3 ms·
I understand what “weakly held” means, but what does the “strong opinions” part mean? I couldn’t get this from the post. What would be an example of a weak opi
by gnicholas 6y ago
I understand what “weakly held” means, but what does the “strong opinions” part mean? I couldn’t get this from the post.
What would be an example of a weak opinion and a related strong opinion? Is this just the difference between “the 49ers will win most of their games this year” and “the 49ers will win the Super Bowl this year”?
If so, why is the latter preferred?
Edit: thanks for the downvote, perhaps you can help me understand what is meant by the term, or why you found my comment to be inappropriate?
- renewiltord 6y agoExamples below. Weak opinion: I cannot conclude anything about why my car won't start. Strong opinion: I think my battery is dead and that's why my car won't start. Strongly held: I tested the battery and voltage and current are within good thresholds. I still believe what I believed before. Weakly held: I tested the battery and voltage and current are within good thresholds. I have adjusted my belief about what I believed before. WOSH: I cannot conclude anything about why my car won't start. You've tested my battery as dead. I still cannot conclude anything about why my car won't start. WOWH: I cannot conclude anything about why my car won't start. You've tested my battery as dead. It could be the battery, maybe. Hard to say. SOSH: I think my battery is dead and that's why my car won't start. You've tested my battery as functioning fine. It's definitely the battery, though. SOWH: I think my battery is dead and that's why my car won't start. You've tested my battery as functioning fine. The reason why my car won't start is not my battery; I think it won't start because my starter motor is broken. Downvotes occur for all sorts of reasons. Please don't introduce noise into the discussion. It's annoying to other readers for all sorts of reasons. I am often tempted to downvote anyone who complains about them.
- gnicholas 6y agoThanks for the examples. Is it possible for a weak opinion to be something other than "IDK why X is happening"? That is, can it be an affirmative opinion about some causal relationship or future event? Honestly, if someone asked me whether the WO example above was strong or weak, I would tend to say it is strong because it is a categorical statement. To me, a weak statement would be "I think my car won't start because there's either a battery problem or a starter engine problem or a wiring problem". That doesn't take a strong stand or eliminate many possibilities.
- renewiltord 6y agoI think in the context of the original statement it was a heuristic for searching for truth, i.e. "to know, form hypotheses then subject them to falsification tests". So yes, in the meaning of SOWH, all WO are ones that leave you unable to progress. Your reading of 'categorical implying strong' is reasonable, imho, in just the meaning of the word 'strong'. It's just not what I believe was the intended meaning in the statement of SOWH.
- gnicholas 6y agoInteresting, so the SO part of SOWH just means "have opinions that can be validated"? That seems very weak, no pun intended. Would anyone go around advocating for people to have WO, using that definition? I guess if that's what it means, then SOWH is pretty vacuous. Perhaps it's my background (law, economics, logic) but I assumed that "strong" referred to "the strong form" of an argument or hypothesis (such as the efficient market hypothesis). I never understood why someone would say it's better to embrace strong forms of arguments, since these tend to be more extreme (and IMO, things tend to be wrong more when they are taken to extremes).
- sooheon 6y agoReally I think it's just to enable the pithy phrasing. Catchy memes propagate.
- renewiltord 6y agoDespite your belief that it is vacuous, WO is a pretty standard mode of operation for many. It usually manifests as "We just don't know enough. Let's collect more information." or "There's not enough to go on. Let's wait it out." etc. i.e. unstructured search is more common than hypothesize-falsify despite the latter being established epistemology since early 1900s or before.