4 ms·
What's wrong with do they know it's Christmas?
by mhh__ 6y ago
What's wrong with do they know it's Christmas?
- onionisafruit 6y agoAside from being unpleasant to listen to, it’s the perfect Christmas song.
- hinkley 6y agoBy that definition, so is Please Daddy, Don’t Get Drunk This Christmas.
- earthboundkid 6y agoIt was written in benefit of Ethiopia, a Christian country since before the Anglo-Saxon invasion…
- 9nGQluzmnq3M 6y agoHowever, they actually don't know it's Christmas (elsewhere) on Dec 25, because the Ethiopian Orthodox Church follows the Coptic calendar and celebrates Christmas on January 7th.
- mhh__ 6y agoIt was written in 5 minutes on the back of a napkin by midge ure (and sort of Bob Geldof), the lyrics don't really matter. It was inspired by footage of and visits to (not sure on the chronology of Bob Geldof visiting) of thousands of dying children in tents - the idea was clearly the western idea of Christmas rather than the religious celebration. Small anecdote: When the British song (aforementioned) was written, the musicians went out for fish and chips and got back to work, whereas the American equivalent (We are the world) was apparently catered with an enormous near-banquet for the stars.
- opk 6y ago... the invading Anglo-Saxons were mostly pagans invading a Christian (thanks to Rome) country.
- hinkley 6y agoGo listen to it right now, but first imagine that you are tired of colonialism and exceptionalism from the West. It is a condescending song, even without perhaps the worst line in charity history: Well, tonight thank god it’s them, instead of you. I had forgotten that line was in the song until I heard it again years later. What. The. Fuck. Worse, this line is belted out by Bono, with an unusually tight closeup in his face. He is still trying to do work in Africa. Every time I think of this song, I wonder if he cringes remembering it. Good bits by Boy George and George Micheal, but boy is the rest hard to listen to now.
- mhh__ 6y agoAs I have said elsewhere, it was written in 5 minutes on the back of napkin. The point was making money for charity, which it did. For that reason I doubt Geldof or Bono care. And that line is condescending to the listener, surely. It's clearly not actually saying thank God it's not you. If they had more time Midge Ure probably would've written something a bit less crap but they didn't.
- ajuc 6y agoThe problem with charities like that is that they fill coffers of some corrupt middleman instead of the intended recipients, and even when this doesn't happen - they disrupt functional businesses in Africa by random price-dumping so you cannot plan years ahead because westerners can just flood your market for a year with free stuff out of the blue. All the countries that went from developing to developed - did this not because of charity, but because of globalisation and business. The only charity that seemed to help was reduction of debt and cheap money for investment. The song isn't a problem compared to that. And BTW most of the condescending meaning is infered by western listeners. I'd like to hear the opinion of people from Africa, because often this kind of outrage on behalf of someone is a self-fulfilling prophesy: "I think Africa is backward, poor and unhappy and there's nothing you can do - therefore when you sing about that it's rude, because you are pointing out the thing that can't be helped, like pointing a finger at a person on a wheelchair". But if the song was about some poor part of USA you wouldn't have that problem, because you would assume it's temporary thing that will get fixed. And even if not - all these people can just move to other state, right? Well maybe the problem is with your assumptions? People don't usually think of themselves as a lost cause.