4 ms·
20% YoY Revenue increase, 43% YoY Growth in Datacenter Segment. 76% Growth in Non-Volatile Memory solution, another 7% YoY growth in Client Side computing. Thi
by ksec 6y ago
20% YoY Revenue increase, 43% YoY Growth in Datacenter Segment. 76% Growth in Non-Volatile Memory solution, another 7% YoY growth in Client Side computing.
This is truly amazing results.
I get stabbed over at Anandtech every time I made an argument for Intel as an AMD investor. The Internet is full of Intel bashing comments but reality is Intel has been making record revenue quarter after quarter.
For the not so good part.
>The company's 7nm-based CPU product timing is shifting approximately six months relative to prior expectations. The primary driver is the yield of Intel's 7nm process, which based on recent data, is now trending approximately twelve months behind the company's internal target.
The most important bit is that last part, 12 months behind Internal target. To put this into perspective.
Intel original 7nm, ( on the assumption it is still the same 7nm because Intel has already changed their 10nm spec) was suppose to be slightly better than TSMC 5nm+, but not as good as TSMC' 3nm. ( In terms of transistor density, by no means it is the only metric it should be judged on ). It was scheduled for 2019, pushed to 2020 then 2H 2021, and are now looking at 1H 2022, which means in terms of consumer getting their hands on it, it would be more like 2H 2022 assuming no further delay.
Given TSMC has never missed a beat in their execution and has iPhone SoC production. It is highly likely by the end of Calendar year 2022, TSMC would have shipped more 3nm Wafer than Intel's 7nm for the whole year.
I am waiting to see AMD's results.
- bhouston 6y agoWhy hasn't Intel given up on their internal process nodes? Their advantage is clearly not in owning their process nodes at this point. Dump them and adopt TSMC.
- jonplackett 6y agoProfit margin. They want that slice o pie.
- qppo 6y agoThey may be betting that a switchover to TSMC would take as long or longer as doing it themselves. As well there's hubris, sunken costs, and Uncle Sam taking a vested interest in semiconductor manufacturing to take into account.
- eloff 6y agoOne could ague that vertical integration has been their strength up until recently. I don't think it suddenly becomes a bad idea just because they dropped the ball recently.
- rgbrenner 6y agoWho would they order from? Keep in mind they are slightly behind Samsung in ic volume. Samsung is #1 and Intel #2. Almost double the volume of TSMC. It takes a few years to build a new plant. Literally impossible without a very long term plan... and when it’s over they lose control of their destiny. They can beg TSMC for more chips if they want to meet their sales targets, but maybe they’ll sell to Apple or Nvidia instead.
- sct202 6y agoWhere are you getting that number for Intel? Everything I see has Samsung, TMSC, then Micron as the top in terms of wafer production. Intel is like 1/3 of TMSC which is still alot. https://www.eetindia.co.in/over-half-of-global-wafer-capacity-held-by-five-companies/ https://www.eetindia.co.in/over-half-of-global-wafer-capacit...
- wtallis 6y agoRaw wafer counts aren't particularly relevant here, because you can't really re-tool a NAND or DRAM fab into a competitive logic fab. Based on those numbers, about a third of Samsung's wafer count is logic, putting them slightly ahead of Intel (logic and a bit of NAND). TSMC's wafer count (all logic, AFAIK) is higher than Samsung+Intel, but not all of that is on leading-edge nodes. TSMC 28nm and 16nmFF nodes are going to be sticking around for many years to come.
- MrBuddyCasino 6y agoThe numbers are even more tilted in Intel‘s favor if you consider that the foundries do a huge part of their volume business on outdated nodes. Intel doesn‘t do that. They have many times the capacity of TSMC in their market segment.
- pantalaimon 6y agoWhy would they grant their competitor a monopoly?
- trasz 6y agoGiving up manufacturing would reduce Intel to what AMD now is, except with worse designs.
- arcticbull 6y agoThey're clearly not reaping any reward from their process, TSMC has them beat hands down and they continue to show lack of forward progress towards smaller nodes. They have a much bigger IP portfolio than AMD, and frankly, it appears their foundries are a cost center/boat anchor rather than a profit driver for next-gen silicon. They don't have to give up their existing 14nm capacity, but next-generation processors could much more easily (apparently) be fab'd externally.
- trasz 6y agoI'm not sure I agree. From what I remember manufacturing is a big part of Intel's profits. Sure, they might not have the best process, but they still have _a_ process, and customers are willing to pay for it.
- arcticbull 6y agoI agree, there's no reason for intel to shut down their fab, but I don't know that they need to hold progress on their CPUs for like, 5 years now? They can continue to work on their process while fabbing next gen CPUs at TSMC IMO.
- starfallg 6y agoIntel is behind, but not actually that behind. Spinning off their fab business at this point in time is throwing money in to the sea. TSMC doesn't have the capacity to handle the volume of Intel orders anyway.
- orbifold 6y agoOnce they figure out UV, there are lots of in house innovations in the pipeline that could prolong Moore's law for the next 10-15 years. This is according to Jim Keller, who gave talks about how there could be up to 50x density increase. Most of that technology is proprietary and together with TSMC they are heading toward a quasi monopoly.
- galeos 6y agoThis obviously puts more wind in AMD's sails. That said, Intel's Datacenter growth is very impressive. I have been an AMD investor since pre-Zen launch and I think it is fair to say that EPYC sales feel like they haven't reached the levels some have hoped for quite yet. If AMD continue to widen the gap between EPYC and Xeon, I suspect we may look back on this inertia as a bit of a 'roadrunner effect' and in a year or two's time get a shocking quarter where AMD suddenly starts taking surprisingly large bites out of Intel's datacenter market share. Also on the GPU side of things, it is rumored that Nvidia has struggled to get capacity at TSMC and is having to use Samsung's, supposedly inferior, 8nm process for its forthcoming Ampere cards, at least until their 7nm capacity comes online at TSMC. Not sure how much truth there is to this, but highlights the capacity issues that may currently be in play.
- xoa 6y ago>I have been an AMD investor since pre-Zen launch and I think it is fair to say that EPYC sales feel like they haven't reached the levels some have hoped for quite yet. I've been looking just these last few weeks at buying a new Epyc Rome system, and one thing I was a bit surprised (though I shouldn't have been, I just haven't thought about it in a long time) about was that while Rome is incredible as a CPU the whole ecosystem around it has lagged by quite a bit. Specifically, the motherboard selection is still well behind what you can find for Xeon. That's not AMD's fault and there is a bit of a standard egg/chicken bootstrap issue, the market has to be deep enough to really start to fill out the niches. Epyc being so good is what has allowed them to start clawing their way up at all, and the MB scene is already massively better then even the start of this year. Still though it's made it harder for me at least to unthinkingly pull the trigger, every option for my intended use-case entails compromises. There is no perfect fit. I suspect over the next 6-12 months even that will be less and less the case. And hopefully that will mean accelerating momentum for AMD and bring some more long term competitiveness to that market. But it's been interesting being on the purchase hunt and seeing the development in real time, it already feels like the whole game has changed for CPUs but of course everything supporting that lags a cycle or two.
- beezle 6y agoINTC investors are quite unhappy tonight. Down 11.25% at 54.20. Anyone expecting the Robbin Hooders to understand comparative lithography, well... there's a bridge still available in NY. Maybe INTC will still make a lot of money but there's a "nanometer gap", damnit!
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- nicoburns 6y agoIf there really is not further delay, then Intel will be fine. But their 10nm was initially only delayed by 12 months too. And then another 12 months. And another. Intel have big problems if they have those same delays again.
- ponker 6y agoRevenue growth is great but enterprise tech companies can grow revenue long after they are as dead as a doornail. Lotus Notes (!) posted revenue growth in 2008 (!). Intel in some serious shit and the revenue numbers don’t change that.
- trhway 6y ago>Lotus Notes (!) posted revenue growth in 2008 (!). i worked with Lotus Notes in 1997, and even that 1997 version would be miles ahead of many enterprise software in 2008. A super-hyper-important project had finally [and quietly] failed at Sun around 2008 after several years of trying to build a functionality which was just a one item in the large list of 1997 Lotus Notes capabilities :) Wrt. the original discussion - Intel - anekdotally i don't see any moves on our huge mostly C++ platform (with our customers running machines with hundreds cores and terabytes of memory) toward AMD, unfortunately. Giving the cost structure of software vs. hardware, our customers will run only what is certified by us, "minor" theoretical savings on AMD hardware be damned. I think that only when Intel will get really slower than AMD, then the enterprise glacier will start moving. If i were AMD, i'd not even bother with enterprise on-premise datacenter, and would focus instead on those few places where the future is - AWS and the likes. By the time Intel, if it happens at all, brings the price/performance and energy/performance (the metrics which are really important to cloud and not that to enterprise datacenter) back to competitive level, the cloud may be owned by AMD.
- paulpan 6y agoThe 7nm may well likely snowball into a much bigger issue and put the company in jeopardy. E.g. allow competitors to surpass and erode the brand value/perception. This year is already proving to be a watershed one for Intel, largely due to AMD's continued resurgence and taking the performance crown in mobile (Renoir) and expected in desktop (Zen3). Apple announced their move away from Intel silicon and even AWS making strides in their own ARM server chips (Graviton). By itself and without further delays, 7nm will already be a hail mary of sorts due to the TSMC's pace and roadmap. But remember that 10nm yields have not been good so will it be able to handle producing server and desktop chips. If there's another delay (e.g. 7nm in 2023), would Intel need to sell of their fabs?
- DSingularity 6y agoIntel sell the fans? Would google sell it’s search engine?
- abacadaba 6y agonever say never
- shadowtree 6y agoRIM/Blackberry's best quarters happened after the iPhone launch. Unclear if Intel is following that path.
- godzillabrennus 6y agoSeems reasonably clear. The naming convention Intel has chosen for the last 10 years (Core iX Generation X) has basically been a long running joke. The average person can’t figure out if a used machine from 2015 has the same CPU as a 2020 machine. Not that they’ve made the chips noticeably faster for web browsing in that timeline anyway. Basically, this news is the blackberry storm launch announcement.
- rasz 6y agoCommodore reported 7-year record revenue&profit 4 years before going bankrupt. https://dfarq.homeip.net/commodore-financial-history-1978-1994/ https://dfarq.homeip.net/commodore-financial-history-1978-19...
- Torkel 6y agoAs other commenters I'm reminded of the classic RIM roadrunner effect - the decapitated chicken that keeps running. Another thought though: is it completely unthinkable for Intel to pull an AMD themselves and spin out their fabs and rely on whoever has the best fabs out there? I mean - if they are years late with something that is already outdated there are not too many downsides to it.. Next-gen process nodes are now so delayed that they might as well use the time until then to retarget their designs for TSMC/Samsung.
- p1esk 6y agoWhat is already outdated? Is TSMC shipping their 3nm already?
- MrBuddyCasino 6y agoThey can’t. Intel has at least five times the production capacity of TSMC when it comes to the bleeding edge nodes, and companies are already fighting for a share of TSMC capacity, which means contracts will be expensive.