3 ms·
The big problem I see is discussed at the end of the article. Language is difficult to interpret and many times we misinterpret one another. When communicating
by godelski 6y ago
The big problem I see is discussed at the end of the article. Language is difficult to interpret and many times we misinterpret one another. When communicating we have a certain amount of assumptions we make about the other person's argument. If these are in good faith these tend to go smoothly, although there's always hiccups. The problem I see is that we're in a hyper partisan environment so the assumptions we are making about others' opinions are extreme. For example there's two assumed positions on immigration: let everyone in vs kick everyone out and build a wall. Of course the vast majority of people believe something in between (because both extremes are pretty unrealistic) but that's hard to determine without good communication. If you're pro DACA and you talk to someone that is pro restrictions you are likely to assume the person holds the extreme version of build a wall and kick everyone out (as in White Nationalism) despite that they probably have a more nuanced viewpoint. I believe this is happening because 1) the news is showing us these extremist people because it generates more hate, and thus more views/clicks and 2) people are co-opting some of these terms to dog whistle so it is hard to distinguish who is dog whistling (aka a white nationalist) vs who is oblivious to this context and using it in earnest. Which if it is latter, presuming they are the former makes it more likely that they turn to the former because you back them into a corner where that's where they can get support from.
This all, I believe, comes down to a phrase I have been finding myself repeat more and more.
> There are three components to communication: What is meant, what is said, and what is heard. They don't have the all be the same thing.
So I think we need to better train ourselves to try better at hearing what was intended and trying to say what we mean. In addition we need to stop turning to this reactionary based news, I believe this is why many (including myself) have turned off social media. Having lived in many parts of the country what I've learned is that everyone, no matter how simple their education is, has a nuanced view on everything. But I've also learned that trolling people, exaggerating arguments well beyond their merit, and "winning" have become more and more acceptable. There's a lot of people who just want to "get 'em" with a sick burn instead of having a conversation. I believe this is where we have broken down (and yes, I do think this is all related to the cancel culture).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- slowmovintarget 6y agoI agree that we need to be better listeners. I disagree that this is the reason for cancel culture. This isn't about misinterpretation. It's typically about bad-faith interpretation. There's a very deliberate effort to destroy anyone who disagrees in the slightest from an ideology. When you disagree, anything you do or say will be construed, regardless of how tortured the reasoning, as meaning what the cancel-mob wants it to mean, in an effort to destroy your life. This is straight out of the revolutionary playbooks. "Rules for Radicals", Lenin's brand of Marxism, Mao's Cultural Revolution... This is not "oops, they misunderstood." It would be a much smaller problem if it were that.