4 ms·
> "Financial repression" is one of those heavily loaded political terms that annoys me, because of the implication that the investment class are owed a positive
by roenxi 6y ago
> "Financial repression" is one of those heavily loaded political terms that annoys me, because of the implication that the investment class are owed a positive risk-free rate of return even if that's at the cost of the rest of society.
The investor class aren't owed anything and the jaw dropping foolish policy of bailing out losers needs to stop.
But two points; first just to be clear on terms there is no such thing as a return that is free from risk. The term 'risk free returns' means no risk of the contract counterparty welching on the terms of the contract. The other background risks still exist. Nobody knows what the return on bonds will be in real terms and investors get involved in them with the knowledge that the investment could well be worthless or worth-negative in real terms.
Second - if the rate of return is negative then that really just means nobody rational will be willingly to lend the money to the government. So while I may not be owed a positive rate of return (which makes sense, I can't force anyone to borrow from me) there is no fair situation where I accept a negative (or nil) expected rate of return for taking on real risk.
- cerberusss 6y ago> The investor class aren't owed anything I don't know about your country, but in my country, you would be generalizing. There isn't a specific "investor class" because a large percentage of the population invests due to industry-wide organized pension funds.
- roenxi 6y agoThey aren't owed anything either. If bad decision makers are rewarded then the situation will only get worse and people who don't know what they are doing will accumulate more market power. There needs to be some sort of program to keep people fed and in decent accommodation; but there is too much to be lost rewarding people for standing by idly while bad decisions get made with their money. It is not going to work out well in the long term bailing out specifically the people who are screwing up.
- Nasrudith 6y agoThe funny thing about the second is that there actually are some people who would in fact voluntarily lend at negative rates if they are defined as lower. But that is getting into Forex messiness and stability aspects.
- RobertoG 6y ago>>"Second - [..]there is no fair situation where I accept a negative (or nil) expected rate of return for taking on real risk." Except that governments don't need any market to finance themselves. Even if you want to keep that fiction, you can do something like the European Central Bank is doing with the debt of the Euroarea. They don't buy the bonds directly but they buy them in the secondary market, creating demand. The investor would not buy that bond for the return, only to make arbitrage between the primary and the secondary market. There are many tricks that can be done to hide the obvious fact that governments are not households and control the currency, but, at the end of the day, that's the reality.
- pjc50 6y ago> if the rate of return is negative then that really just means nobody rational will be willingly to lend the money to the government https://www.snb.ch/en/iabout/stat/statrep/id/current_interest_exchange_rates#t2 https://www.snb.ch/en/iabout/stat/statrep/id/current_interes... Swiss National Bank is at -0.75% and still getting buyers. Negative rates are feasible. It is, after all, a free market. There is nowhere else to go and switching into physical assets has a carrying cost and an illiquidity problem.
- roenxi 6y ago> It is, after all, a free market. It is a remarkably unusual free market where a small committee declares what the market price will be. I'm not sure what more it takes to get it called a planned market.
- pjc50 6y agoBonds are sold at auction. https://www.treasurydirect.gov/instit/auctfund/work/work.htm https://www.treasurydirect.gov/instit/auctfund/work/work.htm If investors don't like the price, they are free not to buy them. A notable feature of the Greek crisis was that investors did in fact refuse to buy Greek government bonds, or only offered substantial discounts ("yields"). It is perfectly possible to have a $1 bond which pays $0.95 in 30 years sell for $1, $0.95, or even $0.90.
- roenxi 6y agoThat isn't what characterises a free market though. A free market is one where the price is set by participants without special regulatory powers. I'm not sure about the SNBs specific mechanisms; but the central banks typically stand up and announce what price the market will discover +- some error bands they think are reasonable. It is a bit of a leap to call that a free market. The price discovery is going to discover roughly the price that was announced. I mean, it isn't like the "free market" is going to head off to 2% while the SNB says the interest rate is going to be -0.8%. The correlation between committee announcements and actual rates seem pretty high [0]. In a fairly literal sense that isn't a free market. The outcome of the market is being fixed. [0] https://www.snb.ch/en/iabout/stat/statpub/zidea/id/current_interest_exchange_rates#t2 https://www.snb.ch/en/iabout/stat/statpub/zidea/id/current_i...
- mschuster91 6y ago> The investor class aren't owed anything and the jaw dropping foolish policy of bailing out losers needs to stop. For that the US especially (but also the rest of the Western world) needs to seriously sharpen and actually use antitrust legislation. At the moment there are way too many companies whose failure would cause serious shockwaves across the worldwide economy.