3 ms·
>> I see no reason to accept this. Yes, I'm aware it's very difficult to get people to believe this outside of AI research. Of course, it is entirely uncontrov
by YeGoblynQueenne 6y ago
>> I see no reason to accept this.
Yes, I'm aware it's very difficult to get people to believe this outside of AI
research. Of course, it is entirely uncontroversial and very well understood
by researchers. For example, I was in a presentation by a gentleman who works
at DeepMind last year and who works on neuro-symbolic integration and he was
asked a question along the lines of "how can you model first order logic
without variables?" and he pointed out that he had a footnote on one of his
slides where he was noting this limitation and that work was underway to
address it.
Regarding arithmetic, none of the points made in your comment made in the
GPT-3 paper. In fact, the paper makes no attempt to explain what makes GPT-3
capable of performing arithmetic, other than to say that the mistakes in
carrying a one suggest that it's actually trying to perform computation and
failing. So I have to ask, where do these points come from?
What I mean is, you seem to have a theory about how GPT-3 works. Where does it
come from? I apologise if this comes across as personal or unfair, but many
commenters in this thread and similar conversations express strong opinions
and give detailed explanations about how GPT-3 and similar models work. I am
always left wondering where all this information comes from, given that
usually it can't be found in the sources I'd expect to find it, namely the
work that is being discussed (namely, the GPT-3 paper, in this case).
- hackinthebochs 6y ago>For example, I was in a presentation by a gentleman who works at DeepMind last year and who works on neuro-symbolic integration Sure, neural networks don't operate on proper variables and so in the context of neuro-symbolic processing I'm sure this is a significant hurdle. But in general, abstract representations is part-and-parcel of what makes deep learning powerful. And such an abstract representation is all that's needed for a neural arithmetic unit. Here[1] is a study on GPT-2 that demonstrates its middle layers develop a representation of syntax and part-of-speech, the sorts of abstract representations that would be needed to develop a mechanism to do abstract arithmetic. >What I mean is, you seem to have a theory about how GPT-3 works. Where does it come from? Studies like the one mentioned, and reasonable extrapolation from knowledge of DL and other transformer architectures. We are not totally ignorant on how GPT-3 works. [1] https://aletheap.github.io/posts/2020/07/looking-for-grammar/ https://aletheap.github.io/posts/2020/07/looking-for-grammar...
- YeGoblynQueenne 6y agoMy comment above discussed the inability of neural networks (and propositional, attribute-value learners in general) to represent variables. I'm sorry, but I can't see how your comment or the post you link to show that neural networks can represent variables. I do not quite understand the relation between "abstract representations that would be needed to develop a mechanism to do abstract arithmetic" and variables. I'm also not sure what you mean by "abstract arithmetic", or what mechanisms you mean. Can you please explain? Also, I had thought we shared an understanding that the ability to represent primitive recursive functions (which presupose the ability to represent variables and recursion) is necessary to represent arithmetic. Your above comment now makes me doubt this, also. Can you clarify? Finally, the link above is a blog post. I wouldn't call it a study. But, can you say where in that post I can find the theory about GPT-3's function that you express above?