3 ms·
I have a lot of sympathy for the telcos on this. They did not volunteer telephone numbers as universal proof of ID. So their threat model was proportional to t
by tialaramex 6y ago
I have a lot of sympathy for the telcos on this.
They did not volunteer telephone numbers as universal proof of ID. So their threat model was proportional to their intended purpose of the identifier. If bad guys steal your phone number and run up $100 of calls, the phone company would eat the charges and get the number back. Of course nobody did that because it wasn't worth it.
Imagine you own a medium-sized residential building, maybe 20 households live there. You issue them all with front door keys. You use pretty good locks, from a no-duplicate series that isn't trivially picked by amateurs. You figure that picking the door or forging a key would be pretty hard so there's no way it's worth it when someone could just kick it down.
Then, to your astonishment, a local jewellery store announces that anyone who has one of your front door keys can now store up to $1M of valuables in safes they've made accessible from the street. "It's totally safe" they assure your residents, "because how could anybody else get one of these front door keys? That'd be impossible".
Um. What? Before you know what's happening, one of your residents is trying to sue you for a million dollars because they proudly used a safe to store their $1M of Bitcoins for some crazy reason and (duh) somebody just got a duplicate key easily enough for way less than $1M and stole them.
- tillcarlos 6y agoI cannot find fault in that analogy. Maybe only add that the whole city starts to run on your keys and you have been seeing this for years already.
- bigiain 6y agoThey not only "did not volunteer" to be a secure identity provider via SMS, they've been actively warning against it for almost a decade: https://www.itnews.com.au/news/telcos-declare-sms-unsafe-for-bank-transactions-322194 https://www.itnews.com.au/news/telcos-declare-sms-unsafe-for... Telcos declare SMS 'unsafe' for bank transactions By Brett Winterford Nov 9 2012 Communications Alliance chief executive John Stanton, representing the interests of mobile providers Telstra, Optus and Vodafone, took the extraordinary step of of declaring the technology insecure in the wake of numerous reports of Australians being defrauded via a phone porting scam first uncovered in Secure Computing magazine. "SMS is not designed to be a secure communications channel and should not be used by banks for electronic funds transfer authentication," Stanton told iTnews this week.