3 ms·
> The title either refers to the art practised by the Magi (the Zoroastrian priests from Persia), or it refers to the fact that the discussion is a discussion a
by simonebrunozzi 6y ago
> The title either refers to the art practised by the Magi (the Zoroastrian priests from Persia), or it refers to the fact that the discussion is a discussion about the Magi
In Aristotle's time, Magic / Magi refers mostly to priests and/or healers, not the "sorcerers" that we might have in mind today.
- gmantg 6y agoIt's the same thing. There were posers and those with practical knowledge. Today it's almost entirely clueless posers.
- krustyburger 6y agoThe way that occultists all claim that all of the other occultists are clueless posers is one of the things that makes the whole lot look rather silly.
- centimeter 6y agoIncluding the clueless posers that fill 90% of hospital positions!
- eru 6y agoThe OECD suggests [1] that there are about three nurses for every doctor. Complain about doctors as much as you like, but most nurses have lots of useful and relevant practical experience. (I think most doctors are probably fine. But I don't need to win that argument to deny the 90% claim.) [1] https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/docserver/health_glance-2017-56-en.pdf?expires=1595477172&id=id&accname=guest&checksum=AC1DC1F8F085B06434DF20ECEBAF6B21 https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/docserver/health_glance-2017-5... suggests
- cyan87 6y agoI agree, I think a lot of context is lost here by wordage that now has different meaning.
- User23 6y agoAlso medicine and magic used to be synonymous until quite recently. See for example the American Indian medicine men.
- ARandomerDude 6y agoAmerican Indians and Europeans have/had radically different cultures. "Magic" and "medicine" have been distinct for thousands of years in Europe.
- lioeters 6y ago> "Magic" and "medicine" have been distinct for thousands of years in Europe. Medicine and magic have been intertwined throughout human history, all over the world. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Materia_medica https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Materia_medica
- yesenadam 6y agoNot sure why you linked to that page, as it doesn't mention magic at all, unless I missed it, apart from this in the first paragraph: "The Ebers papyrus is an ancient recipe book dated to approximately 1552 BC. It contains a mixture of magic and medicine with invocations to banish disease and a catalogue of useful plants, minerals, magic amulets and spells." Materia medica was the old term for what is now pharmacology.
- simonh 6y agoThere's also this bit on Egyptian medicine: "It contains a mixture of magic and medicine with invocations to banish disease and a catalogue of useful plants, minerals, magic amulets and spells." So it doesn't, except when it does. I'd also argue a lot of medicine employed 'magical thinking' such as efficacy from similarity. Herbs were recommended based on their physical similarity to organs or parts of the body. I don't think it's pejorative of early practitioners to point this out. Until empiricism and experimentalism there was no way to reliably clarify what worked and why.