5 ms·
I think this does not mesh well with their mission. They are the Internet Archive, the archive of freely (in the past) available stuff that can't be found anyw
by nine_k 6y ago
I think this does not mesh well with their mission.
They are the Internet Archive, the archive of freely (in the past) available stuff that can't be found anywhere else, in most cases. This is much more fragile than old books which likely exists in thousands of copies anyway.
I do not admire their stance, and am unhappy that they are recklessly jeopardizing their unique thing to make a case where they have a very big chance to lose, without any circumstances forcing them to do so.
This is not how you serve as a warden of a valuable archive. (I know, I know, it's their right and their choice.)
- quazar 6y ago> The Internet Archive is an American digital library with the stated mission of "universal access to all knowledge." First sentence of the Wikipedia article.
- mulmen 6y agoAnd how will they achieve that mission when someone makes the following edit: > The Internet Archive was an American digital library with the stated mission of "universal access to all knowledge."
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- nitrogen 6y agoThey certainly won't achieve their mission by giving up on it because someone didn't like it.
- Reelin 6y agoSciHub and Library Genesis still seem to be doing well enough. (To be clear, I don't think IA is even remotely comparable. I'm just directly responding to what you said.)
- horsawlarway 6y agoI understand you, and vehemently disagree. There is a real and serious risk of having ALL published material eventually fall under "licensed use" instead of ownership. We're rapidly tipping towards a society where you pay rent to license everything, and own nothing. In the short term, I find this model abusive. In the long I think it guarantees we will have a competitive disadvantage against countries that don't enforce this style of licensing.
- patrickhogan1 6y agoIA does NOT own the books. IA is only referencing that they own some of the books to distract readers. The vast majority of books IA is “lending” come from the purported “endorsement” from 130 libraries. Yet there is no explanation if the endorsement means a general “Hey we love IA” or “a contractual relationship that allows IA to lend out copyrighted works licensed by the endorsing library”
- icebraining 6y agoThat was only during the Emergency event, when the libraries were closed, and which they already ended.
- zorpner 6y agoEvery book IA lent, they physically owned at least one copy of. Suspension of waitlists meant that they were lending more copies than they owned; copies physically held by partner libraries.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tohmeiphun 6y agoYou'll own the things you create.
- Silhouette 6y agoYou make a reasonable point, so let's accept it for the sake of this discussion. Shouldn't the response then be to update copyright law, taking into account modern trends in technology and society? Surely the answer can't be to let one private organisation decide it's above the law and infringe with impunity.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoLet's go ahead and put to rest this theory that they're going to cease to exist. They don't have enough resources to be destroyed. Suppose the naysayers are right and they're going to go bankrupt. What happens in bankruptcy? They sell their assets for fair market value. To a new non-profit that uses them for the same purpose. All that requires is that they raise an amount of money similar to what they ordinarily have to raise to continue operating regardless. They do, after all, replace all of their computers with newer ones from time to time already.
- mirimir 6y agoRight. And furthermore, if they could be taken down, that's a bug, and it ought to be fixed. As I understand it, they're already somewhat decentralized, and it wouldn't be a huge stretch to become fully decentralized.
- nordsieck 6y ago> What happens in bankruptcy? They sell their assets for fair market value. Maybe. The other thing that could happen is that their assets get valued by some 3rd party and the publishers own IA's assets as part of the settlement (who presumably destroy them).