3 ms·
I'm not sure what the issue is here - they wouldn't be deciding whether every post gets posted or not. Presumably they would be using their 'intelligence gather
by helsinkiandrew 6y ago
I'm not sure what the issue is here - they wouldn't be deciding whether every post gets posted or not.
Presumably they would be using their 'intelligence gathering facilities' to identify users that are likely Russian funded or controlled which would get marked or taken down. In the same way that law enforcement agencies might search for accounts undertaking criminal activities.
If they start to get 'innocent' accounts taken down there will be a huge uproar in the press.
- throwawaymanbot 6y agoThere are 2 issues. Mainly Mi5/6 can find out who is Russian funded as is, right now. Lastly, the worst problem would be what we dont know they are compiling for example BLM "activists" and even those journalists who are deemed sympathetic to BLM, who are finding out they have had dossiers compiled on them for the past few years. (See the federal green men "Snatching" certain people off the street) I dont see anyway to stop that abuse.
- mc32 6y agoAren’t you mixing the U.K. with the US? What is MI5 doing to local press?
- jariel 6y ago"I dont see anyway to stop that abuse" Is this abuse happening though? Are CNN reporters getting harassed by the NSA or FBI because they cover BLM? I know probably some in the system would like that, but that does not mean it's happening.
- haunted_otter 6y agothis speaks to an enormous amount of faith in both the security services and the press - the report seems to suggest that the security services are somehow inept and have let their guard down, and yet they should also be handed more power and control. let alone that their activity, by its nature, would be unmonitored and unaccountable
- noja 6y agoDon't they have special letters (I can't remember the name) to prevent articles being run in the press? Don't they have separate courts?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- matthewheath 6y agoThe Security Services and other national security apparatus have "DSMA notices" for the media, yes, but they're not legally binding. They would have to seek an injunction to legally prevent anything being published. There are no separate courts for the intelligence community here. The court hearings themselves can be held in camera and with specially cleared lawyers, but that's all.
- auganov 6y ago> If they start to get 'innocent' accounts taken down there will be a huge uproar in the press. Not so sure about that. The US President has been falsely accused of colluding with Russia and the press (both in America and beyond incl. the UK) cheered these allegations on. Even after they've been disproved by Mueller there haven't been too many retractions (if any?). If the MI5 takes down accounts the press already doesn't like it will probably similarly be welcomed by them.
- AndrewBissell 6y ago"What evidence do you have that these accounts are Russian funded or controlled?" -> "That's classified for national security reasons." "Have they published something which is actually false or misleading, or is it just something which the UK government finds inconvenient?" -> "No further questions at this time."
- machello13 6y agoI've seen plenty of actual people get called "russian bots" on social media for no reason other than people disagreed with their politics. This sounds like a terrible idea.
- Proziam 6y agoI experience this fairly regularly. My views tick a few of the boxes that result in me being called a Nazi among other things. Truly radical ideas like 'I believe every single American, including people of color and transfolk, should be armed to the teeth to prevent against evil government' will put me in that category for some people.
- machello13 6y agoYour politics are definitely out of the liberal mainstream, but they don't have to be to get labeled a bot. Just criticizing the current democratic nominee will do it.
- Proziam 6y agoIt's absolutely true that liberalism has changed shape dramatically. It's almost unrecognizable in it's current form. I wouldn't expect that most people would object to something like this (wikipedia): Liberalism is a political and moral philosophy based on liberty, consent of the governed and equality before the law.[1][2][3] Liberals espouse a wide array of views depending on their understanding of these principles, but they generally support free markets, free trade, limited government, individual rights (including civil rights and human rights), capitalism, democracy, secularism, gender equality, racial equality, internationalism, freedom of speech, freedom of the press and freedom of religion. But even the above comment I made was downvoted, so I guess this is just where we are now.
- coolgeek 6y agoDo you not understand the difference between a rando making such an accusation and a law enforcement or intelligence agency making a documented case? This does, indeed, have the potential to be abused at some point in the future. But at present there is a real, documented, problem that needs to be solved. Let's solve the existing problem, and deal with the potential one if and when it occurs.