11 ms·
The AN-225: How the Cold War created the world's largest airplane
- jonplackett 6y agoThey don’t make ‘em like they used to
- iagovar 6y agoAntonov is really struggling to keep the shop open, I wonder if it's possible to keep such plane operational with the manufacturer on the brink of bankrupcy. Las time I checked Boing was supplying some parts that couldn't get imported from Russia now, but AFAIK the are not really having many customers.
- aww_dang 6y agoI don't see Antonov disappearing anymore than GM, Boeing or Volkswagen. I'm sure the Russian state will continue to protect them in one form or another.
- possiblelion 6y agothat's the problem, Antonov is based in Kyiv, Ukraine
- baybal2 6y agoAnd that's the problem. The state of Ukraine is just few months away from going bust. If Ukraine falls, EU will have big problems.
- the_mitsuhiko 6y agoWhy would Ukraine defaulting cause big problems for the EU?
- clawoo 6y agoPresumably because that would push them into the hands of Russia (whether they want it or not).
- fit2rule 6y agoWho are "they"? Ukraine? Ukraine rejoining the CIS would be good for everyone, except those with an interest in selling arms and fomenting war and disruption in the area. EDIT: downvoters/flaggers: are you censoring the narrative because it doesn't jive with what you've been told, or because you simply cannot tolerate a viewpoint that is counter to the one you have subsumed through authoritarian contact? Because, on the ground, things may be very different to what you've been told through the fog of war, which is being weaponised on this topic. Take that into consideration.
- evgen 6y agoGiven the fact that the only way Russia was able to claw back a bit of Ukrainian territory was through outright invasion I think that the Ukrainian people do not share your misguided belief that it would be good for them to rejoin the CIS. In fact, other than Russian apparatchiks I do not think there is anyone in the world who thinks that this would be a good idea.
- fit2rule 6y agoWell, Russia didn't take a 'bit' of Ukrainian territory, they annexed Crimea, where their nuclear base and black water navy base was located, a region for which the people of Russia have had cultural ties for over 700 years as a nation, installed a buffer zone around their military assets - and then conveniently left most of the rest of the Ukraine for the people of Ukraine. Wasn't that gracious of them? Not at all like the piles of smoking rubble, immense list of war crimes and demolished infrastructure of recent Western "police action" standards, but nevertheless, for those of us familiar with the area, not as drastic a scenario as the dis-sovereignty forced on so many nations by the West that we can't even keep count any more, not that anyone is interested... I mean, really, if you really think you know what Russia has done in Crimea, "pics or gtfo". Citizens of the West can feign indignance at this action, and call for an immediate response from their own noble, ethical military forces who can do no wrong, whatsoever, but since the Ukraine is on my doorstep I personally know a lot of Russian citizens who live in the area who are quite content with the state of affairs, and even quite a few Ukrainians too .. In fact, like I said, the only ones who are really pissed are those who had hoped to profit from the coup d'etat, i.e. war mongers, who are relatively disincentivized by the fact that yes, Russia has managed to de-escalate in the region, since they have the support of the people in the area, and therefore the provocateurs in Kiev won't be selling as many Stingers and Javelins as they'd hoped might be needed by the citizens in the region .. EDIT: there is a Western narrative which most readers are familiar with. But there is a Crimea/Russia narrative which deserves your enlightened consideration too. Do not fall so easily into the warmonger trap: the Ukraine is a lot more peaceful than Yemen, Iraq, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Libya and Syria at the moment. Precisely because there are Russian forces in the region, not in spite of it. The 5-eyes coalition would not dare do to Crimea what it has done many, many times elsewhere: i.e. committing war crimes with impunity is not going to happen. The people of Ukraine and Crimea are very, very much more informed about what the USA's War Coalition has been doing with its illegal wars than the average American citizen. There is a great deal of validity to the idea that the CIA wanted to do to Ukraine what it did to Libya - but was thwarted by Russias Little Green Men. So, take that into account. Western Media is not the only narrative for the region. (s/Croatia/Crimea/ autocorrect brainfart)
- fit2rule 6y agoBrexit .. and to a lesser extent, Ukraine-fail .. is the least of EU's problems. It was, in the first place, formed to guard against these kinds of circumstances. So, its probably better to say "EU will be unit tested" by Ukraine's disruption, rather than 'have big problems' ..
- go13 6y agoI would worry about Russia more. It will go bust sooner or later. If Russia is now a problem for everyone, then it can be not a problem but a disaster.
- baybal2 6y agoYes, completely right. EU, and NATO will have a problem almost on the same scale if Russia collapses on them, as if it will launch an attack on them. Russia has 8 times the population of Syria, and people can't live on a big part of its territory without artificial heating (and thus fuel supplies; your heating bill is pretty much a live or die price in a lot of places there,) or completely reliant for on long range freight for essential supplies.
- fit2rule 6y agoRussia is a very, very big country and economic unit. It may have been sanctioned into oblivion by its Western enemies, but its collapse before the USA devolves into civil war is anything but certain. >Russia has 8 times the population of Syria, and people can't live on a big part of its territory without artificial heating, or completely reliant for on long range freight for essential supplies. What part of this makes you think Russia is dependent on the Wests' criminal sanctions being lifted?
- pjc50 6y agoThis kind of already happened in the 90s? And to some extent is why the current problems exist.
- baybal2 6y agoThe state was far from complete failure, very far from it. Nowhere near Syria. The state kept control of the military. Troops were orderly demobilised. The criminality was comparatively low in comparison to Putin's years. The state-mafia fusion came long after the years immediately following the collapse. The same is for much of the industry, much of it has failed over nineties, and not immediately after. The remnants of state economy at least managed to keep supplies going. Utilities in cities on "life support" were failing, but otherwise kept working at any cost. If Russia will fail today, the collapse will be much less gradual, and this time, there will be a civil war, and warlordism, and famine, and mass humanitarian catastrophy.
- Maakuth 6y agoAntonov is a Ukrainian state enterprise, no problem for Russia to see them go under.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- baybal2 6y agoAntonov Airlines is said to have made a windfall on COVID supplies recently, with countries, and relief organisations putting bigger, and bigger bids.
- prehistoricdog 6y agoThe reasons it's not going to bankrupt, as well as will not develop any AN-225v2 are: Antonov is not a private company. As a part of Ministry of Defense, it may let itself to be unprofitable and not competitive, cause the losses would be covered by budget. And yes, it is not considered a desirable workplace among locals due to rather low salaries and predominantly well-aged equipment. Moreover, Antonov suffered from breaking it's supply chain in 2014. Apart from that, everything's absolutely great! Obviously, it is not the Golden Age of Antonov's assembly, nor it's development, nor anything else, but it happened so I live 1 block away from Antonov design bureau and every morning I see quite impressive flow of employees heading in there. I mean, of course, except the shutdown period and it's just my personal 'seems quite impressive'. PS English is not my native, so it may be clunky or poorly readable)
- iagovar 6y agoHow is Ukraine doing with its tech and military industry? Are they keeping up with the times or slow fading away? I don't see them doing much active development, amd I wrong?
- clon 6y agoI never knew they had a second, unfinished, airframe ready for assembly.
- LeonM 6y agoI remember a Discovery program showing what supposedly was an AN-225 airframe parked in a field somewhere. The story was that it was finished, but never certified for flight, and was eventually used for parts to keep the one 225 operational. I can't find evidence online to back this story up though. Not sure of this was the second airframe shown in the article, or that this may have been a third airframe.
- coldcode 6y agoWhatever its future, that is one monster plane I would love to see fly. Given the 747 has no future now and even the A380 is not that popular and might vanish, we may never see such a huge plane again.
- zhte415 6y agoSaw it once visiting DLC, probably the only time visiting that airport, this was ~2008. The airport is pretty downtown; fences at each end of the runway (3,300m, pretty tight) were removed and the motorway immediately adjunct to the airport shut down. It was reported as delivering oil/gas supplies for the shipyard and no smaller plane could do it. Searched for a local media report but seems pains of time mean they're no longer up.
- kilroy123 6y ago747s are still used for cargo. I saw one fly over my head just yesterday.
- kjs3 6y agoYeah...while there probably won't be many/any new 747s built, they'll probably be flying cargo for many decades. Last II knew, FedEx was still flying 25 or so Douglas DC-10 cargos, more than 30 years after the last one was built.
- artpi 6y agoAs a political stunt, Polish government has chartered this plane to deliver medical supplies to Poland. What a sight! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bnQPcMcGVZ8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bnQPcMcGVZ8 However, the costs were insane - around $3 million . Transporting the same amount of cargo with 777 would cost about $1 milion. But the political stunt was priceless.
- naivedevops 6y ago"The uploader has not made this video available in your country"
- TomMarius 6y agoHaving countries matter on the internet now feels like going back to the 90's after living in the future for a while. :/
- nitrogen 6y agoThe 90s Internet didn't have deliberate region blocks. The future is old, and it is dying.
- artificial 6y agoWhile the connection speeds of today are hard to give up, I liked having oceans of smaller sites instead of a handful of larger ones with content shared from the others. http://c0rk.tripod.com http://c0rk.tripod.com
- moltar 6y agoCanada too. I think it landed twice in Montreal. https://youtu.be/OGbtUHEYJ3M https://youtu.be/OGbtUHEYJ3M
- nuccy 6y agoMaybe it was a political stunt, but actually there are two justification of that. 1) The volume. The masks and other protective gear is volume-demanding cargo, since the overall density including packing (boxes) is low. The Boeing 777 Freighter (777F) has 518m3 of cargo volume on main deck [1], An-225 has 1200m3 [2], so the price per 1m3 of volume is 1930$ and 2500$ respectively (ratio 1.3). 2) The demand and the quarantine itself. During March-April demand on masks was enormous, everyone tried to buy them, some countries even tried to take over deliveries for other ones. China and many other countries were not accepting flights, so arranging even a single flight was challenging (thats why An-225 was flying through Almaty city that many times when making China-Europe routes, all other airports simply didn't accept any planes for transit and refueling). As a result, one huge plane was much more beneficial than 2-3 smaller ones. [1] https://www.boeing.com/commercial/aeromagazine/articles/qtr_02_09/article_02_1.html https://www.boeing.com/commercial/aeromagazine/articles/qtr_... [2] https://www.antonov-airlines.com/our-fleet/an-225 https://www.antonov-airlines.com/our-fleet/an-225 Edit: correcting An-225 cargo volume from 1100m3 to 1200m3 using data from the official website.
- pseudolus 6y agoThere's no shortage of documentaries on Youtube on the AN-225 [0][1]. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hsh2GSHM2TA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hsh2GSHM2TA [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6sggQqdvqHs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6sggQqdvqHs
- Slump 6y ago"...20 tons of fuel per hour..." holy cow. Pretty impressive statistics all around, apparently the A380 uses closer to 12.5 tons per hour to put it in perspective.
- baybal2 6y agoPretty impressive given that: Type MTOW [kg] ICAO category Antonov An-225 640,000 Heavy Airbus A380-800 575,000 Super and that 225 is made with much less than an ideal aerodynamics, heavy frame, 6 thrust reversers, and oversized control surfaces to accommodate external cargo. Its 6 engines are also prehistoric. D-18T was made with a much more focus on getting the highest take off thrust over cruise speed performance. Such a large, wide wing apparently gets very little aerodynamic losses, even with all above considered.
- perl4ever 6y agoWhy is 60% more fuel for 10% more weight "pretty impressive"? I mean, you just listed several reasons why it might be "not bad", but what's your baseline expectation that makes it impressive?
- baybal2 6y agoOne is a passenger airliner, made with relatively new engines, and material technology, designed with the aim of flying as economically as possible, another is a one of a kind cargo plane, that from the start had, uniquely, no design aim of flying efficiently. Also, for that 20t per hour, we need to know if it is for the loaded, or a ferry flight.
- perl4ever 6y agoYes, that is why it is not surprising if it uses 60% more fuel. My question was why is it impressive? What would you expect given all the things you have mentioned? Twice as much fuel? Ten times? 100 times? I'm not arguing against your opinion, just asking for context that seemed to be missing.
- major505 6y ago2 years ago they landed this plane here in Brazil, when they camt to pick hidroeletrical generator parts. I gone with a plane enthusiast friend to see the thing take off. I know the phisics, but amazes me that something that big can fly. Theres hope that more of this are made in the next years. It looks like China is interested in making a few units;
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- duxup 6y agoIt always amazed me that you could strap a space shuttle to a modified 747 and ... fly. The whole idea of "just strap it to another flying machine and move it that way" seems like something my 4 year old would come up with. It is clear my mental model of 'things that can fly good' is deficit when we see things like the AN-225 and etc.
- nickff 6y agoInterestingly, there was some doubt within NASA as to whether the 747 piggyback was a good idea. One of the proponents of the idea was a scale model builder, and made a model to demonstrate it; the model's success was persuasive enough that they continued to study the idea. In the end, the 747-Space Shuttle combo actually has better crosswind landing characteristics than a normal 747, but it has atrocious fuel economy.
- duxup 6y agoI wonder how many great ideas have been missed out on because our most basic filter / mental models that allow us to just choose basic candidates for options are ... wrong. "Wait no you can't do that, let's look into this other thing."
- nickff 6y agoMy favorite example of a near-miss because of that sort of opposition is lunar orbit rendezvous.[1] Yuri Kondratyuk, Tom Dolan, and John Houbolt were the protagonists in that instance; I generally disfavor the 'great man' theory of history, but I think those three made a real difference. [1] https://www.nasa.gov/centers/langley/news/factsheets/Rendezvous.html https://www.nasa.gov/centers/langley/news/factsheets/Rendezv...
- prehistoricdog 6y agohere is a great tour inside the aircraft with 1 of it's pilots (in russian, but with a comprehensible English subs): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9TX9L62_Eac https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9TX9L62_Eac
- whatch 6y agoReally enjoyed the video (I speak Russian though).
- prehistoricdog 6y agoCouldn't agree more)
- myself248 6y agoWow, just wow. I knew it carried its whole crew with it, but the cabins are almost a little hotel, two kitchens! Three sleeping quarters! And that's all just tucked into the parts that aren't used for cargo. I got a few good chuckles out of the back-and-forth, just from the subtitle, I'm sure it's even better if you speak Russian. Well worth a watch, thank you for posting it!
- prehistoricdog 6y agoThere was a piece, where the pilot explained why airports are not in favor of accepting AN225 for landing and takeoff on theirs runways: they have to check the runway surface after landing/takeoff. but even more crucial (not now, but in those times) is that suitable for landing airports are in most cases are those with high throughput of aircrafts and tight schedule and according to the international safety regulations it is possible give permittion for the next takeoff only after 7-10 min due to turbulent wake(is it the right term?). while common passenger flights have an interval of 30 sec
- 0x737368 6y agoSmall correction with regards to AN-124's name, Ruslan doesn't stand for "condor", condor is its NATO reporting name, Ruslan is just a popular Russian name.
- codeduck 6y agolargest by payload - unless the Stratolaunch gets uprated.
- scottlocklin 6y agoJeez CNN is really terrible. The Myasishchev VM-T didn't "carry the spacecraft unassembled" as anyone with eyes can plainly see, and the AN-225 was designed as a replacement for the VM-T (and, truth be told, as a sort of stunt). https://www.popularmechanics.com/military/aviation/a30930668/vm-t-atlant/ https://www.popularmechanics.com/military/aviation/a30930668...
- _ph_ 6y agoIn the linked article the image clearly shows, the Buran was not fully assembled. For example the vertical tail rudder was missing, and probably a lot of other things which might have decreased the weight of the Buran.
- rob74 6y agoWell, the plane shown in the first photo is clearly carrying an incomplete spacecraft. To find out that it was in fact able to carry the completely assembled Buran, you'd have to actually read the article ("During another flight in 1988 — this time with a flight-worthy Buran orbiter"), and that's probably too much to ask nowadays...
- g8oz 6y ago>> Jeez CNN is really terrible. Related: it was very satisfying to watch uBlock Origin block no less than 82 scripts/trackers.
- kd5bjo 6y agoThe H-4 Hercules could plausibly be considered larger. It has a larger wingspan, height, and cargo volume, but only ever flew once (for about a mile) and has significantly lower weight capacity. It was also bult several decades before the AN-225. cf https://www.theaviationzone.com/factsheets/hk1_specs.asp https://www.theaviationzone.com/factsheets/hk1_specs.asp
- avmich 6y agoStratolaunch has widest wingspan, Hercules has highest height and Mriya is the longest/heaviest. So... they are all demonstrations for how we learned to build extreme aircrafts.
- hedgehog 6y agoHour-long video showing parts of a whole mission: https://youtube.com/watch?v=eNxTq9RrOs0 https://youtube.com/watch?v=eNxTq9RrOs0
- egorfine 6y agoI have been inside this airplane and I've got some pics to share: https://egorfine.com/photo/mriya/ https://egorfine.com/photo/mriya/
- c0nsumer 6y agoOff topic, but I wanted to say thank-you. I've recently had to move away from an antiquated Gallery2 install, and these photos had me wondering how you were hosting a personal gallery. This led me to Juicebox which seems super-cool and perfect for meeting a lingering need. Thank you!
- GoblinSlayer 6y agoLooks like Nostromo: big, old, dark, messy spaceship.
- baybal2 6y agoThink of it, that entire electronic automation suite on board can be now replaced with a single 1$ smartphone chipset.
- ben7799 6y agoThanks for this.. killer photos.. Was this at an airshow? Was someone following you around to make sure you didn't pull on any wires or anything you weren't supposed to be touching?
- 6y ago
- Synaesthesia 6y agoI saw it once at an air show in Pretoria, along with some other cool planes like the Sukhoi SU-35. The Russians actually loaded up all their other planes into the Antonov, and flew it straight from Moscow to Pretoria in one shot!
- jupp0r 6y agoIt's crazy how this can be economical with economics of scale=1. Every replacement part for maintenance must be custom-made, there must be no market for trained pilots and technicians on that particular plane, etc.
- sbalea 6y agoThey cross-train for AN-124, which is quite similar, though obviously smaller.
- Animats 6y agoPaul Allen's Stratolaunch has a wider wingspan, but less cargo capacity. Wonder where that monster will end up. It's intended for high-altitude rocket launches and not useful for much else.
- m0zg 6y agoI don't think it's the "Cold War" that created it per se - it was the Space Race. We need another one of those, doesn't matter with whom.
- smabie 6y agoAnd the space race was created by the Cold War. Without the Cold War, I doubt we would have ever sent a man to the moon.
- m0zg 6y agoTrue. But I feel like Space Race eventually took a life of its own, and it was not military in nature. You don't do joint space programs if you're having a "war".
- usrusr 6y agoBut military requirements seem to have played a significant role in how the Shuttles became what they were. A purely civilian space race wouldn't have had shuttles at all, or at least a very different design.