5 ms·
Is 'merit' necessarily unrelated to 'privilege'? Much of our talent and ability is not something we are born with; a meritocracy based on innate ability would
by sliverstorm 16y ago
Is 'merit' necessarily unrelated to 'privilege'?
Much of our talent and ability is not something we are born with; a meritocracy based on innate ability would be a mess- it would practically boil down to ranking everyone based on their IQ. Instead, a meritocracy is typically going to be based on current ability, and isn't 'privilege' deeply entwined with your ability?
It's not pretty or P-C, but it's not exactly confusing to me that someone with more opportunities for schooling performs better in an environment labeled 'meritocratic'. It's not "Nature", it's "Nature AND Nurture".
- arethuza 16y agoOne example that I have seen happening in the UK: take two people with directly comparable excellent university education (same university, same course, same results) - the one who went to the "better" school will be perceived as having more "merit" than someone who achieved the same result from a far less privileged background. To me the latter, having achieved far more, has the more "merit" whereas to others it often the opposite.
- larrik 16y agoI don't get it. If it's the "same university, same course, same results", which one is the "better" school?
- notahacker 16y agoIs that really the case? The majority of people have very little idea of "better" schools beyond a handful of elite institutions, their local area and those that stick "grammar" into their title. It's also reasonably well established that the better state-funded schools are as good as or better than many private school in terms of academic performance. I'm seeing "Eton-educated" increasingly used as a pejorative description by inverse snobs too.
- arethuza 16y agoI wouldn't say it is widespread and certainly not in the software world - but there are environments where that kind of daft thinking does occur.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoEven meritocracy based on IQ would likely be correlated to privilege. IQ is highly heritable. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heritability_of_IQ http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heritability_of_IQ An article posted on HN had an interesting quote on merit (this time in the context of college admissions): ...the dark little secret about [merit-based] grants. They do not create access to higher education for students who otherwise could not go [for financial reasons]. Merit-based price discounts only help determine which school a student attends. A fully funded need-based aid system is what would create real access for students who would otherwise be shut out or have to trade down to lower quality alternatives. If correct, this means that at the college level, merit is also highly correlated to privilege. http://economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/02/18/why-does-college-cost-so-much/ http://economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/02/18/why-does-colleg...
- jbooth 16y agoScores on IQ tests are highly heritable. Whether IQ is highly heritable depends on whether you define it as the result of the test or something that the tests are trying to measure. A lot of tests tend to embed a ton of middle-upper-class cultural touchstones that you don't even realize are there until you find yourself explaining them to a test-taker who's never been camping or on a boat. EDIT: The concept of "intelligence" that IQ purports to measure is probably highly heritable as well, of course. I'm just cautioning against drawing too many straight lines from test results, particularly on the topic of diversity and intelligence.
- selenamarie 16y agoPrivilege isn’t just about money – it’s about a collection of gifts individuals receive from society, regardless of merit. Those gifts include but aren’t restricted to freedom, time and indulgence. And to say that a person can only contribute to an open source project if they have equivalent freedom, time and indulgence from society as our very most privileged members, is to exclude a great number of people – I’d say 99% of people – who are capable and would be wonderful additions to our community. So to address your question about privilege being entwined with ability: it is dangerous to assume a relationship between the two. I choose to question my assumptions about ability (because I know that I have biases!), because the truth is that I have no idea about other people until they actually do something. And even then, my understanding of someone else's abilities is often limited to only what I directly observe. Keeping that in mind opens up opportunities between people. And I prefer that mindset to one that assumes a link between privilege with ability.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoCould you be specific about what that "collection of gifts" is and how Postgres/OSS needlessly excludes people based on these gifts?
- selenamarie 16y agoI listed a few: freedom, time and indulgence. More specifically, the freedom to pursue passion in life is often enabled by one's parents having enough money and stability. Time is mostly about leisure time. Having a job that supports work on open source is still not that common, so one is left with figuring out how to do this on your own time - and that depends on you actually having free time because you don't have kids, you only have one job, and you have the background knowledge (socially, tools-wise and background reading) necessary to participate. So, that's how the whole world works, right? I am not saying that Postgres is unique here. I think we actually do a really great job. We have about 300 contributors every year, and only about 20 committers. That's impressive and shows how the contributors feel about our project. It is prestigious, interesting and fun enough for them to send us their code even though we don't give out commit access, and we subject everyone to a pretty difficult code review. That just goes to show that if you ask a lot from people, they like it and come back for more. Or at least the people I want to be in a community with like it. :) I am bringing up to my community that we could do a little better inside of Postgres. We could take a closer look at how we operate, and find ways of inviting people in that don't already fit our mold. There isn't an easy solution to addressing privilege inside a community, at all. But I was at a conference last week, and a couple people asked me to write my thoughts down about meritocracy. It was not an easy thing for me to do.. I already see a few de-railing comments about gender. But I continue to get support for thinking and writing about this issue, and ultimately finding more ways of getting more contributors. This is why I continue to contribute, and why I took a moment to make a gentle criticism of a community that I enjoy very much.