3 ms·
> every human in 2020 is either an ancestor of every human in Y or of no human in Y. as the population increases in size, the likelihood that at time T' there
by PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago
> every human in 2020 is either an ancestor of every human in Y or of no human in Y.
as the population increases in size, the likelihood that at time T' there is a living descendant of any given individual at time T increases. It never becomes 100%, but it does increase (for reasons you note).
by contrast, for the likelihood to decrease to zero means that as (T' - T) increases, an ever increasing number of descendants have to die before having children. for example, if i have two children and T' is T+1 year, then both children must not have children or must die in the next year. Now increase T' to T+30 years, and we now require that both my children, plus any children they have in the intervening 30 years, die before having any more children (at which point, I will have no descendants at any time beyond T'). Increase T' to T+300000 years, and we're talking about a huge number of people who must all die or have no more children before T'+1.
That's more or less what you've said above. But the problem is that it applies to every living human today also. For the situation to change such that I (or any other living human) become the IA, the descendant trees that do not include myself (or that other currently living human) must all vanish. This would be a near extinction event, since the number of humans in every descendant tree except the one connected to the IA will vastly outnumber those in that tree.
- xamuel 6y agoYou seem to be reasoning as if I've said there's a unique person today such that everyone in future year Y will be that person's descendant. In the above oversimplified example that I gave, everyone alive today would have the property that they are ancestors of everyone alive in year Y.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoIsn't that what an IA is?
- unkulunkulu 6y agoThere couldn’t be one because one of his partners would have a descendant alive at 2020