2 ms·
> Recording who set a police car on fire and refusing to hand over the recording is a different matter. That might be true if you know that Journalist X has an
by bsder 6y ago
> Recording who set a police car on fire and refusing to hand over the recording is a different matter.
That might be true if you know that Journalist X has an actual picture of the person lighting the car on fire and your are asking for that specific picture.
However, that is NOT the case here. The police are on a fishing expedition and are asking for pictures that "might" include the perpetrators.
Those pictures also might include a picture of someone the police might like to identify in order to exert some intimidation. The fact that the judge limited the scope is not terribly useful. Parallel construction is a thing.
Journalists aren't evil. They don't necessarily want criminals to get away with their crimes. Normally you would just politely ask the journalists to go over their pictures and turn over any that they think would be helpful.
However, after the police attacked journalists on camera, you can imagine that most journalists are more inclined to give the police the middle finger rather than cooperate.
- jojobas 6y agoThe judgement only allows the cops to prosecute arson and gun theft based on the evidence, which doesn't add up with dragnet fishing. The rest is non sequitur.
- jacobush 6y agoExcept in the US, there is parallel construction. So it could help with the dragnet for sure. Given that we at this point don't entirely trust the Police either, they could also just find people in the videos and harass them, right?