3 ms·
The CCP would state literally the exact same argument to justify their actions : "It's very disingenuous to imply that these people are being arrested for purel
by sudosysgen 6y ago
The CCP would state literally the exact same argument to justify their actions : "It's very disingenuous to imply that these people are being arrested for purely political reasons, they are causing social unrest and preventing harmony. They are not being targeted because of their identity, but because of their actions".
And it's just as bullshit when China says it and when the Feds say it. There is no justification for black-bagging people. When that happens, it is almost always for political reasons. If it wasn't, then they could use normal legal channels instead of violating the law.
By the way, civil disobedience is always illegal. That's what the "disobediance" means.
- fearingreprisal 6y agoThere is a very clear difference between "Arrested for disagreeing with Donald Trump" and "Arrested for participation in an illegal act". You know what the difference is. Everyone knows China's crackdown on dissidents is entirely different from people participating in the riot getting arrested by Federal agents in unmarked cars.
- sudosysgen 6y agoHow do you know that they were participating in a riot? By the way, in Oregon, Federal agents are not allowed to carry out such actions without registering beforehand with the State. So this was literally an illegal arrest made by agents of a completely unrelated agency being used in order to do what Donald Trump wants instead of following the process of the law. China's crackdown on dissidents is very similar, they also use the tactic where they push peaceful protests into riots and then use that as an excuse to arrest everyone.
- grandmczeb 6y agoFederal agents can enforce federal law anywhere in the US. They don’t need the state’s permission to, for example, arrest someone for vandalizing a federal courthouse. What you’re referring to is federal agents enforcing state law, which is also allowed but requires registration in Oregon[1]. That’s not a defense of the current situation; we should be putting more limits on what federal agents can do (like requiring them to identify themselves during an arrest). [1] https://www.lawfareblog.com/what-heck-are-federal-law-enforcement-officers-doing-portland https://www.lawfareblog.com/what-heck-are-federal-law-enforc...
- sudosysgen 6y agoYes. Federal crimes. Rioting, unless it is specifically vandalism on a federal building, is not enforceable by Federal agents, because it isn't a federal crime. When I'll see the warrant signed by a federal judge against these people for a federal crime with probable cause, then maybe. But so far, no one was served with a warrant.
- grandmczeb 6y agoFederal officers can make warrantless arrests if they have probable cause to believe the individual has committed a crime, just like normal officers. It's hard to tell if these arrests meet that threshold, but it's at least possible that all laws are technically being following here. Again, that's not to say this isn't a bad situation. I'm explicitly advocating for changing the laws that allow this to be even possibly legal in the first place.
- sudosysgen 6y agoSure, if they had probable cause. Do you think that those federal agents just witnessed that a federal crime was committed?
- grandmczeb 6y agoIn the video I’ve seen, there’s not enough context to tell whether they have probable cause. Which by the way does not require that they “just witnessed that a federal crime was committed”.
- nyolfen 6y agoi'm not fan of blackbagging people to terrorize them, but the ccp's regard for human rights is in a completely different universe. these people are getting arrested in a frightening and disorienting way, then charged (or not) and released. for a ccp response to rioting, please see the current situation in xinjiang -- evictions of entire communities via demolition of neighborhoods, indefinite detention of extended families, forced sterilization, etc.
- sudosysgen 6y agoThey also get charged in China and if not released. It's just that when Law Enforcement and Justice doesn't care much about the law, you can almost always arrange things to suit what you want. Much the same way that the Trump administration went against the law, due to their control of Law Enforcement and more generally of the monopoly of violence, in order to unlawfully detain people and build a database of people that have been targeted beforehand, including biometrics.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tonyztan 6y agoNo, people just get detained and disappeared in China, with families sent to labor camps if you're Uighur minority. That doesn't happen in the United States. Does the United States have problems? Yes. Are those problems on the same level as China? No.
- perl4ever 6y agoIf we are going to allow law enforcement to behave like this, you don't really have a check on people being disappeared. Even if the secret police are absolutely perfectly 100% scrupulous in only taking "bad guys" off the street for good reason, anybody could impersonate them, because they don't have identification or keep records. For the sake of argument, stipulate the US is not right now on the same level as some despotic states. What is going to tell us that we've arrived, next week or next year, if anonymous security forces can grab people off the street with no accountability? What sounds the alarm, that the feds are not doing things correctly, or that someone is pretending to be the feds, who kidnap people?