3 ms·
I used to deal with this sort of stolen data (wow, it seems like a long time ago now). A big pile arrived every single morning before dawn. At this scale you'd
by tialaramex 6y ago
I used to deal with this sort of stolen data (wow, it seems like a long time ago now). A big pile arrived every single morning before dawn.
At this scale you'd expect to find clear evidence it was Instacart users e.g. an account with email address dave+instacart@davesdomain.example. If there's nothing like that in the data then it's immediately suspicious, a small site might just not have any users with such breadcrumb trails in their email but a big dump like this should statistically have something because there are lots of people (including me) using a breadcrumb for every account.
This is how I know for sure that one of the banks I used years ago lost all their customer email/ name data even though they denied this at the time when it was news. I get scam emails to the address I gave them even now.
You'd also expect a company that cares about its users data to have plausible looking "watermark" accounts that trip alarms and so they'd be able to confirm this is their data. Even, if they did a proper job, what the source was (e.g. if you send a subset of data to a partner organisation you can add more watermark data and that lets you know if the data is stolen from that partner)
- nsomaru 6y agoHave always been curious about this; if you stole data or are using stolen data why wouldn’t you just strip out the breadcrumb?
- tialaramex 6y agoTwo answers for that: 1. Crooks are lazy. Actually humans are lazy and crooks are human, but even more so criminal activity doesn't tend to come with any quality control. Even obvious data cleanup like fixing escaping often isn't done, because there's no incentive. 2. Breadcrumbs tend to be obvious to a human but a variety of schemes might be employed which means automation to strip them would need to be relatively sophisticated or it'll miss many of them. I used to use breadcrumbs of the form emanniamodXX@my-breadcrumb-domain.vanity.example where XX is two digits signifying when I updated this email address, like maybe 14 means May/June 2009. A human can stare at that address, see it says domainname backwards and realise it's a breadcrumb. But a trivial regex match will miss it.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoI’ve been using spamex for years. You can generate completely random email addresses.