3 ms·
I actually have a plan for this! I want to build a ratings website where you rate things in the same way they generally structure psychological tests, by respo
by fastball 6y ago
I actually have a plan for this!
I want to build a ratings website where you rate things in the same way they generally structure psychological tests, by responding to affirmative statements with something between "strongly agree" and "strongly disagree".
As an example, if you were rating films, questions could be:
"This film was enjoyable."
"This film had an engaging plot."
"The acting was believable / appropriate for the film."
etc. Ideally you'd have about 5 standard statements that you respond to for a particular thing you want to rate (whether its films, books, food, or a university course).
Better than a star rating system, because the problem with stars is that you end up with scores that always hover from 5-8 (if out of 10) in a very not useful way (see IMDB).
It's also better than what RT / Netflix / many others have moved to (just voting with up/down) as those require a lot of data in order to really give interesting results, where as with this system you can start to find interesting insights almost immediately, or within a single person's own collection.
- jkinudsjknds 6y agoPeople not answering questions correctly is precisely the reason many companies switch to thumbs up thumbs down. The precision of the measurement just isn't there for good / bad. Collaborative filtering with just these simple metrics works decently well, the issue is most sites like netflix have difficult UIs to actually use it as a poweruser. The average consensus of people on how good a thing is on some sort of scale, is pretty worthless. The consensus of people who seem to be like you on previous works is kind of useful. Strongly disagree, disagree, neutral, agree, strongly agree is just a 5 star system with a different name.
- abakker 6y agoI like this - in general, I’m a fan of this (my job is survey research). There are many different approaches to getting better results than most reviews get. Personally, I’d love to see a max-diff approach to reviews.
- fastball 6y agoFeel free to steal the idea! I'm a bit busy building out another idea I had haha.