3 ms·
5% false positives on people who have some symptoms of cancer isn’t bad. But 5% of a ‘high risk group’ could be a lot - particularly if the cancer is too early
by helsinkiandrew 6y ago
5% false positives on people who have some symptoms of cancer isn’t bad. But 5% of a ‘high risk group’ could be a lot - particularly if the cancer is too early to confirm detection any other way yet and possibly not treatable for several years.
- minerjoe 6y agoThey'll find something to sell in this case.
- ethbro 6y agoTime provides options in cancer. Even if the first option is "get more regular checkups over the next year+, to characterize the growth rate." You don't have to nuke an organ from orbit, if you have historical data that indicates a tumor isn't aggressive. Or you would, if you've been watching it and it suddenly takes off.
- minerjoe 6y ago"You don't" but many doctors sure seem happy to treat early and to be blind to the potential harm that the treatement entails.
- ethbro 6y agoAnd many software developers don't properly use a CVS. But that doesn't make GitHub a bad idea.
- batty_alex 6y agoThe problem is that you don’t want to treat every cancer like it’s potentially life-threatening (many aren’t) because you can cause other problems with detection/treatment. I’d want any early detection to be pretty damn solid if we’re going to start talking monthly checkups for something that could resolve on its own. Using an SCM tool isn’t going to cause additional problems except for reminding yourself of all the dumb mistakes you made last week.
- ethbro 6y ago> Using an SCM tool isn’t going to cause additional problems except for reminding yourself of all the dumb mistakes you made last week. You haven't worked at a shop that mandated Team Foundation Server, have you? ;)
- refurb 6y agoBut in this example - stomach cancer - you could just skip the test and do a routine endoscopy and get some tissue samples. You’d have a much higher confidence in the result. Reminds me a bit of the PSA test for prostate cancer. More of an early warning, but with the weak predictability, doctors are moving away from routine PSA tests.
- jjk166 6y agoIf option A is regular blood tests with an endoscopy to confirm should the blood test come back positive and option B is getting endoscopies on a regular basis, option A is a no brainer. While it might not be super invasive, I'd definitely like to keep the number of times a tube has to be shoved down my throat to a minimum.
- refurb 6y agoBut if the false positive rate is high, just skip the test and do the endoscopy.
- jjk166 6y agoNo, the false positive rate is irrelevant. Let's say you want to check for cancer annually and the blood test has a 50% false positive rate: If you only get endoscopies after positive results, you get an endoscopy every other year. If you skip the test and go straight to the endoscopy, you get one every year. Thus you get half as many tubes shoved down your throat if you get the blood test. For a more reasonable false positive rate like 5%, you would have a 50/50 chance of getting a false positive any given decade. I'd much rather get 4 endoscopies than 40. Indeed, for any false positive rate less than 100% (which isn't really a test to begin with) still on average decreases the number of endoscopies you need. Really the metric that's important is the false negatives: if that's too high then I can't safely forego the endoscopy just because this year's blood test was negative. Even then though, if the blood test has a long lead time then maybe it's safe to wait and see how next year's blood test goes.