7 ms·
Dear Slack, You're selling something that isn't a product. Standalone chat is a feature, and you won't win against a full product offering unless you drastical
by echelon 6y ago
Dear Slack,
You're selling something that isn't a product. Standalone chat is a feature, and you won't win against a full product offering unless you drastically reduce your prices. You need to get acquired (by Google or Facebook), because I don't think you can innovate an office productivity suite fast enough to compete. And that's clearly the enterprise puzzle piece where chat fits into nicely.
Microsoft isn't being anti-competitive here. Out of all the FAAMG, they're the one that least resembles a monopoly.
You're struggling because you are selling chat as a service. Something that has been free since IRC and AOL Instant Messenger. Something any fifteen year old can write with web sockets. You built a pretty (through opinions vary) version with access controls.
You had a chance to build a moat and make acquisitions to fortify your position, but you didn't do it. You invited competition from Microsoft and instead of doing something, you rewrote your Electron layout six times and made a WYSIWYG that everyone hated.
You had four or five years to do something. You had a chance most startup companies dream of. But here we are. You squandered that chance while you reveled in hubris.
You're going to get eaten, and there's not much you can do about it now.
- thinkingkong 6y agoSlack is in a tough position but they don't really sell "chat as a service" as much as they sell an incredibly convenient workplace experience. They're like the netflix / amazon of enterprise; convenience and ease of use is their product more than anything else. From everything I've read, heard, and experienced, Teams is way worse of an experience. What MS _can_ do that Slack can't is append Teams as a line-item it to an existing invoice, or shift spend within a contract. It happens; Salesforces does this with Heroku.
- nickpeterson 6y agoSlack has created the blueprint of what to make. It’s much easier for MS to copy those features until the difference between the two products is small. I think Slack is hoping their focus will save them, but in the end they’re going to lose most of their MS oriented customers
- IncRnd 6y agoWhat is unique about what Slack has created? The Slack app is in many ways a closed email app with tons of features removed.
- mping 6y agoIt doesn't matter, it has become the reference already. You could say the same about Nike or BMW or Dropbox. The truth is that these brands enjoy a certain (literal) mindshare (through proper execution) that is hard to replace.
- IncRnd 6y agoThe point is that Slack is not difficult to replace. In fact, it is extremely easy to replace Slack.
- mping 6y agoIt's easy to replace Slack the tech, it's hard to replace Slack the app that people are used to when they say they want a chat app for their company. It's like saying Windows is not difficult to replace. Technicaly true but practically false.
- IncRnd 6y ago> It's easy to replace Slack the tech, it's hard to replace Slack the app that people are used to when they say they want a chat app for their company. Well, that's not true. That is easily refuted by it having been replaced at least once. > It's like saying Windows is not difficult to replace. Technicaly true but practically false. While you may believe that Slack offers something that other solutions lack, that simply isn't true. I know of two companies which have replaced Slack, one with a commercial offering, and the other with an in-house solution. Rewriting most of Slack is a week-end project. Slack, over time, actually locks a company more and more into their ecosystem, since to have history you must pay them. With many other solutions, including 50 year old email, messages can be stored locally and filtered as is beleived to be appropriate by each user. If all you want is a chat bot with channels, then use Slack, and throw it away when you're finished.
- basch 6y ago>You need to get acquired (by Google or Facebook), because I don't think you can innovate an office productivity suite fast enough to compete. Dropbox, Box, Asana, Airtable, Zoho, Amazon, Adobe. There's other ways they could grow to become Microsoft that don't start with document editing. Adobe in particular would be an attractive mix. Google and Facebook sound like mediocre homes, because they already offer such overlapping suites, but maybe its just about user acquisition. Oracle would probably be interested in monetizing chat. At the end of the day though, they will need a competitive spreadsheet offering. Everyone needs spreadsheets.
- lewisjoe 6y agoYes, unlike other softwares office suite is too complicated a problem to pursue. Zoho's cloud office suite is the only thing that comes close to Microsoft's offerings. And Zoho does offers a spreadsheet software as part of its suite.
- mavsman 6y agoLove, Kevin O'Leary
- TazeTSchnitzel 6y agoWhy can't a chat platform be a product? Chat has only been free when run by volunteers or funded directly or indirectly by ad revenue or bundling with another service. Slack is not MSN messenger, it's an team communication package for companies in the same way that, for example, Zoom is, though the two have different primary focuses.
- raesene9 6y agoIMO it's too easy for competitors to create a similar level of functionality for it to be a standalone product. If Slack charges too much, there's a host of free alternatives that can be used, meaning they have limited ability to increase prices. Compare that to office suites. There's not that many options here and it's pretty difficult to build something that would have the functionality that enterprises think they want/need and compete with incumbants like MS. The main free alternative (libreoffice) has had recent struggles with funding, due to the level of work needed to maintain and improve their offering
- scoutt 6y ago> Why can't a chat platform be a product? It can be a product, but I guess it will have the same fate as Web Browsers. Who buys a browser product nowadays? Web-browsing is a feature. > team communication package A.k.a chat program.
- rgrs 6y agoBrowsers were bundled free so that the company behind majority user share could later control the web standards.
- xnx 6y agoSlack doesn't need to be free, but it's overpriced for the value it's offering. Same story with Zoom.
- rburhum 6y agoAnd yet they both have tons of customers and increasing revenues... they must be doing something right, no?
- _jal 6y agoI generally agree. I think Slack had a very small window to keep pushing and missed it. (The complement didn't have to be an office suite, but that's the most obvious one.) What it needs now is someone who can add (for want of a better term) "knowledge management". The search sucks; it is just garbage. But beyond fixing search, it needs... something. I started sketching an idea involving users tagging comments as a baseline something to try to make it more than a realtime stream of undifferentiated business info. Your Slack history contains a ton of info your company needs. Too bad you can't find it if someone said it last week.
- TazeTSchnitzel 6y agoA simple thing that could improve Slack would be to be able to retroactively mark where a conversation started and ended, what the topic was, and what the conclusion was. It would be especially good to be able to move unrelated messages that appeared in the chat at the same time to be in their own conversations.
- ThrowawayR2 6y ago> "Your Slack history contains a ton of info your company needs. Too bad you can't find it if someone said it last week." Amen. It's deeply ironic that email threads actually work better at this use case than Slack does, despite it being Slack's alleged raison d'etre.
- mercer 6y agoWhat Slack also needs is a good set of native clients. I try to think from the 'regular user' perspective and often assumed that they just don't care. I figured they'd have Slack open on their desktop all the time at work, or just not care about load times or battery drain. I figured that was just one of those '(web) developer things'. But I've been surprised at how much friction there is to using Slack with various non-nerdy clients I have. They'll constantly send me messages via WhatsApp or even Telegram. The ones that I've convinced to use Trello often start using it for their own stuff. But Slack is a slog to them. Mostly the desktop clients, but I've heard a number of them complain about mobile (which I don't use much, but I thought was native?). Whatever Slack is doing right, whatever its other problems, surely the fact that 'regular folks' feel friction using a chat app that one is supposed to regularly use is a cause for concern!
- pwinnski 6y agoI somewhat agree with you, but I remember how Steve Jobs said much the same thing to DropBox, but DropBox beats iCloud in nearly every way to this day.
- bhupy 6y agoYup, and as commendable as it was for Dropbox to beat those odds, I guess the idea is that Slack ought to do the same without filing a lawsuit. Dropbox didn't get to where it is today by suing Apple.
- ceo_tim_crook 6y agoI dunno I find iCloud on mac and OneDrive on Windows both to be much better, Dropbox is kind of annoying on the desktop tbh
- larrik 6y agoExcept price. $10/month minimum is a steep cliff, and I just can't justify it.
- magicalhippo 6y agoIndeed. I'm near the 5GB limit, and Dropbox keeps annoying me about paying, but for 10/mo I'd rather go with OneDrive and get Office along for the ride. Not that I need 1TB of cloud storage at all, which is why I haven't committed to either yet.
- mercer 6y agoA few years ago I'd have agreed, but I actually stopped using Dropbox because both Apple and Google offer something that is finally 'good enough' and I couldn't justify 10 euro a month for a tiny bit of convenience. And at least anecdotally, Dropbox has completely disappeared in the world around me. I used to get links to stuff in someone's public folder, or be added to a company/person's dropbox to collaborate, and all of that's gone now. It's usually Google Drive, sending stuff around on Slack (which I'm not a fan of), or back to email attachments. Maybe that's just very particular to my situation, but considering the variety of people I interact with as a freelancer/consultant, it doesn't bode well for Dropbox in NL at least.
- vmception 6y ago> You're struggling because you are selling chat as a service. Yeaaahhh I used to think that. Until I expanded to Asia. Chats as platforms and general portals to the internet is pretty amazing, despite the drawbacks to the centralized control that some of the chat app implementations. For the last several years when I open a new business bank account for an online-only service and the banker asks for my website, I correctly tell them I don't have one, as everything happens over chat apps, and "websites" are an antiquated, useless, unnecessary form of validation for North American and European markets for a pyramid of ad/web design/tracking services and are simply not a barrier in selling a product online. Bots for slack/discord/telegram and platforms in asian markets all leverage pretty robust environments. Whereas in the past (and many people still do this) it was necessary to build a whole website and your own platform with the hope of reaching users like with mobile apps that have so much friction to reaching you. Can they complement each other? sure. But you should just keep selling those shovels to other companies stuck in the last decade, while building something with much lower barriers and efficiencies for yourself. I think Slack is on the right track. They can monetize their api and bot marketplace.
- mercer 6y agoPerhaps that supports OP's general claim though? I've been excited about what the general 'chat UI' can accommodate and love API's like that of Telegram that allow a ton of custom UI and functionality that augment chatbots. And it's been frustrating to learn how in Asia this unified interface offers portals to tons of stuff that in the west I need to visit (shitty) websites for (putting aside the issue of the web technically being more open than something like WeChat). My impression is that Slack hasn't really done much to try and bring the 'chat UI' to the masses, even though they have a lot of power to try and do so. Telegram seems to have done more, including of course native desktop apps that I feel comfortable having open all the time. While it's true that other chat-offering companies haven't done much either (WhatsApp doesn't even have bots?), or perhaps it's just really hard to change a culture, it still feels like Slack could've put a ton more effort in trying to bring what's clearly working in Asia to Europe/US/etc. I might be wrong though; I've mostly been reading up on this on occasion and never really dove into any of it beyond building Telegram bots to scratch my own itch. But I picked Telegram because it has much better apps for all my devices, so there's that at least. By all means correct me though. I really, really want chat-based solutions to so many things. It's nice, for example, to be able finally order most of my takeout online with so much less friction than in the past. But it feels silly to have to make an account with at least two providers, open their 'bespoke' apps or website, learn their UI, and so on, when I'd much prefer having an ongoing 'conversation' with the restaurants of my choice where, say, I can re-order an earlier order or pre-populate an order by scrolling up the chat history and picking an order I liked. or to be able to chat with the courier/restaurant about delivery rather than having to deal with whatever shitty home-built interface the restaurant or delivery service offers.
- ceocoder 6y agoI see this IRC argument come up quite a bit every time Slack or like thereof are mentioned, especially on HN because - you know hackers, quite a few of us used IRC and still have a bit of nostalgia about it. However, please consider this as a thought experiment - how many of your family members, co-workers (especially people from non tech/non STEM backgrounds) were able to successfully use IRC or you used IRC to communicate with. When we had IRC server at my current job before we switched to Slack, it was an insular club of engineers with a high bar of entry - you need to know how to setup clients and create alts if you wanted to use on multiple devices and know decent amount about IRC to use IRC. Now contrast that with Slack, it is used across Sojern by 100% of our team - commercial, marketing, product, c-staff, and engineering alike. UX is designed to get out of your way and make it easy to communicate rather than act as a "filter" or "bar" or "must be this haxx0r to use", in addition my family has a slack workspace we use for various things and that includes - again the least technical member of my family - my mom, who is a Pharmacist but not the most tech savvy - she has zero issues using Slack. It is easy to dismiss something as "just a chat product" but then again, it is incredibly hard to make a product that is so easy to use that everyone can use. Reminds me of that comment about Dropbox from years ago https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9224 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9224
- addicted 6y agoMSN Messenger. AIM. Yahoo Messenger. Skype. GChat. iChat. etc. There was a whole list of extremely popular chat products that were used by people who wouldn’t even have been able to log into Slack with the level of computer literacy they had at the time. Personally, I think what happened was that GChat became popular, and killed all the alternatives, and then basically stagnated and confused the shit out of its users through hangouts etc. Slack was one of the first products that realized that since GChat had gone, there was a huge gap in the market. I’m hard pressed to think of any area where they were beyond predecessors in either ease of use or features (I can’t remember if persistent chat rooms were available in all the other messengers) beyond those little custom emoji things.
- keithnz 6y agoI started on IRC not too long after it was invented, and I saw, even in the terminal days, lots of "regular" people use it, once SLIP and PPP became popular, things like mIRC made it pretty easy for most people. Microsoft even made comic chat for it https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Comic_Chat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Comic_Chat But open systems got overtaken by walled gardens.
- cik 6y agoI think they're actually jilted by Microsoft kicking the tires, then deciding not to buy them. By expanding Teams and integrating it into Office... well, when I work in that way the experience really is way, way, way, way (did I say way) better. Slack doesn't fit in nearly the same way, within that ecosystem. At the same time, I think Slack has an exit problem. As you've said, they're selling chat. They have to hope to be acquired - but by whom? Google already has 12 platforms. Facebook has 2, and famously doesn't compete on this part of the business side. Similarly, many of my friends companies have left Slack for things like RocketChat, Chanty, or Mattermost.
- fauigerzigerk 6y ago>They have to hope to be acquired - but by whom? I think Amazon may well feel a need to go up against its cloud infrastructure competitors Microsoft and Google with its own set of office/collaboration offerings. And they have a pretty deep cooperation with Slack already. (Disclosure: I am a Slack shareholder)
- edoceo 6y agoAmazon makes Chime for the communication solution. Don't need Slack
- fauigerzigerk 6y agoThen why is Amazon signing up its own employees to Slack? This looks like pretty close cooperation to me: https://www.theverge.com/2020/6/4/21280829/slack-amazon-aws-partnership-amazon-chime-voice-video-calls https://www.theverge.com/2020/6/4/21280829/slack-amazon-aws-...
- swebs 6y ago>FAAMG Seriously?
- kkotak 6y agoYou're right, it should be FMAGA.
- rgrs 6y agoAre you sure that it is just a chat as a service? My freelancer friends write bots for Slack that integrate various other products to work within slack. They would say Slack is a "platform" for communication.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> Microsoft isn't being anti-competitive here. Out of all the FAAMG, they're the one that least resembles a monopoly. Ouch, what happened to Netflix?
- tabbott 6y agoI run an open source team chat product (Zulip) and I have no love for Slack (https://zulip.com/why-zulip/ https://zulip.com/why-zulip/). But I also think Microsoft's behavior in the team chat market is definitely anticompetitive. * Many businesses have purchasing rules that discourage buying 2 duplicate products -- so by bundling a bad team chat product with Office 365, they significantly reduce Slack's ability to get paying customers simply because of their monopoly position (not because of their product's quality). * Microsoft is in a market position where they can effectively bribe potential customers with discounts on other services they sell (E.g. we'll add another $250K in Azure credits if you agree to go all Microsoft). > You're going to get eaten, and there's not much you can do about it now. This I agree with -- but the reason is that we're in a world of essentially unconstrained monopolistic tech giants, and it's basically impossible to stop a tech giant 100 times your size from taking your market if they really focus on doing so. And Microsoft is clearly very focused on the team chat market. There are very few markets where it's possible to create a moat that can resist a monopolist copying your product (however badly) and then making the price of their copy zero (or negative!). I don't think we should accept a world where the only long-term outcomes for a fast-growing technology company are to be acquired or destroyed by a tech monopoly. > Something any fifteen year old can write with web sockets This is a common misconception. While you can make "chat" as a demo with any web framework, nobody would willingly use that tool. Creating a team chat user experience that isn't terrible requires a huge amount of work because there are hundreds of features that significantly improve important workflows for large classes of people (if you don't believe me that it's hundreds, read https://zulip.readthedocs.io/en/latest/overview/changelog.html https://zulip.readthedocs.io/en/latest/overview/changelog.ht... and https://github.com/zulip/zulip/issues?q=is%3Aissue+is%3Aopen+label%3A%22new+feature%22 https://github.com/zulip/zulip/issues?q=is%3Aissue+is%3Aopen...).
- legopiece 6y ago> Something any fifteen year old can write with web sockets. This is clearly a case of confounding an app being easy to use, with it being easy to build [1] [1] - https://graymatters.substack.com/p/-why-easy-to-use-apps-are-complex https://graymatters.substack.com/p/-why-easy-to-use-apps-are...