4 ms·
>True. As mentioned above, architecture success != economic success ARM is enormously economically successful, they're just not a manufacturer and thus not rem
by simonh 6y ago
>True. As mentioned above, architecture success != economic success
ARM is enormously economically successful, they're just not a manufacturer and thus not remotely a comparable business to the entirety of Intel, fabs and all.
Apple has a perpetual license from ARM, so it doesn't matter who buys ARM, Apple is all set license wise.
There is a risk that a new buyer might under-invest in the evolution of the architecture and future core designs. This is a small but real risk for Apple because they do base their cores on ARM designs. I've seen the argument before that the only thing Apple uses is the ISA, but that's flat out not true. They customise and tune the design sure, but the basic architecture comes from ARM. The secure enclave, for example, is an ARM design. Lack of investment in that core ARM architecture would be a problem.
On the other hand, it would equally be a problem for all the other ARM licensees, many of which are current direct Apple competitors. For this reason such a risk seems manageable from an Apple perspective. They are in a much better position to compensate for under-investment by the owner of ARM that most of their current competitors.
The exception in Intel, because Apple is soon be a direct competitor of theirs in the desktop and laptop CPU space. Hence my use of the work 'current' in several places above. Ultimately though, Apple seems to be on top of their CPU design game. They're already beating the living pants off their competitors on mobile, no threat there whatsoever, and very well placed to beat Intel on desktop/laptop. Underinvestment in ARM would be in inconvenience, but not an imminent threat.
RISC-V is interesting, but I think there's a lot of wishful thinking happening around it. Most of the really interesting RISC-V chips include proprietary enhancements. Theres a serious tragedy of the commons issue going on there that is already a problem, and that issue isn't going away. The sheer amount of talent and money ARM and their licensee ecosystem, including Apple, Qualcomm, Amazon, etc are throwing at the problem simply can't be matched by the ecosystem around RISC-V.
- tadfisher 6y ago> Most of the really interesting RISC-V chips include proprietary enhancements. 100% of ARM chips on the market include proprietary enhancements. I don't think that has any bearing on the adoption of the core ISA, unless you can point to cases where a decision was made to avoid RISC-V over licensing an ISA extension.
- klelatti 6y agoIsn't the point though that a lot of the enthusiasm around RISC-V is that it's 'free' and that's no longer the case if you're using a proprietary extension. Plus you're looking at much greater possible fragmentation than can happen with ARM?
- jasonwatkinspdx 6y agoThe big difference is RISC-V has been designed to handle that situation from the start. That's why the ISA is modular.
- pjmlp 6y agoThere's is no modularity when my code requires a specific RISC-V model from vendor X.
- thu2111 6y agoRISC-V is modular in the same way Windows or x86 is. Yeah, you can break up opcodes into groups and say there's some kind of probe to find out what groups are present. If your app needs that module then you're out of luck - it needs a different chip. This is nothing special and I don't see why it'd change anything fundamentally, competition wise.