3 ms·
This is a good and interesting read regardless, but I'll just point out that when studies are properly controlled for confounders, the "relationship with the ea
by kqr 6y ago
This is a good and interesting read regardless, but I'll just point out that when studies are properly controlled for confounders, the "relationship with the early caregivers" matters much less than we want to think. Maybe not even at all.
What shapes us are our interactions with our early peers. This makes sense from a hunter-gatherer point of view too; those are the people we will spend almost all our life with.
I highly recommend reading The Nurture Assumption for more on this. The author effectively argues with evidence for why relationships with parents are nothing more than relationships with parents.
It really opened my eyes both for things that went on in my upbringing, the upbringing of people I know, and taught me what is going to be important as I raise my son.
- hrktb 6y agoI think it comes down to how extreme the relation is. In the article there ia a large portion about abusive relationships and other cases warranting a therapist's intervention. In these situations, sure parents behavior will leave a strong and lasting impact on children. For more standard cases, parents will provide a supporting enough environment (even if not perfect) and will make their kid interact more with the world, be it school, activities etc., limiting the impact of their own direct behavior. To get back to your point, parent's thinking and behavior is fundamental IMO, but usually not just in a direct, person to person way. It would be more on the environment and social position they provide to their children.
- kqr 6y agoAll true. Very well put.
- doboyy 6y agoI feel this is a more accurate assessment. The relationship between abuse/quality of parenting and anxiety/disfunction can't be thought of as linear. When parenting starts qualifying as abuse, there is a pretty steep increase. Otherwise, genetic temperament and environmental interactions have more influence.
- HumblyTossed 6y ago> This is a good and interesting read regardless, but I'll just point out that when studies are properly controlled for confounders, the "relationship with the early caregivers" matters much less than we want to think. Maybe not even at all. No, it matters. Baby cries, caregiver shows up. Repeated over and over, that's how babies form bonds. Baby has a need, need is met. If the need is not met, that is trauma and it affects the way baby forms bonds. Forming bonds starts this early and it matters a lot.
- kqr 6y agoChildren are far more resilient than they get credit for. Short of actual abuse, malnutrition, or other terrible things, crying (and not meeting social needs) is not obviously harmful for baby. Sure, baby will have a weak(er) bond with their primary caregivers if that happens, but it does not affect how they turn out later in life with other people. If it does, it is only after genetics and same-age peers have had their much bigger effects. I do recommend reading The Nurture Assumption, which is about that specific assumption that the relationships with parents would be important in all other thing in life. It has not been proven in any strong studies.
- srean 6y ago> but it does not affect how they turn out later in life with other people. Citation please, because there is a lot of peer reviewed literature that claims the exact opposite. One place to start with that literature would be Bowlby.
- kqr 6y agoI did cite Harris' The Nurture Assumption, which argues this incredibly lucidly. IIRC she does reference Bowlby too.
- srean 6y agoThanks for pointing it out, its not a peer reviewed publication but its at least something. Its a minority view though. Here is what Wikipedia has to say about its reception: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Nurture_Assumption#Reception https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Nurture_Assumption#Recepti... The Nurture Assumption received mixed responses. The neuroscientist Robert Sapolsky says her book is "based on solid science".[6] The psychologist Steven Pinker of Harvard predicts that the book "will come to be seen as a turning point in the history of psychology".[7] However, the psychologist Frank Farley claims that "she's taking an extreme position based on a limited set of data. Her thesis is absurd on its face, but consider what might happen if parents believe this stuff!"[6] Wendy Williams, who studies how environment affects IQ, argues that "there are many, many good studies that show parents can affect how children turn out in both cognitive abilities and behavior".[6] The psychologist Jerome Kagan argues that Harris "ignores some important facts, ones that are inconsistent with this book's conclusions".[8] Harris rejects the idea that The Nurture Assumption will encourage parents to neglect or mistreat their children.[9] She maintains that parents will continue to treat their children well "for the same reason you are nice to your friends and your partner, even though you have no hopes of molding their character. For the same reason your great-grandparents were nice to their children, even though they didn't believe in the nurture assumption".[10]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- germinalphrase 6y agoAttachment theory has been extensively researched. I’m all for alternative views - and entirely agree that early peers are significant; however, there are some fairly regular, predictable, and significant outcomes that come from parent-child relationships. I don’t think it can be so easily dismissed.
- kqr 6y agoAll of the significant ones I know can equally well be explained by genetics or early peers. Do you have a concrete example where these are controlled for and the effect remains?
- germinalphrase 6y agoMy wife is the one who does this for a living - but my understanding is that, for example, 1) disorganized attachment is not predictive of later social, emotional, educational and mental health problems but is a moderate to significant risk factor, 2) infant disorganized attachment expression should not be used to assume parental abuse, but has a strong correlation with parent-child relationships featuring abuse, neglect, emotional dependency, etc., 3) while a risk factor, other safe/stable/nuturing relationships early in life can mitigate the negative potential effects. I don’t have specific citations, and I’m not arguing it’s rock solid, settled science, but suggesting parent-child relationships may have no effect at all is out on the edge of reasonable.
- kqr 6y agoDespite what one may think, I agree with most of what you said. Only with some additional observations: 1) We would expect attachment problems to be a risk factor purely based on genetics and environment. Which is indeed what we find. Personality traits like that have stronger correlation with a) your biological parents than the parents you grew up with, and b) your friends' parents than the parents you grew up with. 2) Absolutely. The way a child views their relationship with their parents is a huge signal about what their relationship with their parents is like. 3) Yes, because environment effects are the next most important thing, after genetics. Genetics and environment outside of the home is strongly correlated with parent relationship, which is why this is so hard to study and get right. It is possible to control for those factors though, and the result is surprising -- but makes sense from an evolutionary hunter-gatherer perspective.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoHow much of your agreement with The Nurture Assumption do you think is from the Most Recently Read Book Fallacy? I find I’m easily persuaded by good writing, and the most recent book I’ve read tends to hold an outsized slice of my thinking until I’m a book or two past it.
- kqr 6y agoI wouldn't be able to say. Probably more than I would like! I have been seeking opposing viewpoints since I read it, though (which is part of the reason I wrote my comment here), and none have yet been very convincing.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoNow you’ve got my attention. It’s that one by Judith Rich Harris?
- kqr 6y agoYes.
- isoprophlex 6y agoThe existence of several attachment disorders, where insecure parenting styles and resulting poorly developed attachment has been irrefutably shown to be the cause of the disorder, refutes any claims that "the relationship with early caregivers might not matter at all" For an extreme result of poorly developed attachment see https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reactive_attachment_disorder https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reactive_attachment_disorder Several comments here are dismissive of attachment theory and the importance of proper development of attachment. I don't really know why but it might be the unfortunate existence of the pseudoscientific "attachment therapy" which has nothing to do with what the article is about: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attachment_therapy https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attachment_therapy
- staycoolboy 6y agoI think the reaction you are seeing has to do with Attachment Theory used as a cudgel by speakers to allow narcissist and egotists to dismiss their shitty behavior. Esther Perel is a great example. She's like a modern day Ayn Rand who thinks listening to your partner is akin to cutting off your own arm. And she backs that up with wave after wave of attachment theory gibberish.
- Nasrudith 6y agoThat sounds like an extension of Attachment Therapy as a tool for narcicists. It fits the same "narcissists looking to abuse children for not loving them like they believe they are entitled to - and the horrific death of the child from their actions is never their fault". That and associated discredited refrigerator mother trope for autism along with every pet theory whose only common thread is "not genetic". The legacy of bad ideas makes it questionable as a useful form of guidance especially when lacking more concrete successes analagous to eugenics as a pseudoscientific corruption of genetics.
- kqr 6y agoHow does one go about irrefutably showing insecure parenting leads to attachment disorders that affect people outside of the home? Genuine curiosity.
- aidenn0 6y agoHaving fostered children as young as 15 months, I think it's patently absurd to claim that the relationship with early caregivers matters not at all. The effects of abuse and neglect are so large, and so hard to change after age 3 or so, that you really don't need a big sample size to see it. It's entirely possible that the threshold at which nurture no longer matters is so low that most parents are far above the bar, but I guarantee you if you did an experiment where you spanked a 6 month old every time they cried, or left a 14 month old in a car with a box of cereal and a sippy cup alone for 12 hours every weekend, you would measure some long-term affects quite easily.
- woodandsteel 6y agoPeer relations are very important. But from what I recall, that book doesn't really address what the article is about, partly because many of the developments took place after it was written. And by the way, are you saying that, if you were a man married to a woman and you had children, you wouldn't be bothered if she was insensitive or abusive with them, because it would have no long-term effects on their personalities?