5 ms·
So this is based on one anecdote with one company and this ends up with a blanket statement about society at large?
by ekianjo 6y ago
So this is based on one anecdote with one company and this ends up with a blanket statement about society at large?
- skybrian 6y agoThe story is interesting even if it doesn't prove a trend by itself. Combining it with other evidence is up to the reader.
- arshbot 6y agoHow many anecdotes do we need before we accept there's an issue?
- smnrchrds 6y agoAlways more than what we currently have, until the dam breaks, then people start saying "wow! I had no idea! Why didn't anyone say something sooner?". See police brutality, me too, etc.
- Cthulhu_ 6y ago"Wir haben es nicht gewusst" is what the Germans used after WW2, but part of me can believe it because the world wasn't as connected as it is today. Today though? It does not fly. People know about it, and if they are not actively participating in stopping it, they are complicit - "not my problem, I don't care, blue/all lives matter, what about these crime statistics, muh freedom", these are all people that know about it but do not care, or they do care but they're on the wrong side.
- xenocyon 6y agoSince this is written by a Black person in tech, my guess is that his beliefs are based on a lifetime of being treated as a second-class citizen, and this anecdote was merely a particularly obvious case. However, like you, I am way of anecdotes and put more faith in empirical studies [1]. So what do the data say? Turns out they align with the lived experience of the author: widespread hiring bias by employers hurting Black people. [1] https://www.nber.org/papers/w9873 https://www.nber.org/papers/w9873
- NoImmatureAdHom 6y agoThis is BS. The study is from 2003 and isn't about elite tech jobs. There is evidence that, nowadays, there is a large bias in favor of women and under-represented minorities in, for example, academia and top-tier tech when controlling for resume.
- tptacek 6y agoPresent that evidence, please. The comment you're trying to rebut did you that courtesy; repay it.
- NoImmatureAdHom 6y agoThis is a good point and a reasonable request! Here's one https://www.pnas.org/content/112/17/5360 https://www.pnas.org/content/112/17/5360 Note, when looking at this literature: there is a huge publication bias. Publishing a paper that fits the popular (in social sciences) narratives is easy, publishing one that goes against them (like the one I linked) is hard and may well be career suicide. Also, the bar for what constitutes good enough science in these areas is very low.
- jakelazaroff 6y ago> Publishing a paper that fits the popular (in social sciences) narratives is easy, publishing one that goes against them (like the one I linked) is hard and may well be career suicide. The Occam’s Razor explanation for this is that the popular narratives are popular because most available evidence supports them.
- exolymph 6y agoYes, the person you're responding to made a point about precisely that — available evidence. The file-drawer effect is real and multifaceted, including political narrative strategy. If you don't think that editors consider this aspect of maintaining their journals' reputations, you are simply naive.