2 ms·
Democratic socialist is probably broadly what I would be, but I don't have much certainty on if it's the best choice, and I don't hold much stock in those kinds
by boomboomsubban 6y ago
Democratic socialist is probably broadly what I would be, but I don't have much certainty on if it's the best choice, and I don't hold much stock in those kinds of ideologies.
On Chomsky, no matter how certain you are that violent revolution will lead to oppression, you need sufficient proof that it is happening before you condemn the government. Chomsky had, in my mind, legitimate reason to doubt the evidence coming through the US, and wanted independent verification. I doubt he thought Cambodia would never do such things.
Even when a state is run by a terrible tyrant, that does not mean they are guilty of every crime imaginable. Wanting sufficient proof of their misdeeds before any potential punishment is sane. Waiting may cause more oppression, but brazenly punishing may hurt more people overall.
To me, the Iraq War largely proves Chomsky's point. Hussein was a tyrant, and as he had used weapons of mass destruction in the past there was plenty of reason to suspect he had them. He did not have them though, and the Iraq War has ruined millions of lives.
- woodandsteel 6y agoSorry I haven't responded. I've been busy. I plan to respond tomorrow
- boomboomsubban 6y agoGoing to add one more thing. I did a little research on what Chomsky's stated position on violent revolution is, and he feels it should be a last resort avoided if possible, as the welfare of the people often suffers. He generally advocates against all forms of violence.
- woodandsteel 6y agoThat's good to know.
- woodandsteel 6y agoPart 2 (sorry, the order is fouled up here) Ok, with respect to your views, I think I can narrow it down to a single question. I said that Marxism-Leninism has goals that can be achieved only through a great deal of violence against the population, and as a consequence whenever Marxist-Leninists come to power, this is what they practice. That means that even if a Marxist-Leninist party came to power that was headed by a basically good person, and was not threatened externally, it would still behave quite oppressively toward its population. My question is, do you agree that due to the nature of its basic goals, Marxist-Leninist regimes must be so oppressive?
- boomboomsubban 6y agoI keep saying this, but I have strong doubts in Leninism. I don't think someone would push for that system unless they cared more about seizing power than the wellbeing of the people. That will likely lead to oppression, without any policy changes. I'll address some points, though for the most part I am nor considering a Leninist central party. >The problem is that invariably a large portion of the population is opposed to this, to the bottom of their souls. I don't agree with this. The bourgeoisie would be opposed to it, but they can't be described as a large portion of the population. Ideally, everybody else benefits from the change, they have no reason to oppose what's going on and there should be no reason to opress them. So yes, any such revolution must involve some manner of getting rid of the bourgeoisie. They would likely feel oppressed, though they would just be losing privileges unique to them. They would also likely turn to violence, but wide scale lasting oppression you describe.
- woodandsteel 6y agoLeninism has always lead to great oppression. But that doesn't mean that the people who supported it understood that. Lot of bright, well-meaning people have philosophical, political and religious beliefs that are very wrong. Also, remember, we are not just talking about Lenin's own motives and beliefs, but many if not most of the thousands of party members who supported Leninism. Most of them were sincere idealists (which is why Stalin got rid of them all in the Moscow purge trials).T I strongly disagree that only the bourgeoisie would be opposed. Leninist revolutions take place in preindustrialized societies. That is because Lenin believed that peasants were naturally cooperative and so would eagerly adopt socialism (he got this from the Russian philosophy of narodnikism). But that is simply mistaken. Peasants are deeply conservative and traditional, including being completely embedded in extended kinship networks, raised to value life as a farmer, and extremely religious. Communism in a preindustrial society means tearing that whole culture completely apart, and that requires enormous state violence. Yes, a lot of them got fooled by propaganda for a while, especially before the revolution was over, but many more in Russia were never won over, and many of the ones who had supported it changed their minds once they saw it in practice. And in fact I have read that once the Communists came to power in Russia, Lenin regularly denounced, in private, the peasants for their resistance. So what I am saying is that leninists are generally well-meaning, intelligent people who sincerely believe it will lead to a socialist paradise, but leninism's ideas, when you try to put them in practice in a preindustrial society invariably lead to massive state violence.
- woodandsteel 6y agoOk, I'm back. I've been thinking about this, and I think it would be best if I presented my own ideas in a more organized form, and then said what I think you are saying, and ask some questions. So here is how I look at things To start out, dictatorships vary greatly in how cruel and oppressive they are. And how oppressive they are is greatly determined by whether or not they are ideological. The non-ideological dictatorships are often less violent, while the ones that are ideologically revolutionary invariably are very oppressive. The reason is they have different sorts of goals. Non-ideological dictators just want to stay in power and make use of the state for their own benefit. To achieve this they only need to eliminate and suppress any political opposition, through means such as jail, execution, and controlling the media. The rest of the society they leave as it is. On the other hand, revolutionary ideological dictatorships want to radically change the whole culture and society, top to bottom. The problem is that invariably a large portion of the population is opposed to this, to the bottom of their souls. So the regime has to resort to extreme measures, like endless propaganda, and violence such as execution, imprisonment, labor camps, and starvation, and aimed at large portions of the public. The idea is to eliminate opponents (Stalin: "Man is a problem. No man, no problem") and terrorizing everyone else. Now Marxism-Leninism is such a radical philosophy, and so whenever Marxist-Leninists come to power, they invariably resort to all these extreme measures. Yes it matters that they come to power generally through violent revolution. And yes it matters that they face military threats. But the heart of the matter is that they have ideological goals that can only be achieved by great violence against their people. And this means that the personality of the leader, like Lenin's ambition, is not what is key here. A leader who was basically a good person but believed in Marxism-Leninism would still have to follow similar policies. Most radical Islamic terrorists for instance, sincerely want to do what they think is good for the world, the problem is their ideology and what it clearly requires. One more point. Marxist-Leninist regimes differ in how extreme their ideologies are, and that considerably effects how violent they are. Now I apply all that to the case of the Pol Pot regime, and it was Marxist-Leninist, and so I think one could have predicted with certainty from the begining that it would be violent. And it had an extreme form of Marxism-Leninism, so one would expect it to be very high in violence. End part 1