I can tell you that after this event the odds of me ever purchasing a Garmin device that relies on anything 'cloud' based have even further decreased. They work offline. At least, as much as I use mine it still functions, there may be more advanced features. > Meanwhile my fully offline or local-workstation-hosted GPX based tracking method continues to work normally. You can still get the gpx files right off the watch. Apart from that, this is the classic Hacker News argument of "why do the normies rely on these cloud services it's trivial to <insert giant complicated setup here>". It's awesome that it works for you. My parents, one of whom in his retirement hacks on code that combines local drone captured data with local government LIDAR data and parses it for more accurate maps of his lifestyle block, don't have time for those shenanagins. The expectation that everyone does is folly
- walrus01 6y agoit's not a giant clunky complicated setup - it's a 15 second process once a week of transferring a gpx file from an android phone over to a PC running this: https://www.gpxsee.org/ https://www.gpxsee.org/ If I really wanted to automate it, I would use some sort of tool to do the equivalent of a cron job to scp the files from the contents of /sdcard/bike/*.gpx to my desktop PC.
- vinay427 6y agoYou can do that offline with Garmin watches right now, along with heart rate data, and can view GPS+HR using a variety of online platforms like Strava. The .FIT files are stored on the watch itself and can be accessed over USB. The online features that aren't currently working involve syncing wirelessly with your phone and their servers, and more uniquely analytics on training (effectiveness, recovery, records, etc.) that your method doesn't seem to offer.
- cassianoleal 6y ago> can be accessed over USB True, but some devices (like the Fenix 6 lineup) don't mount as USB mass storage. For those, Android File Transfer [0] seems to work. [0] https://www.android.com/filetransfer/ https://www.android.com/filetransfer/
- SCdF 6y agoAs the other person said, all that you're doing can still be done by these watches if people want to. On your system though: what happens if your computer crashes, gets a virus or you otherwise lose the data? You should probably have a backup system right? Now you're adding more steps, and either doing a reasonable complicated 321 setup manually, or back to involving the cloud. I'm not saying what you're doing is bad, but dismissing easy to use cloud systems is just silly. Ironically I push my runs to the cloud (or clouds, as I go watch -> garmin -> strava) because it's an offsite backup that I don't have to manage. I also then export strava data and re-back it up myself, but I'm a tech nerd so that's just icing. You're also side stepping any social features. I know people who are very encouraged to exercise because they see their friends doing it, or because they get kudos / likes and praise when they post their workouts. This may not be important to you but for many people it is.
- tallanvor 6y agoYou can still copy data from the Garmin watches manually. For a lot of the watches, this is mainly affecting the ability to use Garmin Connect to view your aggregated data. It IS frustrating - I have a Fenix 3, so I can relate. But it is still tracking the activities and the service will be back up, so saying that the watches are useless right now is rather hyperbolic.
- vincnetas 6y agoBut when you think about it currently for most users computer = internet. No internet is almost equal to non functional computer. No gmail, no FB, Insta, Twitter, no news sites, no messaging. For some even no document editing if you are using online editors and are not prepared in advance by installing offline editor office 365 or sketchup). And also not many have offline maps ready. It's scary how much we became dependent on internet connectivity.
- paulcole 6y ago> Is there some group out there now in possession of hundreds of thousands of .gpx files with detailed tracking points of peoples' residences, favorite running and cycling routes, and what times of the day they're usually away from home? Nobody knows. Yeah it’s called anyone who goes on Strava.
- mns 6y agoThe watches are not useless, the only useless thing is the app and the Garmin dashboard. Before, when I had a watch only with USB/ANT client, I used to sync it once per week, the only thing you need to do now is to just get the .fit files and upload them on Strava or whatever platform you want or process the files yourself. I can also still sync Spotify for my music and podcasts, so that works.
- missosoup 6y agoThose watches work perfectly fine offline, and that's how most people use them. Mine isn't even set up to connect to my phone. You don't have a need for a 750 dollar watch with dedicated onboard maps and gps unless your use case is specifically being outside of coverage areas to start with.