4 ms·
This is the same as any other (ab)use of statistics. Forecasting is a valid and useful practice for managing your people and process. Maybe you redeploy resourc
by Spooky23 6y ago
This is the same as any other (ab)use of statistics. Forecasting is a valid and useful practice for managing your people and process. Maybe you redeploy resources to improve response time or schedule shifts to match forecasted incidents, etc. Data collection is pretty awful with this type of data, so good luck doing much more.
But the problem is that the public hears something different when they hear "automated crime prediction". People hear something novel that could prevent crime. After all, if rain is predicted, you grab an umbrella.
The reality is that cops on the street already know where crimes are likely to happen. You'll get some tools to reduce workload on police sergeants doing scheduling and things like data presentation are probably the primary benefit. Not as sexy as minority report.
- iagovar 6y ago> The reality is that cops on the street already know where crimes are likely to happen. As for many jobs. I work as a consultant and I'm surprised how little effort companies do have conversations with their workers. People in the operational side of things is worth listening. In fact, If I'm valued and I have clients that called me several times it's because I like to interviews, focus groups and informal conversations. In the end, if I have to summarize my job, I listen to people and then do some stupid stuff with numbers to look professional and make my client swallow it. That's about it. It's 30k, thanks.
- hutzlibu 6y agoI suppose it is lack of trust. And they do trust you, so they pay you.
- clairity 6y agoyou could simply write a geographic correlation function on income/wealth and race/ethnicity and do just as well at this kind of forecasting, since police find crime where they look, and they tend to look in poorer and non-white areas. further, we need to disabuse ourselves of the idea that we can predict crimes to any degree beyond random (vs. aggregate stats, like crime rates), because it's tantalizing ideas like that which leads to the slide into surveillance and totalitarianism without any real, positive return to society as a whole.
- valvar 6y agoI don't believe anyone on HN is so naïve that they think that the main reason crime rates vary between areas is that police presence varies. Your post makes it sound like you are, but I assume that you only think varying presence skews the numbers rather than generates them?
- clairity 6y agoi would hope no adult is naïve enough to believe police magically appear only where crime is and only addresses clear and existing crime, rather than being embedded in a complicated sociopolitical system overwhelmed by legal pitfalls. those are stories we tell children to comfort them for sleep.
- JoeSmithson 6y agoThe vast majority of frontline policing is in response to an emergency call, so they have no control over where it is. HN seems to think police spend their shift waiting for crimes to happen in front of them.
- hutzlibu 6y ago"HN seems to think police spend their shift waiting for crimes to happen in front of them" Some police stations definitely work that way. And some even close their eyes, so they can go on waiting. It is in the poorer areas, where you could arrest all day long to the point of why bother. Makes sense, if the source of crime is complicated.
- vkou 6y ago> HN seems to think police spend their shift waiting for crimes to happen in front of them. No, but when they aren't responding to calls, they spend the rest of their shift going on fishing expeditions. What do you think traffic cops, for instance, are doing most of their day? What about the cruiser slowly driving through a neighbourhood? They aren't there to respond to a call, they are just running license plates/looking for poorly maintained cars to pull over (Obviously, if someone egregiously breaks traffic rules in front of them, they don't need to look very far - but when nobody's breaking the rules, they can always find someone who looks suspicious.) The thing is, when you only go on fishing expeditions in poorer neighbourhoods/targeting poorer vehicles, you're going to find that will skew crime statistics - and statistical model based on that will direct even more policing towards those areas. It's why in the United States, the higher you are on the income ladder, the more illegal drugs you consume - yet the lower you are on the income ladder, the more likely you will end up in prison for drug use.