4 ms·
> I guess my view is probably a devil's advocate on HN I agree, but it's ironic, because in other threads, HN crows about the need for free-market solutions to
by smt88 6y ago
> I guess my view is probably a devil's advocate on HN
I agree, but it's ironic, because in other threads, HN crows about the need for free-market solutions to society's ills rather than regulation.
Then, when free markets/speech make mistakes (or take down their heroes), they call it "Cancel Culture". Or, when private companies respond to market demand to moderate their platforms, they call it "de-platforming".
> I actually view cancel culture as (mostly) good
I do too, but I view complaints about cancel culture (like Pinker's) as being good, too. If people aren't constantly analyzing it, criticizing it, and fighting it, cancel culture may become a weapon that is wielded too easily. We've already seen instances where people were "cancelled" based on false rumors that spread on social media.
People on both sides lament the death of the marketplace of ideas, but in a way, this debate is a reflection of that marketplace still being alive and well.