4 ms·
> basically requires that everyone involved be extremely experienced, and kept together as a team for years Yep, that's the issue. Businesses can't codify tha
by shadowgovt 6y ago
> basically requires that everyone involved be extremely experienced, and kept together as a team for years
Yep, that's the issue. Businesses can't codify that approach into a process because they can't make any guarantees around that.
Your approach is "conclave of wizards." It's a high-output approach that is the right thing for some problem domains, but (a) it isn't repeatable and (b) it isn't sustainable (if a critical mass of wizards leave the conclave, what is the company to do? Give up and shut down?)
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y ago> Give up and shut down? In some cases, yes. That's exactly what needs to happen. If the business model is dependent upon the "conclave of wizards," then they are a critical path resource, just like a major supplier or business partner, which, if withdrawn, could doom the company just as certainly. If the corporation refuses to treat that resource as a valuable, critical resource, then they don't deserve to stay in business. Managing that type of team is not something that is really taught in school. It comes from experience, and also requires a level of empathy that is, quite honestly, almost nonexistent in today's business culture.
- shadowgovt 6y agoIndeed. So the correct thing for a business to do for both its short- and long-term survival (since we can't know a-priori whether the conclave of wizards will be stable) is to minimize the odds of forming one in the first place. Businesses are structures that minimize risk. A core set of specialists who can't be replaced without tanking the business's performance is a risk. And a hard-to-quantify one at that. Unless, of course, the business is not setting out to minimize risk, but instead to shield some less-risky structure from outsized risk exposure. Like, say, a startup company funded by angel investors trying out experimental technologies in the hopes of hitting on a jackpot new system that a big corp could then buy. If they fail, only the angel investor money is gone. If they succeed, a risk-averse business can buy a valuable asset. But the first thing that business will want to do to maintain its long-term risk profile is fire the wizards. ;)
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoBut...those "wizards" can do some unique stuff. Most of the time, the only reason to have them, is to do stuff that a "generic" team can't do.