7 ms·
I'm a Math and CS student and still wonder how was it even possible that I did not start to hate math in high school. Things done there are dull and boring, exe
by xyzzyz 16y ago
I'm a Math and CS student and still wonder how was it even possible that I did not start to hate math in high school. Things done there are dull and boring, exercises are repetitive and do not teach anything substantial other than applying another algorithm shown by a teacher. I found out that almost everyone did not really understand not only the problems that were told to solve, but also the solutions they gave -- and it was hard to blame them, for it was mainly teacher's and education system's fault not to give them thorough understanding of what is math really about.
My idea? Dump all that algorithmic crap and teach real problem solving. Do not punish for bad performance, because it is really hard to actually come up with a solution to a problem, and this skill is not something that can be learned by doing the same thing over and over again. Problem solving also require less concepts to be introduced and internalized, so more time can be spent on actual thinking and discussing, and less on preparations.
This kind of math course may seem not to prepare to good to "university level" math, but in fact it is quite opposite -- universities have to start almost from scratch anyway, and it is easier to teach new concepts a person who has a good understanding what math really is, than a person who only know tens of algorithms, used in high school to grind all kind of "problems" given there.
- btam 16y agoThe thing is, students already think of math as difficult. If we switched from algorithms to actual creative problem solving, it would become a lot more intimidating. I'm pretty confident of this. I'm in high school, and the other students have noted how much more they would 'hate' math if it were like the creative problem solving math competition that we have here in the US each year. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Mathematics_Competitions http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Mathematics_Competitio... What many -- perhaps even most -- kids really want is a course where they do only simple mechanical work, and get a boost to their GPA. At least, that's what it seems to me to be. Also, we have to consider that unfortunately, not all teachers care. Now that teaching to the test is rampant(at least in the US), I think many classes would fall apart if the added structure and 'accountability' disappeared, like it would if we made that switch. I don't disagree with you. The world would be a better place if we could get rid of this; if we didn't have all of this baggage to deal with. EDIT: RiderOfGiraffes seems to have said the same thing in a different way in this thread; check it out: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2390960 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2390960.
- RiderOfGiraffes 16y agoBut that's math competition stuff, which is seriously more daunting, and practising mathematicians will often claim is even less like "real, proper math." It's occasionally suggested that some real, long-standing unsolved problems should be set as IMO questions, because there's a non-zero chance they'd get solved. > What many -- perhaps even most -- kids really want is a > course where they do only simple mechanical work, and > get a boost to their GPA. "Most people would sooner die than think. And most of them do." -- G.B.Shaw. > ... not all teachers care. And not all teachers are capable. And largely all of your points are exactly right, except for your misconception about what kind of math we want kids to be doing. Going back to that point, the IMO is like playing at Carnegie Hall. What we want is like messing about with instruments to see what they do, and getting hooked on the curious things that are possible. I'm not offering solutions here, I'm just helping define the problem, and explore directions.
- btam 16y agoYou're pretty much right on the math competitions front, but the first few problems on the AMC are pretty simple IMO(pardon the pun). They are barely above the level of mechanical problem solving. It does get harder, though, and I agree that that is more daunting. You've reminded me, however -- I remembered thinking that the Phillips Exeter Academy model for math education (the "Harkness" method) is amazing. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phillips_Exeter_Academy#Harkness_teaching_method http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phillips_Exeter_Academy#Harknes... > Exeter does not teach math with traditional textbooks. Instead, > math teachers assign problems from workbooks that have been > written collectively by the Academy's math department. From these > custom workbooks, students are assigned word problems as > homework. In class, students then present their solutions at the > blackboard. This means that in math class at Exeter, students are not > given theorems, model problems, or principles beforehand. Instead, > theorems and principles emerge more organically, as students work > through the word problems."* This is what we want. Discovering math makes it fun for everyone. Honesty and actual learning with that method(my whole would be not be too difficult, because everyone would inevitably have their own personal spin on the origins of the theorems et cetera. Plus, it'd be embarrassing to go to the blackboard and say that you haven't done the work. ---- By the way, expect an email regarding what you said about the IMO.
- crasshopper 16y agoLockhart's Lament: www.maa.org/devlin/LockhartsLament.pdf A musician wakes from a terrible nightmare. In his dream he finds himself in a society where music education has been made mandatory.... Since musicians are known to set down their ideas in the form of sheet music, these curious black dots and lines must constitute the “language of music.” It is imperative that students become fluent in this language if they are to attain any degree of musical competence; indeed, it would be ludicrous to expect a child to sing a song or play an instrument without having a thorough grounding in music notation and theory. Playing and listening to music ... are considered very advanced topics and are generally put off until college, and more often graduate school.
- samlittlewood 16y agoThe incentives should be around changes in performance, +ve or -ve, especially if it was as a result of the kid's own actions.
- icegreentea 16y agoFrom talking to my professors, there really was once a time when university math (calc 101 or w/e) was not starting from scratch (from the perspective of engineering anyways). Spend maybe a month over derivatives and limits, and then off to integrals and everything else you'll need so that mechanics actually makes some sense.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- neutronicus 16y agoI'm probably one of the few, but I didn't have any problem with the paradigm of high school math education, just the pace. As far as my later career, it's been my experience that rote manipulation without conceptual understanding can solve your problem, and that the converse isn't true. Sometimes, if you do the math right, it will contradict your intuition. I'm hesitant to endorse any paradigm that aims to make math more intuitive, since at the end of the day that's a lie. One of the take-home messages of mathematics education should be that these mechanical processes are better than your own "problem-solving skills".
- eru 16y agoIn some sense, yes. Mathematics is the science of how to solve problems without thinking. Progress in mathematics means elimination of thought needed. But actually inventing that time saving machinery is different from applying it.
- ajscherer 16y agoMathematics is most definitley not that. The fact that your definition probably sounds reasonable to most people who made it all the way through calculus (and even excelled in those courses) probably supports what Vi is saying. On the other hand, maybe it's okay that people don't really understand what math is (as mathematicians understand it). I don't see any evidence that society is falling apart due to lack of appreciation for pure math.
- neutronicus 16y agoI think "mathematics is a mechanical process for solving problems without an intuitive grasp of their nature" is a very good definition, with which many professional mathematicians would agree. Sometimes you're surprised by what pops out when you turn the crank. (Witness: every non-trivial probability problem ever) Einstein's special theory of relativity was mainly an intuitive interpretation of Lorenz's discovery of Maxwell's equations' invariance under Lorenz transformation. The insight "c is constant in every frame of reference", would not have been possible without Lorenz mechanically working out what sort of transformation would leave Maxwell's equations invariant. Dirac predicted the existence of the positron solely based on a mechanical process of finding out what sort of equation satisfied the symmetries observed in nature. My point being that many great intellectual advances have been made by people who trusted the process more than themselves, and that's one of the cornerstones of mathematical thinking: trust the process more than yourself.